Changes vs Carlton

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,755]

1 minute ago, DemonLad5 said:

I'd like to think Salem would give more output off half back than Harmes

I don't know how many games you need to play in the VFL to play finals but it's sort of weird to think that the decision about Salem might be influenced by the possibility of Melbourne and Casey both playing finals.

[SPC 3,549]

It was a great result after the Port game, because we had quite a few guys who didn't play well, yet managed a big win away.. Got an 8 day break, so no change for this week.

All the guys who were off a little against Port, such as Stretch, Viney, Hogan etc will play well against the blues.. 

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

At some stage we need Salem's skill in the team, the only players I can see making way would be Harmes, Bugg or vandenBerg,

Garlett's two goals at the end will keep him in the side (they were incredibly important in the scheme of things) but ANB, JKH and Kennedy are all putting pressure on that small forward position.

I like Pedersen in the team because of the structure he provides and as much as I want Weideman back in (he's pure class) I can't see a change here. Hogan needs to sort himself out. On a side note, why does Hogan always wear a jumper about three sizes too big for him? He must be the easiest player in the team to tackle because of this.

Sadly, any inclusion of Grimes, M. Jones, Dawes, Trengove (maybe), Dunn or Garland would be a step backwards.

In summary, I have no idea which changes should or will be made this week.

[SPC 3,549]

3 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

I don't know how many games you need to play in the VFL to play finals but it's sort of weird to think that the decision about Salem might be influenced by the possibility of Melbourne and Casey both playing finals.

I think if you come off a minor injury, then 2-3 weeks at Casey should be enough to build on fitness base and sharpen skills.. This guy from all reports lost 5kg's and had all his energy drained.. He should just continue to build fitness and form at Casey I think.

[Diamond_Jim 12,588]

1 minute ago, Clint Bizkit said:

At some stage we need Salem's skill in the team, the only players I can see making way would be Harmes, Bugg or vandenBerg,

Garlett's two goals at the end will keep him in the side (they were incredibly important in the scheme of things) but ANB, JKH and Kennedy are all putting pressure on that small forward position.

I like Pedersen in the team because of the structure he provides and as much as I want Weideman back in (he's pure class) I can't see a change here. Hogan needs to sort himself out. On a side note, why does Hogan always wear a jumper about three sizes too big for him? He must be the easiest player in the team to tackle because of this.

Sadly, any inclusion of Grimes, M. Jones, Dawes, Trengove (maybe), Dunn or Garland would be a step backwards.

In summary, I have no idea which changes should or will be made this week.

Good post

If at all possible we should include Salem this week but otherwise no change

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

No change, unless for soreness or injury.

Need to reward the players for continuing to perform.

Pedo played his role, and thats all we can ask from him. Weids won't crash packs and bring the ball to ground, like pedo does, and we need that to help get Jeffy G and others into the game. Hogan needs a big week this week, looks out of sorts lately and not enjoying his footy much.

Really loving the role Watts is playing now, he has the swagger we always hoped he'd find.

[Akum 2,660]

10 hours ago, KrazyJay said:

ANB is the one that I am not certain of his position in the team... I think he needs a run of more than 1 or 2 in a row for us to see exactly where he sits at the top level...

Was in good spirits during the warm up... On the boundary giving $hit to Bugg when he was having shots... 

I think he offers more than just being a fringe player and I for one hope that he has a ripping pre-season and breaks his way into the side on a more permanent basis...

Clubs need players like ANB to keep others on their toes!

Wasn't it ANB who came back to preseason from the break in less than ideal condition? Or am I mixing him up with someone else?

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,755]

9 minutes ago, Akum said:

Wasn't it ANB who came back to preseason from the break in less than ideal condition? Or am I mixing him up with someone else?

Colin Sylvia?

(I would have been correct most years...)

[SPC 3,549]

21 minutes ago, Akum said:

Wasn't it ANB who came back to preseason from the break in less than ideal condition? Or am I mixing him up with someone else?

From memory, the reports stated that about 5-6 players were in this category, so you could be right.. I remember Gartlett was one of them..

[The Sailing Demon 379]

Pedo stays in.
Hogan has a good long hard look at himself and realises he hasn't kicked a goal in over a month of footy.
Jeffy would be my only omission and it's a stretch...perhaps bring in BK for him based on form.

Very hard to change a winning formula.
I would love to see Wiedeman in but baring injury I just don't know who we drop for a 1 gamer in what is considered a pressure game considering we are still playing for our season.

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

Salem and Weed-man would be my ins but as the overwhelming majority have said, it's hard to see who comes out.

Last game of the year at the G and what should be pumped up as a final goodbye to Roos from MFC supporters, it would be fitting to see Hogan and the Weed lining up at CHF and FF. A real sign of the future. Carlton are pretty light on in terms of KP players unlike Geelong and with Weitering a bit sore after the weekend, this would be the game you'd play them in.

Pedo would be mighty stiff if that eventuated however.

And I have no idea who'd come out for Salem. But I always feel safe when the ball is in his hands at the back half of the ground. (As opposed to many of his team-mates).

