Looking at Slobbos top 50 and Bernard made it at number 43. Only Melb player.

Was surprised to see Hurley at 19, I don't think his season was great. I rate him, but more 25ish.

Thought?

Not worthy of a discussion topic.

No one from Geelong made it on the list so this year I'm taking the 'it's a great list and everything is pretty much spot on' line.

Selwood not making it was a surprise.

I thought Delidio would have been higher too.

I thought Glenlivet would make it above Fosters

Selwood is a great player, but he had an ordinary year. No way he is in the best 50 players of the season. So fair call by Robbo to leave him out. As Huggy Bear said "you just went up a notch in my book, that puts you at notch one".

Selwood is a great player, but he had an ordinary year. No way he is in the best 50 players of the season. So fair call by Robbo to leave him out. As Huggy Bear said "you just went up a notch in my book, that puts you at notch one".

Agree on his year wasn't great but the all love him, that's where the surprise was.

When was there last a Melbourne player in the Mike Sheahan/Mark Robinson end of year top 50?

When was there last a Melbourne player in the Mike Sheahan/Mark Robinson end of year top 50?

Jones was #43 last season. Not sure when the last time we had someone above #20 was, let alone in the top 10.

Not worthy of a discussion topic.

Touche !! Why bring the opinions of this person to the forefront in demonland ??

Jones was #43 last season. Not sure when the last time we had someone above #20 was, let alone in the top 10.

Thanks. I obviously have the memory of a goldfish.

Thanks. I obviously have the memory of a goldfish.

No point remembering the junk that either of them write...I just googled it.

Surprised Slobbo can remember the 2015 season

He had a Wet Toast ruckman, fresh off his 4 posession Grand Final in the low 20s.

Surely a matter of time before Chris Dawes Jesse Hogan bursts onto this list...

Surprised Slobbo can remember the 2015 season

surprised slobbo can count to 50

maybe he had help

Stop making stupid people famous!

Surprised Slobbo can remember the 2015 season

Nar Slobbo had a quite year.

It's believed He even left the Brownlow after party as early as 3am.

I still find it amazing that he's Gerard Whately's side-kick on AFL 360.

Arguably the best commentator/television host coupled with a bloke who knows very little about the game and translates that fact so well.

Read it up until I saw Hurley at 19.

19.

I then proceeded to laugh loudly.

And calmly carried on with my day.

Gerard W would feel quite at home with this bloke because he played with Manangatang under 15's

Was Hird named Coach of the year?

Was Hird named Coach of the year?

no need. i think slobbo earlier declared him coach of the century

Not sure when the last time we had someone above #20 was, let alone in the top 10.

Back then, Moses did the top 50. But really everyone only cared about the top 10, which he carved in stone.

Saw it this morning and read no further.

After the last couple of years of his Hird / Essendrug fawning he has zero credibility IMO.

surprised slobbo can count to 50

maybe he had help

The gave him two slabs and two tinnies and told him to write the players names on the and arrange them in order.