POST MATCH DISCUSSION - Round 6

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

10 minutes ago, JV7 said:

Thought Vince was a lot better moving into the midfield in the 2nd half. It's were he should have been playing all along & should stay there. 

Vince is the kind of player that makes Viney better.

Viney needs bigger bodies around him, no coincidence he had a great third quarter when this happened.

[Webber 10,570]

I thought this might be the game after which Demonland gave rightful praise to Tom McDonald. I now realise that's never going to happen. Those people who continually (zzzzzzzzzzz........) criticise him for his imperfections are clearly unaware that the football world at large sees him as one of our most important players, our most important backmen, and one of the league's best. He got media votes today, but still gets shamelessly and pathetically pilloried on Demonland. 

[Young Blood 2,638]

Vince

I think the move to put Bernie, Jones and Lewis in the middle for periods in the second half really steadied us and took some of the pressure off the young guys.

But I still think Vince plays a key role down back and allows Lewis to do more damage up the ground. He has been caught out playing deep in defence but I think he's much more effective as a high halfback/wing while rolling through the middle when we're needing some obvious clearances.

Tyson

I think Dom plays his role well most weeks. Showed today his ability to receive the ball from the in tight contest (from Viney/Oliver mostly) and release the ball for the clearance. He works really well as the outside mid. If he rotates this role with Salem and Lewis we should continue to see it work well.

[DemonOX 8,823]

For the love of god can someone teach TMac how to kick. 

Some of his kicks were horrific. 

[Webber 10,570]

1 minute ago, DemonOX said:

For the love of god can someone teach TMac how to kick. 

Some of his kicks were horrific. 

Tell me why all the game's commentators (TV and radio) thought he had a great game? What are your thoughts? 

[Gorgoroth 13,144]

3 minutes ago, Webber said:

I thought this might be the game after which Demonland gave rightful praise to Tom McDonald. I now realise that's never going to happen. Those people who continually (zzzzzzzzzzz........) criticise him for his imperfections are clearly unaware that the football world at large sees him as one of our most important players, our most important backmen, and one of the league's best. He got media votes today, but still gets shamelessly and pathetically pilloried on Demonland. 

Tmac's biggest problem is he tries to do things he just ain't capable of which is why it is so frustrating. He tries very hard kicks and quite often at times when he shouldn't.

[Webber 10,570]

1 minute ago, Gorgoroth said:

Tmac's biggest problem is he tries to do things he just ain't capable of which is why it is so frustrating. He tries very hard kicks and quite often at times when he shouldn't.

No kidding. And yet he is vitally important to us and an excellent footballer. Try getting your head around that, because he is what he is, he's improving still, and no doubt trying to get even better. Or is that still not good enough? 

[picket fence 17,754]

1 hour ago, Gorgoroth said:

Did he? Did not notice that. 

Anyone that Reckons ANB tagging Heppel a great move, Well I reckon Heppel was the bombers best!! By Far!

[Biffen 12,949]

Tom Mc pulled off some lovely spoils today .

Stopped any chance Frost had of marking cleanly.

[Lucifers Hero 40,489]

2 minutes ago, Webber said:

Tell me why all the game's commentators (TV and radio) thought he had a great game? What are your thoughts? 

You may as well give up 'Webber'.  Some people can't see past their biases or past a few clangers which all players have.  Even today's hero, Pedobear (whom I love) had 8.

I couldn't see the game but heard on ABC that at the start of the 3rd qtr we had 7 in defence and T McD was the 'spare'.  He almost immediately kicked a goal.  Not quite a momentum turning piece of play but really significant for the game.  T Mc more than did his job today. 

I might add putting Frost on Daniher for the game and freeing T Mac was a bit of coaching masterstroke.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

3 minutes ago, Webber said:

No kidding. And yet he is vitally important to us and an excellent footballer. Try getting your head around that, because he is what he is, he's improving still, and no doubt trying to get even better. Or is that still not good enough? 

Webber - no doubt he gets potted more than he should on here.  When he is on he is one of the better defenders in the league.  He reads the play well, backs himself and is rarely beaten one on one.

His decision making, though, leaves a little to be desired which I'm sure you would agree with.  A few times today his kicking really let him down and sometimes he needs to just go with the safer option, but is no different to many others who made glaring errors.  I agree that we should look at his positives more often, but he also gives reason for negatives as well.

[faultydet 7,623]

8 minutes ago, Webber said:

Tell me why all the game's commentators (TV and radio) thought he had a great game? What are your thoughts? 

Mate, he can still have a great game AND butcher some of his kicks.

You are coming across as quite a know it all.

 

If he could kick properly, he would be an all Australian starter every year.

[faultydet 7,623]

1 minute ago, Wiseblood said:

Webber - no doubt he gets potted more than he should on here.  When he is on he is one of the better defenders in the league.  He reads the play well, backs himself and is rarely beaten one on one.

His decision making, though, leaves a little to be desired which I'm sure you would agree with.  A few times today his kicking really let him down and sometimes he needs to just go with the safer option, but is no different to many others who made glaring errors.  I agree that we should look at his positives more often, but he also gives reason for negatives as well.

