WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - HARLEY BALIC

[RalphiusMaximus 6,046]

This is a great deal. Balic can move when he's fit and more importantly he's a decent kick. For a junk pick it's really good value. Don't be surprised if he moves ahead of Stretch in the pecking order.

[leucopogon 1,519]

1 hour ago, P-man said:

If he's half as good as Freo fans on BF claim he is then we've got ourselves a bargain.

My best mate who's a diehard Docker rates the kid really highly and is spewing to see him leave. Reckon we might have a player on our hands. Also like the one year contract, he'll need to buy in and contribute straight away, no more armchair rides at the Dees!

[hillie 41]

2 hours ago, mo64 said:

 

2 hours ago, Bay Riffin said:

Jack Fitzpatrick. it was seriously average.

You read my mind. His "highlights package" actually showed him missing a goal from 2 metres out.

 

I Laughed watching his u/18 carnival cos he was so hopeless I was certain if there’s one player I don’t want it was him. Sure enough...

[Siren 156]

Harley talking a bit about the homesickness and being traded:

http://www.aflplayers.com.au/article/qa-harley-balic/

Edited October 18, 2017 by Siren

[hillie 41]

2 hours ago, Unleash Hell said:

Maybe youd care to explain how we'd get a higher pick out of port which they didn't have? 

Maybe not higher than 31. But could of upgraded 47 or even 36. Look foolish if our desired player goes one pick earlier. Mahoney has stated that it was easier. His responsibility is to get the best deal for the club and us members. 

Mahoneys negotiation skills are horrible. He’s mastered the lose- win outcome of negotiation. 

If Mahoney was a hostage negotiator they’d all be dead and the guy would be sunning it up on a tropical island.

[Lord Ivanhoe 311]

40 minutes ago, leucopogon said:

My best mate who's a diehard Docker rates the kid really highly and is spewing to see him leave. Reckon we might have a player on our hands. Also like the one year contract, he'll need to buy in and contribute straight away, no more armchair rides at the Dees!

Now he is home & surrounded by his support group, real chance he may really start to grow. Love it. Hope! It sells!!!!

[daisycutter 29,612]

22 minutes ago, hillie said:

.....

If Mahoney was a hostage negotiator they’d all be dead and the guy would be sunning it up on a tropical island.

so, all afl trade managers need to do a course in hostage negotiation - lmao

[Vogon Poetry 2,095]

1 hour ago, leucopogon said:

My best mate who's a diehard Docker rates the kid really highly and is spewing to see him leave. Reckon we might have a player on our hands. Also like the one year contract, he'll need to buy in and contribute straight away, no more armchair rides at the Dees!

Saw the same comment when we got Michie.

Hope your mate is a good judge and I welcome Harley to the club but I'll wait and see how he goes on game day before I get too excited.

[Lord Travis 10,727]

Love he said his aim is to play afl seniors in round 1 2018. Didn’t give an answer about building up or consistency or anything, he’s said he’s gonna train hard and aim for round 1. Love the confidence. 

This kid has talent and could wind up a good player for us. Definitely feel he is more talented than a lot of depth we’ve had the last few years.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

55 minutes ago, hillie said:

Maybe not higher than 31. But could of upgraded 47 or even 36. Look foolish if our desired player goes one pick earlier. Mahoney has stated that it was easier. His responsibility is to get the best deal for the club and us members. 

Mahoneys negotiation skills are horrible. He’s mastered the lose- win outcome of negotiation. 

If Mahoney was a hostage negotiator they’d all be dead and the guy would be sunning it up on a tropical island.

In fairness, at least he executes i.e. he gets the deals done.

No use being Captain Scrooge only to see some rival club land the player we wanted.

We're probably seen as being a reasonable club to deal with too, which has its benefits.

 

[1964nowMORE 488]

Coached in 2018 by his U18 coach whom he excelled with - Plapp in the Demons midfield. I like it. Is he better at the same age than Kane Lambert? That's the comparison I'm looking at.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,816]

Can someone direct me to the "GET EXCITED HARLEY BALIC" video on afl.com? 

[buck_nekkid 5,852]

1 hour ago, hillie said:

Maybe not higher than 31. But could of upgraded 47 or even 36. Look foolish if our desired player goes one pick earlier. Mahoney has stated that it was easier. His responsibility is to get the best deal for the club and us members. 

