WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - STEVEN MAY

[Lucifers Hero 37,173]

5 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

My memory might be hazy, but did we really let Frawley and Howe go, or did they decide to leave?  I know that we netted pick #3 for Frawley when he left, but I can recall us trying to re-sign him throughout the year.  Howe wanted out so there wasn't a whole lot we could do there.

As I recall it Roos switched Frawley fwd, to settle a new defence, as soon as he realised Frawley wasn't putting in the effort (see 2014, round 2 vs WCE) much like Clarkson did with Buddy(played him up the ground).  I don't recall discussion of an mfc offer.  I recall he went to WA to talk to Freo.

Edited September 29, 2018 by Lucifer's Hero

[Wiseblood 24,636]

2 minutes ago, Danelska said:

My memory was that Roos played him forward for the entire year...not to test others out, but to ensure our back line could learn to play without him... it was so effing obvious from round 3....

You're possibly right.  I think I've blocked a few years from my memory.

[Binmans PA 26,248]

27 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Today proved and showed today why its important to have genuine high talent defenders.

McGovern and Barrass won them the game today.

Their mids stood up too. That cannot be underplayed.

[Gator 16,893]

3 minutes ago, A F said:

Is May an elite defender though? Happy to have him, but he's certainly (for me) not in the same class as McGovern.

He's very good.  How many McGoverns do you think there are ?

Also, how do you think McGovern would have fared playing for years in Gold Coasts defence ?

But, as usual, players at other clubs are crap, and players at Melbourne are great.  Is that how it works ?

[Gator 16,893]

7 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Why May???

We have two very good key backs and Lever is back in 2019

we need outside pace

we need a Kelly Shiel or Gaff

now one is gettable

Well, if you're right then the MFC won't chase May.

But of course, you're not right, are you ?  Are you ever ?

[Binmans PA 26,248]

28 minutes ago, ProDee said:

He's very good.  How many McGoverns do you think there are ?

Also, how do you think McGovern would have fared playing for years in Gold Coasts defence ?

But, as usual, players at other clubs are crap, and players at Melbourne are great.  Is that how it works ?

That's not what I said at all. But you intimated May was elite and I disagree. That's all.

[Gator 16,893]

6 minutes ago, A F said:

That's not what I said at all. But you intimated May was elite and I disagree. That's all.

Elite, very good - they're just words.

He's far better than what we have.  He'd immediately be our best key defender.  Nothing to sneeze at.

Jetta  McDonald  Lever

Salem  May  Hibberd

Looks pretty good to me.

[SFebes 4,692]

May is a decent upgrade on OMAC and Frost and we need it. Lever coming back will start to look half decent, just hoping we can shuffle Lewis out of there also.

[Binmans PA 26,248]

26 minutes ago, ProDee said:

Elite, very good - they're just words.

He's far better than what we have.  He'd immediately be our best key defender.  Nothing to sneeze at.

Jetta  McDonald  Lever

Salem  May  Hibberd

Looks pretty good to me.

They are just words, but they do have relevance to the conversation, otherwise we'd use different words.

He's a good player and would make us better. And I'd agree he'd be ahead of Lever as best one-on-one defender, but I'd argue Lever is the better player for his role. But, it's about them complimenting each other and improving our list. May is certainly a better player than OMac or Frost, so we've got a significant upgrade there.

Sounds like he's coming, which is great news.

FWIW, I'd play May deeper and get OMac at CHF, but agree with the rest.

[Binmans PA 26,248]

29 minutes ago, SFebes said:

May is a decent upgrade on OMAC and Frost and we need it. Lever coming back will start to look half decent, just hoping we can shuffle Lewis out of there also.

I think you'll find Lewis and Jones will be competing for the same spot next season.

Interesting that Salem, May and Hibberd are all left footers. We've really gone hard for those left footers in recent year. They're coming out of our ears these days.

[Engorged Onion 9,380]

1 minute ago, A F said:

I think you'll find Lewis and Jones will be competing for the same spot next season.

Interesting that Salem, May and Hibberd are all left footers. We've really gone hard for those left footers in recent year. They're coming out of our ears these days.

I'm a left footer, and my father always said it was an advantage in my junior days... (which was true, in the way you naturally turn) alas i am late 30's and like a drink

(cool story bro ?)

Edited September 29, 2018 by Danelska

[DV8 2,271]

On 9/27/2018 at 12:32 AM, Dee tention said:

Firstly, I would not trade for May. I would prefer to keep Frost and O Mac. We will have Lever back next season and we should be looking at another key backman that won’t cost the world...

If the Dees receive Picks 5 & 6 from Freo for Hogan. Gold Coast will receive say Pick 6  for May. This is definitely way overs in my book. If this was to happen I believe we have to get Pick 18 from GC also...

May & Pick 18 = Pick 6

Collingwood who are also interested in May have Pick 17.