.....should have just quoted this......

[praha 11,241]

14 minutes ago, Webber said:

I thought this might be the game after which Demonland gave rightful praise to Tom McDonald. I now realise that's never going to happen. Those people who continually (zzzzzzzzzzz........) criticise him for his imperfections are clearly unaware that the football world at large sees him as one of our most important players, our most important backmen, and one of the league's best. He got media votes today, but still gets shamelessly and pathetically pilloried on Demonland. 

He's ranked the second best key defender behind Rance. His bro will join him soon. Just watch.

[dimmy 1,308]

Every footballer has some imperfections. TMacs good points far outweigh his weaknesses. DO you reckon the type of person he is would not be working on those issues. At least he is trying to set things up. I have criticism for Tyson who seems to "Bomb"at first instance.

If we had 20 Tmacs we would be unbeatable (even with his occasional kicking lapses).

Ther are a lot of clubs who o9wuld gladly trade for him !!!!!  So be pleased he is with us.

Umpiring : Disgusting and inconsistent both ways !!! They are confused with all the grey areas of the game.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,368]

Haven't seen the game yet as had my nephew's christening today - bloody wrapt we won this one and convincingly! Can't wait to watch the replay.

Seasons back on track

[Sigil 1,001]

1 minute ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

Haven't seen the game yet as had my nephew's christening today - bloody wrapt we won this one and convincingly! Can't wait to watch the replay.

Seasons back on track

Don't watch the first half.

[Webber 10,570]

Just now, faultydet said:

Mate, he can still have a great game AND butcher some of his kicks.

You are coming across as quite a know it all.

 

If he could kick properly, he would be an all Australian starter every year.

And you're just one more to state the obvious. Which has been stated and restated, again and again, incessantly. We all know his limitations, but if you just got your info from that's all he would have. Plain truth, or too know it all? 

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,950]

18 minutes ago, Webber said:

I thought this might be the game after which Demonland gave rightful praise to Tom McDonald. I now realise that's never going to happen. Those people who continually (zzzzzzzzzzz........) criticise him for his imperfections are clearly unaware that the football world at large sees him as one of our most important players, our most important backmen, and one of the league's best. He got media votes today, but still gets shamelessly and pathetically pilloried on Demonland. 

We should also give credit to the selectors. Playing Oscar may have been a surprise* but playing Oscar and Frost on Hooker and Daniher respectively freed Tom up. 

(*I had assumed Oscar had been picked for Frost to play in the ruck.)

[faultydet 7,623]

1 minute ago, Webber said:

And you're just one more to state the obvious. Which has been stated and restated, again and again, incessantly. We all know his limitations, but if you just got your info from that's all he would have. Plain truth, or too know it all? 

And you are whiny and juvenile.

 

People are free to criticise, obvious or not.

It's only a problem when they are plainly wrong, which in this case, they are not.

[Webber 10,570]

Obviously personal attacks make you feel better, so be it. Do you think TMac has any qualities, and if so, what are they? 

[Lucifers Hero 40,489]

There were a few positional changes at half time:  Vince, Mcdonald etc

Another was that Petracca took Hurley who had thrashed us in the 1st half,  away from the play and stop him intercepting.  I think he had only 4 marks in the 2nd half.

Virtually all Goodwin's moves worked.

Goodwin comprehensively outcoached Worsfold!

[Satyriconhome 10,880]

1 minute ago, faultydet said:

And you are whiny and juvenile.

 

People are free to criticise, obvious or not.

It's only a problem when they are plainly wrong, which in this case, they are not.

It just becomes tedious, I take my own advice and have to not read half the posts in a thread when I see who is posting

All players have faults

[Chook 15,022]

8 minutes ago, dimmy said:

Every footballer has some imperfections. TMacs good points far outweigh his weaknesses. DO you reckon the type of person he is would not be working on those issues. At least he is trying to set things up. I have criticism for Tyson who seems to "Bomb"at first instance.

If we had 20 Tmacs we would be unbeatable (even with his occasional kicking lapses).

Ther are a lot of clubs who o9wuld gladly trade for him !!!!!  So be pleased he is with us.

Umpiring : Disgusting and inconsistent both ways !!! They are confused with all the grey areas of the game.

If we had 20 Tom McDonalds, Melksham and JKH would still let us down.

[beelzebub 23,388]

21 minutes ago, Webber said:

I thought this might be the game after which Demonland gave rightful praise to Tom McDonald. I now realise that's never going to happen. Those people who continually (zzzzzzzzzzz........) criticise him for his imperfections are clearly unaware that the football world at large sees him as one of our most important players, our most important backmen, and one of the league's best. He got media votes today, but still gets shamelessly and pathetically pilloried on Demonland. 

Webber. I dont give a flying f what the media/footyworld/ or anyone here or there thinks or writes about football ( or much else )

I watch, observe and consider after as a result. T Mac took some excellent marks and executed some great defence. He also often executed his team mates with sloppy kicking and poor decisions.

How he manages , after all this time , to masacre elementary tasks still bewilders me.

I dont know how he fixes this, Should have done so by now for mine.

Arguably our most frustrating player.