Casey want answers re Jack Trengove concussion

[stuie 7,374]

From an article in the Herald Sun...

MELBOURNE’S VFL club Casey has called for the league to investigate the hit that concussed Demons midfielder Jack Trengove on Saturday night.

A dazed Trengove was collected high just minutes into Casey’s thumping of Frankston and must undergo concussion tests in order to prove his fitness this week.

The VFL confirmed on Monday the Scorpions had requested an investigation and submitted a medical report but said it was already on top of the incident following a referral from the umpires.

Frankston captain Jason Pongracic was on Monday night offered a two-match suspension for rough conduct.

Footage shows Trengove, 24, was bumped in the head by a Frankston player just off the ball early in the first quarter of Casey’s 144-point win.

Casey coach Justin Plapp said Trengove was simply in the wrong place at the wrong time.

“I don’t think there was a hell of a lot of malice. But he was clearly concussed,” Plapp said.

I thought it happened in a pack situation, but this certainly paints a different picture...

 

 

 

[Devil is in the Detail 883]

7 minutes ago, stuie said:

From an article in the Herald Sun...

 

MELBOURNE’S VFL club Casey has called for the league to investigate the hit that concussed Demons midfielder Jack Trengove on Saturday night.

A dazed Trengove was collected high just minutes into Casey’s thumping of Frankston and must undergo concussion tests in order to prove his fitness this week.

 

The VFL confirmed on Monday the Scorpions had requested an investigation and submitted a medical report but said it was already on top of the incident following a referral from the umpires.

Frankston captain Jason Pongracic was on Monday night offered a two-match suspension for rough conduct.

 

Footage shows Trengove, 24, was bumped in the head by a Frankston player just off the ball early in the first quarter of Casey’s 144-point win.

Casey coach Justin Plapp said Trengove was simply in the wrong place at the wrong time.

“I don’t think there was a hell of a lot of malice. But he was clearly concussed,” Plapp said.

 

I thought it happened in a pack situation, but this certainly paints a different picture...

 

 

 

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,803]

38 minutes ago, stuie said:

From an article in the Herald Sun...

 

MELBOURNE’S VFL club Casey has called for the league to investigate the hit that concussed Demons midfielder Jack Trengove on Saturday night.

A dazed Trengove was collected high just minutes into Casey’s thumping of Frankston and must undergo concussion tests in order to prove his fitness this week.

 

The VFL confirmed on Monday the Scorpions had requested an investigation and submitted a medical report but said it was already on top of the incident following a referral from the umpires.

Frankston captain Jason Pongracic was on Monday night offered a two-match suspension for rough conduct.

 

Footage shows Trengove, 24, was bumped in the head by a Frankston player just off the ball early in the first quarter of Casey’s 144-point win.

Casey coach Justin Plapp said Trengove was simply in the wrong place at the wrong time.

“I don’t think there was a hell of a lot of malice. But he was clearly concussed,” Plapp said.

 

I thought it happened in a pack situation, but this certainly paints a different picture...

 

 

 

Casey needs to get its story straight. Why would the club be calling for the league to investigate something that its own coach states was a result of Trengove being in the wrong place at the wrong time and which occurred without malice? (OK, Plapp allegedly said without "a hell of a lot of malice", but he may as well have said no malice).

[Elusive Tunbridge 795]

I'd say Plapp was following the omerta code but Melbourne said "Stuff that, we can't have our stars getting sniped."

[whatwhat say what 22,775]

Lined him up, flattened him.

 

Dog act.

[Ted Lasso 19,518]

Must admit watching the video i didn't think it was in play, it was just a dick move. 

bit of an old fashioned clean up job.

[dazzledavey36 54,949]

1 minute ago, DemonAndrew said:

Lined him up, flattened him.

 

Dog act.

Got 2 weeks for it.. what more can they do? Fair enough if he didn't get any weeks but i think this should be just a simple move on and get on with it.

Trengove tweeted the next day that he felt fine so i dont see any point really of going further.

[dazzledavey36 54,949]

6 minutes ago, Peter Griffen said:

Must admit watching the video i didn't think it was in play, it was just a dick move. 

bit of an old fashioned clean up job.

Pretty sure it happened around the stoppage contest but to be honest i thought the camera work was awful through out the whole game.

[H_T 3,047]

I wonder if some have actually seen the 1st quarter footage posted in the Casey v Frankston thread, given what has been posted: -

My view: -

• It was not behind the play
• It was not off the ball
• It was in play at the stoppage / just after centre bounce (after first goal of game).
• There was no intention/malice to hurt player IMV.

The Frankston player at the centre bounce was on the pounce from the ball up (starting in the centre), determined to get to the ball. The ball approached the two players running in from the wing (Trengove and opponent) all of the sudden as a result from the tap out, the player had speed, changed direction into path of player(s), Trengove was slightly behind his opponent who quickly got out of way, then collision (or bump). Point of contact hit Trengove front on, Trengove went back and looked to hit his head on ground hard. 

Not sure if the contact of head on ground what was caused the concussion, as video footage is poor. But there appears a sudden whiplash after point of initial contact with player suggesting that a shoulder may have split him (hit him) when left open. 

I'd suggest either or both contributed to concussion.

Speedy recovery for Jack I hope. 

 

[Watts the matter 1,235]

9 minutes ago, H_T said:

I wonder if some have actually seen the 1st quarter footage posted in the Casey v Frankston thread, given what has been posted: -

My view: -

• It was not behind the play
• It was not off the ball
• It was in play at the stoppage / just after centre bounce (after first goal of game).
• There was no intention/malice to hurt player IMV.

