Tom McDonald (and Oscar) SIGNS.

[beelzebub 22,700]

3 hours ago, Radar Detector said:

 

Funny Wagner doesn't cop the same knocks. I reckon he's good for at least one howler a game himself.

He's a pup. Tommy supposed to be top dog. Huge difference no ?

[ArtificialWisdom 3,958]

5 hours ago, Radar Detector said:

Funny Wagner doesn't cop the same knocks. I reckon he's good for at least one howler a game himself.

I agree Wagner has a bad kick here or there but i can deal with the odd turnover once in a while, doesnt matter who you get they are all going to turn it over at times, jones and bernie had about 5 or 6 turnovers between them in the first 5 min of the collingwood game. What I cant deal with is a turnover that has come from someone running themselves into trouble, that is what Tmac does too much.

I think Tom is harshly judged for his disposal, its not actually that bad but he seems to want to do everything under pressure when he doesnt need to. A side step in slow motion might get him past 1 opponent but another colapses in and then he kicks off balance and under pressue when he could have kicked earlier. Wagner doesnt do this, he takes the first option. 8/9 times out of 10 the first option is the best one. Took tyson all of last year to learn that, but now he has and he is one of our best every week and nobody complains about his disposal anymore and he doesnt get caught nearly as often as before.

[beelzebub 22,700]

It's often not TMacs kick itself ,as it were, but what his intent with it.i.e the reasoning behind the decisions.

[Members' Wing 1,106]

5 hours ago, Demons11 said:

He has been injured. Once fit, he is a walk up start 

I'd suggest before making a comment like that, you; A) make sure you know what you're talking about, or B) do some research.

 

[Dockett 32 1,213]

13 hours ago, schmuttt said:

If he goes and Hurley is available, package a 1st rounder that we'd get for TMac plus our 2017 1st for Hurley. Essendon won't turn that down if Hurley wants to come to us.

Be a decent outcome, but for it to happen he has to want to go , has to want to come to us  and no other club with a better first rounder or trade can outbid us.

IMO defence ok, midfield and forwards need to perform better. T.Mc ok for me at a sensible arrangement for both parties.

 

[picket fence 15,735]

Wagner is Twice the player T mac is and Three times the player O mac is!

Like him a lot!!

[Radar Detector 1,339]

11 hours ago, beelzebub said:

He's a pup. Tommy supposed to be top dog. Huge difference no ?

He is 22, not much younger than T-Mac who is "supposed to be a top dog" because he is a far superior player.

Some of Tom's mistakes drive me nuts, the one early against Essendon was probably one of the worst ever. But some of the commentary on here is beyond ludicrous. This guy is a young KPD who less than a year ago was in AA calculations. Sydney are rumoured to want him (and not Hurley incidentally) and I suspect almost every other club would be happy to have him.

He has faults but FMD if he isn't a required player I almost don't know who is.

[Little Richard 5,934]

14 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Wagner is Twice the player T mac is and Three times the player O mac is!

Like him a lot!!

What do you base this on? Please explain your system to me.

[Deestroy All 14,262]

11 minutes ago, Django said:

What do you base this on? Please explain your system to me.

!!! + !!!!!! = !!!!!!!!!

[picket fence 15,735]

I like Wagner a lot and have seen the following attributes in this player

1 Can put body on body

2 Has better judgment whether to punch or mark

3 Seems to have more time to dispose of the ball

4 Has less "Anxious" moments than the other two

5 Is developing into an 'Elite" reader of the ball

Yes he does have the occasional "Clanger" but for the reasons above plus my gut feel I reckong he will become an excellent player.

IMV He is much better than the other two, Get Browne from Collingwood, Continue the development of Frost as a defender and I would be very pleased about this!

Edited June 24, 2016 by picket fence

[Rod Grinter Riot Squad 5,654]

2. Tom Mac has great judgement on whether to mark or punch, better than Wagner.

 

3. Wagner gets caught with the ball a bit because, like Tom, he takes too long to kick it.

 

4. Has the same.

 

5. No he isn't.

 

Wagner has started his AFL career very well, to call him twice the player that tmac is just makes all of your critics and their criticisms look correct

[Members' Wing 1,106]

29 minutes ago, picket fence said:

I like Wagner a lot and have seen the following attributes in this player

1 Can put body on body

2 Has better judgment whether to punch or mark

3 Seems to have more time to dispose of the ball

4 Has less "Anxious" moments than the other two

5 Is developing into an 'Elite" reader of the ball

Yes he does have the occasional "Clanger" but for the reasons above plus my gut feel I reckong he will become an excellent player.

