MFC player 1 year contract valuations

[stuie 7,374]

So to add a bit more "reality" into it.

I've actually added in the mandatory payments for 2nd year, 1st year and rookie listed players.

And I've taken into account the incentive of match payments. if a player plays every game for a year, they get an extra $77,000

For that reason, for simplistic sake, I've treated it like "100K" deducted.

On what I would pay/what I think they're on, I've listed it out below.

N.Jones 600000 B.Vince 600000 J.Hogan 400000 T.Mcdonald 350000 L.Dunn 350000 J.Viney 350000 D.Tyson 350000 D.Cross 200000 N.Jetta 200000 J.Garlett 300000 H.Lumumba 300000 A.Brayshaw 71515 A.Vandenberg 55440 C.Dawes 400000 C.Garland 300000 J.Watts 400000 J.Howe 200000 J.Grimes 400000 C.Pederson 200000 D.Kent 150000 C.Salem 72970 J.Kennedy-Harris 62695 S.Frost 80815 M.Gawn 100000 J.Spencer 100000 M.Jamar 200000 M.Jones 80815 C.Petracca 71515 R.Bail 80815 J.Toumpas 100000 J.Trengove 100000 B.Newton 80815 B.Stretch 61610 A.Neal-Bullen 65000 A.Riley 80815 V.Michie 80815 J.Mckenzie 80815 J.Fitzpatrick 80815 D.Terlich 80815 J.Hunt 62695 M.King 55440 M.White 55440 O.Mcdonald 61610 J.Harmes 55440

Salary Cap: $9,921000

Total payments: $8,128,705

Match payments: $1,694,000 (assume 22 players x 22 games x $3500)

Remaining: $98,295

Salary cap in 2016 will be $10.36 million

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Fight fight fight!

does anyone remember that Jimeoin sketch where all the kids are in the playground chanting "what's this?! what's going on?!"

gold

[Deestroy All 14,262]

What if our entire list had their contracts torn up and were to be offered 1 year contracts for the 2016 season...what would they be worth?

N.Jones 800,000

B.Vince 800,000

T.Mcdonald 650,000

L.Dunn 650,000

J.Hogan 650,000

J.Viney 650,000

D.Tyson 650,000

D.Cross 650,000

N.Jetta 500,000

J.Garlett 500,000

H.Lumumba 500,000

A.Brayshaw 500,000

A.Vandenberg 500,000

C.Dawes 450,000

C.Garland 450,000

J.Watts 400,000

J.Howe 400,000

J.Grimes 400,000

C.Pederson 400,000

D.Kent 375,000

C.Salem 375,000

J.Kennedy-Harris 375,000

S.Frost 350,000

M.Gawn 350,000

J.Spencer 350,000

M.Jamar 350,000

M.Jones 350,000

C.Petracca 350,000

R.Bail 300,000

J.Toumpas 300,000

J.Trengove 300,000

B.Newton 300,000

B.Stretch 300,000

A.Neal-Bullen 300,000

A.Riley 275,000

V.Michie 275,000

J.Mckenzie 275,000

J.Fitzpatrick 275,000

D.Terlich 275,000

J.Hunt 200,000

M.King 200,000

M.White 200,000

O.Mcdonald 200,000

J.Harmes 200,000

Interested to see what people think some of the players under 20 games would be offered like Hogan and Vandenberg.

Joe Gutnick has reported this post.

[Roger Mellie 3,867]

This grief could be avoided by just giving players a mark out of 10 for the year.

Eg Hogan = 10, Brayshaw = 10 Vince = 10

Then we don't have to knicker twist over salary caps or whatever tf this is.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

This grief could be avoided by just giving players a mark out of 10 for the year.

Eg Hogan = 10, Brayshaw = 10 Vince = 10

Then we don't have to knicker twist over salary caps or whatever tf this is.

Its good to see it all layed out im interested to see how Sydney affords to keep all its good players, or a team like Adelaide who possibly without Dangerfield and Tippet will seemingly have quite a bit of room to draft some players if high value..

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Cross by his valuation still has at least 1 good year left in him as he is clearly in our top 10 players...

[Roger Mellie 3,867]

Its good to see it all layed out im interested to see how Sydney affords to keep all its good players, or a team like Adelaide who possibly without Dangerfield and Tippet will seemingly have quite a bit of room to draft some players if high value..

Oh OK

Buddy $1.3m

Tipsy $900K

Daylight

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Oh OK

Buddy $1.3m

Tipsy $900K

Daylight

2.2 mil then there is Hannebery, Jack, Mcveigh, Goodes, Kennedy...there must be some players getting unders...

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,644]

This grief could be avoided by just giving players a mark out of 10 for the year.

Eg Hogan = 10, Brayshaw = 10 Vince = 10

Then we don't have to knicker twist over salary caps or whatever tf this is.

You're assuming the AFL doesn't impose a "mark out of 10 cap" to avoid clubs rating everyone too highly.

Presumably some clubs would keep a separate list for those players who score more than 10 out of 10.

[Sir Why You Little 36,587]

Too much Maths for me!!

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

J.Garlett 350,000

Garlett is our leading goal kicker, he is worth more than that.

[deeko 952]

Garlett is our leading goal kicker, he is worth more than that.

He is worth more than that but it would be interesting to see what he actually is getting.

Wasn't exactly flying at Carlton on or off the field when he came across.

He's worth every penny he's getting here anyway

[FireOath 290]

I believe ~80k is a starting wage for an AFL player.