Whatever the case, it's just a really nice to not see this on paper anymore:

(Round 1 three years ago)

B        Lynden Dunn       Tom Gillies             Daniel Nicholson

HB      Jack Watts         James Frawley           Colin Garland

C        Jack Viney           Jack Grimes            Jimmy Toumpas 

HF     Jeremy Howe       James Sellar             Colin Sylvia

F      Shannon Byrnes      Mitch Clark        Cameron Pederson

 

FOL    Mark Jamar        Jordie McKenzie         Nathan Jones

 

I/C     Matt Jones          David Rodan               Luke Tapscott

SUB    Sam Blease

 

Edit: Only four of those names feature in our current best 22 side.

Edited August 15, 2016 by stevethemanjordan

[The Backyard Charizard 1,202]

6 minutes ago, stevethemanjordan said:

 

(Round 1 three years ago)

B        Lynden Dunn       Tom Gillies             Daniel Nicholson

HB      Jack Watts         James Frawley           Colin Garland

C        Jack Viney           Jack Grimes            Jimmy Toumpas 

HF     Jeremy Howe       James Sellar             Colin Sylvia

F      Shannon Byrnes      Mitch Clark        Cameron Pederson

 

FOL    Mark Jamar        Jordie McKenzie         Nathan Jones

 

I/C     Matt Jones          David Rodan               Luke Tapscott

SUB    Sam Blease

 

OUCH!!!

MY EYES!!!!!!!!!

How were we not premiers that year??

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

3 minutes ago, KrazyJay said:

How were we not premiers that year??

Injuries and umpires basically.

 

.....

 

...

 

.........

 

What?

Edited August 15, 2016 by stevethemanjordan

[The Backyard Charizard 1,202]

1 minute ago, stevethemanjordan said:

Injuries and umpires basically.

Aaahhhh....

I thought it was #$hittestListEver

I forgot about #FreeKickHawthorn

Apologies 

[Woodyy 26]

Jeff garlett is on crutches battling a skin infection, so there could be a reasonable chance that he wont lineup this week, meaning ben kenedy would most likely take his place in that small forward role. Wouldn't mind seeing jkh or anb playing the role though, in saying that though if we are battling for finals (which we are atm) this is not the time to be experimenting, therefore we have to play kenedy.

Edited August 15, 2016 by Woodyy

[DubDee 25,865]

1 hour ago, jnrmac said:

Actually we had a number of poor players. Harmes, VBD, Viney (who was well tagged) and Hogan. Pederson was just serviceable and Watts was well below best. Petracca had little impact as well. Kent only had one tackle and made a couple of huge blunders.

There is a lot of improvement and our side didn't play well IMO. Very happy to win away against a very physical side but I think you are off the money with your comment. I can see Harmes, VDB or Pederson making way.

 

agree to disagree.   those guys didnt star but weren't lacking effort.  

Pedos presence and contest in the air was good - its important to have a big, seasoned body in the fwd line.

Harmes and VDB played their role and have some runs on the board as far as their application to the contest goes. VDB 6 tackles, 5 score involvement, 2 assists did okay IMO and Harmes was good last week.

[brendan 3,437]

If garlett is out then give JKH A go 

[The Backyard Charizard 1,202]

I am going early and saying....

OUT : Jeffy & Harmes

IN : JKH & Matt Jones

We will run the absolute pants off Carlscum on the weekend!

[The Sailing Demon 379]

http://www.carltonsc.com/index.php?topic=3058.0

Do yourselves a favour and go into the Carlton pre game thread.

They are shaking in their boots about having to front up to us.

"We need 2 ruckmen to even think about breaking even with Gawn" was my personal favourite.

Also to note, Cripps and Weitering carrying injuries into this game.

Edited August 15, 2016 by The Sailing Demon
link fix

[jnrmac 20,065]

7 minutes ago, DubDee said:

agree to disagree.   those guys didnt star but weren't lacking effort.  

Pedos presence and contest in the air was good - its important to have a big, seasoned body in the fwd line.

Harmes and VDB played their role and have some runs on the board as far as their application to the contest goes. VDB 6 tackles, 5 score involvement, 2 assists did okay IMO and Harmes was good last week.

I agree with the effort. They all tried hard for four quarters.

But they did play poorly. VDB worries me. Had one really good game against Gold Coast and a number of poor ones. Harmes also did well against Hawthorn but has had anumber of poor ones. Kent had some shocking turnovers but was involved in a lot of play

[stuie 7,374]

Garlett quite possibly out...

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-08-15/melbourne-forward-jeff-garlett-on-crutches-as-he-battles-skin-infection

 

[ickey_11 145]

If Garlett is out with the skin infection, then I think JHK will get a run.

 

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

1 hour ago, ickey_11 said:

If Garlett is out with the skin infection, then I think JHK will get a run.

 

 

1 hour ago, stuie said:

Garlett quite possibly out...

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-08-15/melbourne-forward-jeff-garlett-on-crutches-as-he-battles-skin-infection

 

What a bizarre injury.

Edited August 15, 2016 by Clint Bizkit

[The Sailing Demon 379]

7 minutes ago, stuie said:

Garlett quite possibly out...

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-08-15/melbourne-forward-jeff-garlett-on-crutches-as-he-battles-skin-infection

 

JKH/BK/ANB

Who do we choose mate?

[The Sailing Demon 379]

2 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

 

What a bizarre injury,

I would expect nothing less from trudging around in the filth of Adelaide.