I'd take him in an instant. Hopefully has a couple of decent years left. Noted goal kicker, good ball user, has footy "smarts" & runs rings around any small forward we have apart from Garlett.

Hell no

As long as we go after Barry Stoneham too.

No

May as well continue signing old duds from other clubs.

May as well continue signing old duds from other clubs.

No needs to play in a top side to be damaging

We are not a aged care facility. No.

No.

Roflcopters.

Slowed down and can't kick over a jam jar. I'd rather be brave and go for Stevie J for a year.

This is worst then the Jed Adcock thread.

NO

FFS.

Thankfully we are past needing to recruit guys like Stokes. He has well and truly looked past it this year and the Cats not offering him a new deal is reflective of that.

Would $3 million over five years be enough to get him out of retirement?

Let's get Dustin Fletcher too.

Is this what we are back to? The good old days of 2012-2013 when any player who got delisted or who retired becomes a supposed target of the MFC (according to some on here)?
And some thought bringing Shagger Byrnes and David Rodan to the club was a good idea too....

he is 29 guys. ease up.

having said that...

NO

Would like us to go after James Kelly as a de-listed free agent. He would slot in nicely as a replacement for Daniel Cross in our back line.

Would like us to go after James Kelly as a de-listed free agent. He would slot in nicely as a replacement for Daniel Cross in our back line.

If that was the case, I'd rather we kept Cross.

If that was the case, I'd rather we kept Cross.

I really liked Cross but Kelly is quicker and a much better user off half back so I don't see the merit in that comment.

Interestingly, he said even if Geelong offered him a new contract he'd turn it down.

Chris Scott is pissing off a few people at the moment.

May not last too much longer.

Apart from culling the very successful dead wood.Why is it so Machsy?

We are not a aged care facility. No.

play like one !!