IMV He is much better than the other two, Get Browne from Collingwood, Continue the development of Frost as a defender and I would be very pleased about this!

Hang on a minute. You think Josh Wagner is a better player than Tom McDonald?

[Demons11 6,406]

8 hours ago, Members' Wing said:

I'd suggest before making a comment like that, you; A) make sure you know what you're talking about, or B) do some research.

 

Has he not been injured?? He played 2 or so games in the NEAFL and got injured again. 

I suggest you do some research 

Edited June 24, 2016 by Demons11

[beelzebub 22,700]

1 hour ago, Radar Detector said:

He is 22, not much younger than T-Mac who is "supposed to be a top dog" because he is a far superior player.

Some of Tom's mistakes drive me nuts, the one early against Essendon was probably one of the worst ever. But some of the commentary on here is beyond ludicrous. This guy is a young KPD who less than a year ago was in AA calculations. Sydney are rumoured to want him (and not Hurley incidentally) and I suspect almost every other club would be happy to have him.

He has faults but FMD if he isn't a required player I almost don't know who is.

Wagner's been in the system a year . Tmac 5

There's nearly 2 years between them to say nothing of 80 odd games.

Josh has shown more improvement in one season than has in all of his.

I'm not concerned when Wagner has the ball. He has a far better head for what to do with it. .... and he's still green, I concede !!

Edited June 24, 2016 by beelzebub

[Deestroy All 14,262]

39 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

Has he not been injured?? He played 2 or so games in the NEAFL and got injured again. 

I suggest you do some research 

You replied to a comment about Brown from Collingwood, who was dropped, hence Members Wing's response.

[Demons11 6,406]

5 minutes ago, Deestroy All said:

You replied to a comment about Brown from Collingwood, who was dropped, hence Members Wing's response.

My bad

[Wilson7 2,538]

1 hour ago, Members' Wing said:

Hang on a minute. You think Josh Wagner is a better player than Tom McDonald?

Says it all really

[beelzebub 22,700]

1 hour ago, Members' Wing said:

Hang on a minute. You think Josh Wagner is a better player than Tom McDonald?

He's shown more progress and aptitude for creating an attacking disposal with effect. Tom does probably 2 things well. He can mark and punch well. The roles these two play are different but given ones been around 5 mins, the other 5 seasons  I am prepared one has definitely developed more , relatively.

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,595]

My eyes must be playing tricks on me. Someone on this thread said Wagner is a better player than T McDonald!!!

I think I finally need reading glasses because there is no way someone would actually type that around here.

[beelzebub 22,700]

Tommy lad has his opportunity to showcase his talent and put in for a pay rise next game.

Wants to be on his game...his A game 

[Redleg 38,402]

On 6/24/2016 at 9:33 PM, beelzebub said:

Wagner's been in the system a year . Tmac 5

There's nearly 2 years between them to say nothing of 80 odd games.

Josh has shown more improvement in one season than has in all of his.

I'm not concerned when Wagner has the ball. He has a far better head for what to do with it. .... and he's still green, I concede !!

One is a key back and one is a back flanker. 

[Willmoy1947 3,846]

46 minutes ago, Redleg said:

One is a key back and one is a back flanker. 

I reckon i'll speculate on Josh and a newcomer and speed.

[beelzebub 22,700]

22 hours ago, Redleg said:

One is a key back and one is a back flanker. 

no kidding

[Mach5 4,499]

On 6/23/2016 at 7:33 PM, RalphiusMaximus said:

The AFL site had a live chat on trade targets today.  According to whoever the journo was Sydney are putting a pretty big offer in front of TMac.  Interesting. 

 

Makes sense.

Richards and Grundy are nearing the end.
Richards even talking about contemplating immediate retirement following his recent concussion.

[beelzebub 22,700]

What would the Swannies need to hand over ?