Mahoneys negotiation skills are horrible. He’s mastered the lose- win outcome of negotiation. 

If Mahoney was a hostage negotiator they’d all be dead and the guy would be sunning it up on a tropical island.

Really?  How do you judge that his negotiating skills are horrible when you have NO IDEA what his desired outcome, or minimal negotiating position, actually is?  It is not life and death, FMD!  He is not a hostage negotiator.  I would prefer that the Dees are known as decent to deal with - the first step in building trust to establishing a frame for negotiation.

you slag him off and have not one f’ing clue.

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

1 hour ago, hillie said:

Maybe not higher than 31. But could of upgraded 47 or even 36. Look foolish if our desired player goes one pick earlier. Mahoney has stated that it was easier. His responsibility is to get the best deal for the club and us members. 

Mahoneys negotiation skills are horrible. He’s mastered the lose- win outcome of negotiation. 

If Mahoney was a hostage negotiator they’d all be dead and the guy would be sunning it up on a tropical island.

I dont know how you can pass such a harsh judgement without having intimate knowledge of the negotiations.

So you eithet have no idea or are just bitter.

In your analysis have you considered any of the following other factors? 

Ports position

Jacks position Jacks management position? Because jacks manger also manages orher key mfc players

Continued good relationship with Jack and his management?

The ability ti get the Deal done? How many trades are in limbo due to poor negotiations at other clubs?

 

I know you haven't and this conversation is a waste of time. Your position and arguement on Mahoney shows you have no idea.

End

 

Edited October 18, 2017 by Unleash Hell

[binman 42,862]

6 hours ago, Travis16 said:

Sorry I missed the sarcasm ? 

Hence my joke

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

40 minutes ago, Ron Burgundy said:

In fairness, at least he executes i.e. he gets the deals done.

No use being Captain Scrooge only to see some rival club land the player we wanted.

We're probably seen as being a reasonable club to deal with too, which has its benefits.

 

Agree. Look at the news on the gibbs trade.

Id rather Mahonet who gets the job done then squabble over late picks.

Seems a waste

Ive been harsh to a few on this thread but people need to move on from crap they don't agree with and don't understand.

And anyone who thinks it's only Mahoneys decision alone also falls in to that boat above as being dumb

Edited October 18, 2017 by Unleash Hell
Sorry maye i ended up ranting haha

[Siren 156]

24 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Can someone direct me to the "GET EXCITED HARLEY BALIC" video on afl.com? 

Hopefully this works:

https://t.co/0xiZqgugFw

[monoccular 17,418]

10 minutes ago, Siren said:

Hopefully this works:

https://t.co/0xiZqgugFw

Mmmmmm.  Does a few good things against the Dees ..... hope he can learn the opposite ?

[jnrmac 20,058]

1 hour ago, Vogon Poetry said:

Saw the same comment when we got Michie.

Hope your mate is a good judge and I welcome Harley to the club but I'll wait and see how he goes on game day before I get too excited.

He played 5 more games for Freo than Michie!

[SFebes 4,884]

42 minutes ago, Siren said:

Hopefully this works:

https://t.co/0xiZqgugFw

Hits too many targets for my liking

[Lord Travis 10,727]

51 minutes ago, Siren said:

Hopefully this works:

https://t.co/0xiZqgugFw

Love where he keeps the ball alive by bumping his opponent over the line the gathering the ball and firing off a quick handless to a teammate. Also love how he smothered the ball over the line to lock it in their forward line and prevent the rebound. He's got footy smarts and goes when it's his turn. 

[Dee Zephyr 19,267]

8 minutes ago, SFebey said:

Hits too many targets for my liking

Lol, in that clip he certainly did.

Not a bad goal either against us, just trying to determine if it was his nifty footwork or the magnificent attempt to tackle him that created that goal.

[Vogon Poetry 2,095]

47 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

He played 5 more games for Freo than Michie!

You must be counting practice matches!

[faultydet 7,594]

1 hour ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Can someone direct me to the "GET EXCITED HARLEY BALIC" video on afl.com? 

I saw it.

It's a video of his mum with Josh Mahoney in a headlock at the trade table.

[Jibroni 5,002]

I think he will be ok. He has had a horror start to his career, but from what I have heard from my mates in Perth he can seriously play. Happy to have him on board!