I'd be OK with that scenario, P5 & 6 for Hogan. 

Then P6 & our 2ndRnd pick to GCS's,  for May, P18 &  Kolidasnij.

[Engorged Onion 9,380]

For those packaging up KK and May, I would put KK as a seperate conversation to May as KK is not a required player from their perspective.

[Gator 16,893]

6 minutes ago, A F said:

They are just words, but they do have relevance to the conversation, otherwise we'd use different words.

He's a good player and would make us better. And I'd agree he'd be ahead of Lever as best one-on-one defender, but I'd argue Lever is the better player for his role. But, it's about them complimenting each other and improving our list. May is certainly a better player than OMac or Frost, so we've got a significant upgrade there.

Sounds like he's coming, which is great news.

FWIW, I'd play May deeper and get OMac at CHF, but agree with the rest.

When I said key defender I wasn't including Lever, who I see as the intercept king.  Lever is our no.1 defender and May would be no.2.  As good as Lever is I don't see a flag if we have to rely on McDonald, Frost or Petty.  But I do with May.  It changes everything.

Oscar isn't quick and has always played the FB role.  May is quick, so I named him at CHB.

But I'm not fussed, as they all rotate their opponents.

[Binmans PA 26,248]

32 minutes ago, Danelska said:

I'm a left footer, and my father always said it was an advantage in my junior days... (which was true, in the way you naturally turn) alas i am late 30's and like a drink

(cool story bro ?)

I was a left footer too. My old man always said my height would be handy. Haha. It was in the under 12s.

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

Just a quick reminder that Oscar and Frost will not be premiership defenders in the same side.

[Binmans PA 26,248]

26 minutes ago, stevethemanjordan said:

Just a quick reminder that Oscar and Frost will not be premiership defenders in the same side.

I agree, but I don't think it helps when your midfield goes missing (ie last week).

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

Sure it doesn't, but West Coast were under immense pressure early and those two still stood up.

May is a must. Physically imposing key backs are a must. 

[DV8 2,271]

On 9/28/2018 at 9:39 AM, FarNorthernD said:

Thanks for the info Jane. I must admit I don’t understand the need.

Trading May in will require us to spend a fair bit of the capital we get from any Hogan trade, in terms of salary cap and picks, on yet another key defender (Lever, Frost, O Mac, Petty, Keilty) 

Yes May would improve our back six to a degree but at significant cost. 

Oscar is very young for the main man back. not strong enough yet.

Lever is not a Key Tall Back, but moreso the 3rd tall intercept.  and has had 2 Knee Reco's.

Frost is a risky limited backman.

Petty and Keilty are both Kids, so far as big Defenders go.

So IMO, May is ideally placed for us, Re his maturity, experience & age bracket.  It covers the other defenders on our list fairdeewell.

 

.

[Deemania since 56 6,176]

1 hour ago, Danelska said:

Personally, I don't think he is pretty enough to fit into our culture...

Can he juggle a nice French brie with his wineglass of Grange 68? Does he have his Range Rover Sports V8 parked in the Members? If not, too bad. He fits the bill perfectly.

[Deemania since 56 6,176]

1 hour ago, Danelska said:

Personally, I don't think he is pretty enough to fit into our culture...

We have to put these sentiments aside; Ray Biffen wasn't pretty, either. But hell, he could rough 'em up well for a few years there. 

[dieter 3,325]

41 minutes ago, Danelska said:

I'm a left footer, and my father always said it was an advantage in my junior days... (which was true, in the way you naturally turn) alas i am late 30's and like a drink

(cool story bro ?)

Do you drink with your left foot or the right? 

[Deemania since 56 6,176]

17 minutes ago, DV8 said:

Oscar is very young for the main man back. not strong enough yet.

Lever is not a Key Tall Back, but moreso the 3rd tall intercept.  and has had 2 Knee Reco's.

Frost is a risky limited backman.

Petty and Keilty are both Kids, so far as big Defenders go.

So IMO, May is ideally placed for us, Re his maturity, experience & age bracket.  It covers the other defenders on our list fairdeewell.

 

.

Frosty is aware of his style and weaknesses, and has improved 3 of these in just a couple of months. With a good pre-season, I'd reckon that the FD can sort him out, just fine. Frosty is a playmaker, and a very big asset down back that will turn the final two corners with focussed coaching. It would appear that he will achieve this heightened mastery in quick time, too.

[dazzledavey36 48,901]

37 minutes ago, stevethemanjordan said:

Just a quick reminder that Oscar and Frost will not be premiership defenders in the same side.

Oscar no, Frost yes.

I dont and never have rated Oscar, i dont see what he adds to the side besides being tall. May brings experience and a hardened body down back. Today he would have taken Kennedy and i would backed him in to get the job done.

Frost at least has elite speed and dash that we desperately need put of our backline. May and Lever qould cover him for his disposal and skill.

[Ugottobekidding 915]

May is overrated