Bernie probably gone after that hit on Daisy. Who comes in?

http://m.afl.com.au/video/2018-05-20/bernie-lines-up-daisy

No change, Bernie no case to answer.

3 minutes ago, Nasher said:

No change, Bernie no case to answer.

I dunno. High, left the ground to bump, past the ball... and then there is the Blue's medical report to contend with

He’s a lucky boy Bernie, he bumped and jumped whilst doing it and very surprisingly didn’t make contact with Daisy’s scone.

Surprised how quickly Daisy got up, thought he would have squibbed it looking for a free kick which also helps Bernie get off 

Unless there is an injury then it's no change.  These 22 players deserve to be rewarded for their efforts.

Bernie has no case to answer.  Got him up the middle and Thomas bounced straight up.

NO CHANGE

Peedo stiff

bernie didn’t get daisy high so he’ll be fine

Garlett for Spargo 

Hunt in for Vince if he gets rubbed out 

3 minutes ago, Mickey said:

I dunno. High, left the ground to bump, past the ball... and then there is the Blue's medical report to contend with

CFC MEDICAL REPORT.  Severe delayed concussion

NEXT WEEK. Daisy BOG

6 minutes ago, DemonLad5 said:

Garlett for Spargo 

Hunt in for Vince if he gets rubbed out 

In: Pedo

Out: Smith

6 minutes ago, DemonLad5 said:

Garlett for Spargo 

Hunt in for Vince if he gets rubbed out 

Not a chance. Hannan I could see, but not Spargo.

3 minutes ago, Chook said:

Not a chance. Hannan I could see, but not Spargo.

I was only able to watch the second half but Hannan was brillant, no way he’s going out, no changes for next week

1 minute ago, BrisbaneDemon said:

I was only able to watch the second half but Hannan was brillant, no way he’s going out, no changes for next week

He was no good when the game was up for grabs. Piled it on a bit when the head had gone out of it for sure.

No change you'd think

2 minutes ago, Chook said:

He was no good when the game was up for grabs. Piled it on a bit when the head had gone out of it for sure.

No change you'd think

You're a harsh judge on Hannan @Chook

VFL game was also impressive, and I think Pedo could come in for Smith to help Gawn in the ruck.

You can't ask Gawn to take as much of the ruck as he has been rucking in that heat. He will need some more help, and Pedo's engine isn't too bad.

Smith was Ok, I'm more thinking for team balance a second ruck is going to help in the heat.

Spargo just did enough, but could be due for the dreaded first year "rest" week. Bailey got it already, and Spargo might be rested.

Edited May 20, 20187 yr by Adzman

22 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Unless there is an injury then it's no change.  These 22 players deserve to be rewarded for their efforts.

Bernie has no case to answer.  Got him up the middle and Thomas bounced straight up.

Still, Bernie was a little out of sorts today and his kicking in from fullback was nerve wracking. Salem did some good things but could not handle the physicality very well - hung back a few times. Give Bernie a rest for a week; put in Pedo if this is the game plan we intend to persist with as it would suit his utility function in the forward line. Maybe, just maybe, bring in Hunt for Salem for one week of his own redemption - his pace is still needed. Garlett might be needed now that we have discovered deep forwards behind the defenders. 

Edited May 20, 20187 yr by Deemania since 56

12 minutes ago, Big Carl said:

In: Pedo

Out: Smith

Fully agree. Smith was good, three times. Pedo has more in that fwd utility role. 

I like what Bull Smith brings to the table...  18 disposals, 9 hitouts, 5 tackles, 2 shots on goal.  Whats the point of bringing in Pedersen who may or may not replicate Smiths numbers/impact?

NO CHANGE

Hard to drop anyone after that sort of win

No change would be nice

19 minutes ago, Big Carl said:

In: Pedo

Out: Smith

Why? 18 touches, 5 marks and 5 tackles plus 9 hitouts is more then Pedo will do. Plus Bull has some important knocks, tapons and spoils. Why drop a bloke after a great win for no reason?

No change but maybe a question mark over Bernard- looked a tad high to me

 

Then again those situations are a raffle!

No change massive game next week. Really with Adelaides outs we should expect to win this one as well. 8 point game

23 minutes ago, Big Carl said:

In: Pedo

Out: Smith

No way. As I said in the post match, Smith did a number of contest killers that resulted in goals that should have been easy Carlton marks.

Looked right at home for me. Pedersen is unlucky after his VFL performance, but there are no vacancies in the team for him.

If it ain't broke ...

3 v 4 in the Alice   just WOW!!!! cant wait. 

Big test but the DEES have arrived 

43 minutes ago, Nasher said:

No change, Bernie no case to answer.

Regardless of the MRP, Bernie should still have a case to answer for dabbing a kick inboard from the defensive pocket to a one-on-two 40m out straight in front. I saw it all unfold before it even happened and I'm no prophet.