[DemonDave 1,080]

Colin Garland earning 100K less than a rookie-listed player who's played 10 career games?

While this doesnt have draftees/trades factored in, it shows what a complicated web of numbers

managing an AFL list has become, given you can also back/front end contracts, veterans and rookie

lists, restricted/unrestricted free agency statuses. Not to mention match payments as mentioned, inury

payments, incentive based bonuses etc etc...

[Jaded No More 67,609]

Hogan easily $900,000

[Members' Wing 1,106]

Hogan easily $900,000

No chance, don't let the ridiculous Boyd deal skew your perceptions on players' worth.

Hawkins, both Riewoldts, Kennedy and Cloke are all on less than that and while Hogan has the potential to be better than all of them, he's not in their league yet.

$900k would be insane, there are only about 5 players in the league on more than that.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Garlett is our leading goal kicker, he is worth more than that.

I agree but who would you take money off to give him more...we drafted one of the best small forwards in the game and all for a draft pick in the 60's...

[Jaded No More 67,609]

No chance, don't let the ridiculous Boyd deal skew your perceptions on players' worth.

Hawkins, both Riewoldts, Kennedy and Cloke are all on less than that and while Hogan has the potential to be better than all of them, he's not in their league yet.

$900k would be insane, there are only about 5 players in the league on more than that.

Except if this scenario was real and Hogan was out of contract for next season, club would be throwing this amount of money at him and we would need to at least match it to keep him.

The Boyd deal is an indication of market value for up and coming KPFs, and Hogan is already a more proven prospect than Boyd.

[dpositive 1,649]

sadly

Is this all just an indicator of why there is so much dysfunctional behaviour in AFL teams.

Salary levels as a component of the industry income, apportioned on a random short term calculation.

These guys are footballers, entertainers receiving outrageous returns for their efforts.

A mark out of ten would provide a more realistic recognition than an artificial salary. And marks should be standardised against other players in the league.

Salary should be a life time component and not considered for one year. Amounts should be designated for base with allowances for performance and components for education and long term reward, plus of course allowances for sick injury and hospital accommodation

But hey it aint gonna happen

give em the money and let them keep us entertained by their on and off field antics.

I am happy that at least we seem to have less dysfunctional behaviour than most clubs.

[Chris 2,892]

What if our entire list had their contracts torn up and were to be offered 1 year contracts for the 2016 season...what would they be worth?

N.Jones 700,000

B.Vince 700,000

J.Hogan 500,000

T.Mcdonald 450,000

L.Dunn 450,000

J.Viney 450,000

D.Tyson 450,000

D.Cross 450,000

N.Jetta 350,000

J.Garlett 350,000

H.Lumumba 350,000

A.Brayshaw 350,000

A.Vandenberg 350,000

C.Dawes 250,000

C.Garland 250,000

J.Watts 200,000

J.Howe 200,000

J.Grimes 200,000

C.Pederson 200,000

D.Kent 200,000

C.Salem 200,000

J.Kennedy-Harris 200,000

S.Frost 150,000

M.Gawn 150,000

J.Spencer 150,000

M.Jamar 150,000

M.Jones 150,000

C.Petracca 150,000

R.Bail 100,000

J.Toumpas 100,000

J.Trengove 100,000

B.Newton 100,000

B.Stretch 100,000

A.Neal-Bullen 100,000

A.Riley 75,000

V.Michie 75,000

J.Mckenzie 75,000

J.Fitzpatrick 75,000

D.Terlich 75,000

J.Hunt 50,000

M.King 50,000

M.White 50,000

O.Mcdonald 50,000

J.Harmes 50,000

Interested to see what people think some of the players under 20 games would be offered like Hogan and Vandenberg.

Can I pocket the $146,000 left over?

[Chris 2,892]

Its good to see it all layed out im interested to see how Sydney affords to keep all its good players, or a team like Adelaide who possibly without Dangerfield and Tippet will seemingly have quite a bit of room to draft some players if high value..

Sydney also have an extra mil or so to play with, so they effectively get Tippett for free.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Can I pocket the $146,000 left over?

Just give it to Hogan aye, we all know he is worth it

[Dockett 32 1,237]

NFI.

Complete fairy floss.

If Hogan requires $900,000 for 5 or 6 , suggest we stump it up quick smart and shut the door.

[dee-luded 2,959]

You mean apart from the fact the cap is $10 million and these salaries add up to nearly $18 million?

Edit - Had to add an edit about how effing hilarious it is you would accuse anyone else of sniping when all you do is follow me around... Amazing stuff.

whom follows who in the baked bean scene

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Jesse Hogan- 3mil

Daniel Cross- 2.5 mil.

Jack Viney- 999k and a bus ticket

Angus Brayshaw- 700k

Max Gawn- 500k

Christian Petracca- My good knee

Nathan Jones- A diamond necklace

Bernie Vince- A return trip to heaven

Jack Watts- Immunity from everything

Lynden Dunn- About as much as he's raised from Movember

Chris Dawes- Super glue

Liam Jurrah- A get out of jail free card

Sam Blease- A rock through his window, thrown by Jordie Mckenzie.

Neville Jetta- A concussion test that doesn't sit him for a month.

Viv Michie- Recognition

Jayden Hunt and James Harmes- Differentiation from one another

Jake Spencer- A pencil sharpener

Jack Trengove- Unicorn blood

Jack Grimes- A potato cake.

Matt Jones- A table cloth.

Rohan Bail- The confetti that is left from the torn up contracts.

Dean Terlich- A spa day with Alex Georgiou