The Frankston player at the centre bounce was on the pounce from the ball up (starting in the centre), determined to get to the ball. The ball approached the two players running in from the wing (Trengove and opponent) all of the sudden as a result from the tap out, the player had speed, changed direction into path of player(s), Trengove was slightly behind his opponent who quickly got out of way, then collision (or bump). Point of contact hit Trengove front on, Trengove went back and looked to hit his head on ground hard. 

Not sure if the contact of head on ground what was caused the concussion, as video footage is poor. But there appears a sudden whiplash after point of initial contact with player suggesting that a shoulder may have split him (hit him) when left open. 

I'd suggest either or both contributed to concussion.

Speedy recovery for Jack I hope. 

 

Well said, we would all be up in arms if Viney got 2 weeks for that, not much in it unless it was high.

Here's a link to the hit if you haven't seen it.

 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fmj_e9moYZ4&t=2m28s

 

 

[DeeSpencer 25,717]

Nothing story. 

A player gets knocked out from a bump, you're going to submit the medical and make sure the league has seen it. Not exactly dobbing, just par for the course these days.

Plapp's comments are right. Trengove seems to have moved on. The Frankston player has taken the 2 weeks which is about spot on as far as I can tell for a high bump causing injury. 

If Casey wanted answers then they got them.

[dazzledavey36 54,949]

2 hours ago, ManDee said:

What sort of scumbag lowlife takes out a player who has missed as much footy as Trengove?

Behind the play to a ball player like Trengove, must be a spineless miscreant.  Oh, he's from Frankston of course.

Frankston captain Jason Pongracic - lowlife.

 

 

 

Talk about overreacting much..

Edited April 12, 2016 by dazzledavey36

[stuie 7,374]

18 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Talk about overeating much..

Geez, might have been an overreaction, but no need to call him fat...

 

[binman 43,020]

20 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Talk about overeating much..

He doesn't look that over weight

[ManDee 7,153]

22 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Talk about overeating much..

OK i over ate.  I also overreacted watched replay about 5 times he was stiff.

[Akum 2,660]

5 minutes ago, ManDee said:

OK i over ate.  I also overreacted watched replay about 5 times he was stiff.

You must have amazing definition on your TV to tell that.

[ManDee 7,153]

1 minute ago, Akum said:

You must have amazing definition on your TV to tell that.

Trengove jogs in off the wing and cops a shoulder to the head from 25 who appears to see him then he appears to decide to go through with the hit.

 

 

 

[H_T 3,047]

Trengove actually is the last person to touch the ball a split second before the hit. 

Clearly the Frankston player made the wrong choice. He had a choice to go for the ball.

Right decision 2 weeks IMV.

[Devil is in the Detail 883]

1 hour ago, H_T said:

I wonder if some have actually seen the 1st quarter footage posted in the Casey v Frankston thread, given what has been posted: -

My view: -

• It was not behind the play
• It was not off the ball
• It was in play at the stoppage / just after centre bounce (after first goal of game).
• There was no intention/malice to hurt player IMV.

The Frankston player at the centre bounce was on the pounce from the ball up (starting in the centre), determined to get to the ball. The ball approached the two players running in from the wing (Trengove and opponent) all of the sudden as a result from the tap out, the player had speed, changed direction into path of player(s), Trengove was slightly behind his opponent who quickly got out of way, then collision (or bump). Point of contact hit Trengove front on, Trengove went back and looked to hit his head on ground hard. 

Not sure if the contact of head on ground what was caused the concussion, as video footage is poor. But there appears a sudden whiplash after point of initial contact with player suggesting that a shoulder may have split him (hit him) when left open. 

I'd suggest either or both contributed to concussion.

Speedy recovery for Jack I hope. 

 

Bullsh!t. As soon as the ball was out of his immediate area, he ran past the ball, lined Trengrove up, lifted the elbow and went through him. Not intent for the ball. If he was going for the ball he would have stopped, started to turn around and chase the ball.

[H_T 3,047]

Play the video back that ManDee just posted. have a look at how fast no.25 was travelling and tell me he could have stopped as soon as Trengove tapped ball to ground in different direction. Then post something unbiased.

The mistake he made was following through with a bump in a split second. No malice though IMO. As I said 2 weeks is spot on IMV. Nothing more.

 

[Devil is in the Detail 883]

5 minutes ago, H_T said:

Play the video back that ManDee just posted. have a look at how fast no.25 was travelling and tell me he could have stopped as soon as Trengove tapped ball to ground in different direction. Then post something unbiased.

Not stopped, but his velocity/direction would have changed. There was no sign of him changing direction even when the ball did. No. 25 actually slowed up as he got closer to the ball, then he planted his feet and keep going through Trengrove.

Edited April 12, 2016 by Devil is in the Detail

[DemonDave 1,089]

I must say I've been very confused by the whole media coverage of this incident, in the very same story that states Casey demand an investigation,

it declares the culprit has been given two weeks. What's there to investigate if he's been rubbed out?

 

[H_T 3,047]

9 minutes ago, Devil is in the Detail said:

Not stopped, but his velocity/direction would have changed. There was no sign of him changing direction even when the ball did. No. 25 actually slowed up as he got closer to the ball, then he planted his feet and keep going through Trengrove.

Hence a 2 week penalty. Just penalty for his action. 

 

[DEE fence 5,018]

On emotion - its Trengrove, therefore 25 should be hung. Otherwise 2 weeks is about right. 

[Moonshadow 17,676]

Pretty clear that no. 25 from Frankston lined him up and delivered an elbow/forearm. May not have intended to knock him senseless, but it looked to me like he had no intention of going for the ball. Was 2 games enough? Had it happened at senior AFL level he would've got more IMO. Bernie Vince got two weeks down to one for barely touching an opponent's chin (if he made contact at all).