Open Mike: Todd Viney

[daisycutter 29,738]

Jesu Criste, am I sick of reading the crap about Watts and Toumpas on this site. Get a life you people, get a f.....g life!

out of curiosity dieter, any idea where to start looking? i might be interested

[Slartibartfast 17,625]

"The story of how Stynes saved the Melbourne Football Club is much more than a sporting saga. Demolishing more than $4 million worth of debt was something the AFL initially believed beyond even him, but it was uniting the disenfranchised Demons that remains his most remarkable legacy" Caroline Wilson Age 7 May 2011.

The history of the Club under the leadership of the much-loved Jim Stynes and his successor Don McLardy is a difficult matter for all of us.

We all have a sense of sustained calamity. On the other hand, Jim and his colleagues stepped forward at a time of need, were motivated by the best of intentions and stuck to the task in the face of great and, in Jim's case, persobnal difficulty.

None of this should prevent the writing of the history of the Club accurately and faithfully over this period.

I think Todd's interview last night is a valuable contribution to this history. Most media commentators have to this day followed the Wilson myth that Jim "united the Club". This is a myth on 2 counts. Once the scars of the 2001 Board election had healed, there was no disunity at the Club. All this changed with Jim's election and the commencement of the period Todd referred to and lived through culminating in the events of 186. This period equated to the most sustained and destructive period of disunity at any Club in the modern era.

I was disappointed this aspect of his experience was not followed up and that his reference to the fractured club not expanded although the comment itself was chilling. I wondered if there was more in the interview that was edited out.

But the show was about Todd and his journey and to be honest it was one of the less interesting Mike interviews of which there have been some absolute rippers.

But I'd be fascinated with an insiders view of the role of Jimmy, Don, Garry, Chris, Barry, Cameron, Neale, Paul and Bails on our sad history over the last 10 years or so and Todd would tell it as straight as anyone would I reckon.

[jackaub 1,402]

Jesu Criste, am I sick of reading the crap about Watts and Toumpas on this site. Get a life you people, get a f.....g life!

And the best way to achieve that is to move them on out of our club right??

[Melbman2 226]

Who do you replace him with?

A spot on the list?

[Roost It 1,434]

A spot on the list?

so play each game with 21?

[ManDee 7,222]

Jesu Criste, am I sick of reading the crap about Watts and Toumpas on this site. Get a life you people, get a f.....g life!

Stop reading it then.

[T&W 38]

I was disappointed this aspect of his experience was not followed up and that his reference to the fractured club not expanded although the comment itself was chilling. I wondered if there was more in the interview that was edited out.

But the show was about Todd and his journey and to be honest it was one of the less interesting Mike interviews of which there have been some absolute rippers.

But I'd be fascinated with an insiders view of the role of Jimmy, Don, Garry, Chris, Barry, Cameron, Neale, Paul and Bails on our sad history over the last 10 years or so and Todd would tell it as straight as anyone would I reckon.

I quite enjoyed the interview, nice to hear Mike reaffirm his allegiance to the Demons. Great to hear Todd reemphasize we are heading in the right direction with "good" people but we always anticipated the negative "noise".

Must say I also personally agree the Bails decision was the right decision ... sadly ... 100% agree it never an easy/nice thing to have to do. What is done is done - now we look forward in hope. Go Dees

[Whispering_Jack 30,652]

I was disappointed this aspect of his experience was not followed up and that his reference to the fractured club not expanded although the comment itself was chilling. I wondered if there was more in the interview that was edited out.

But the show was about Todd and his journey and to be honest it was one of the less interesting Mike interviews of which there have been some absolute rippers.

But I'd be fascinated with an insiders view of the role of Jimmy, Don, Garry, Chris, Barry, Cameron, Neale, Paul and Bails on our sad history over the last 10 years or so and Todd would tell it as straight as anyone would I reckon.

I don't think it's possible for any one person to faithfully tell the story of our history over the past 10 - 15 years because history is something that different people tend to look at from different perspectives. The people you've named would no doubt all be able to give their own versions of some of the events and while TV could indeed tell it as straight as anyone, let's not forget that for much of that period he was away from the club having spent time with the Hawks and the Crows.

As far as I'm concerned, the best part of our recent sad history is the fact that it's history.

[grazman 7,451]

because according to Mr Nietzsche who put it best,

all things are subject to interpretation,

whichever interpretation prevails at a given time is a function of power and not truth.

[Grapeviney 9,799]

because according to Mr Nietzsche who put it best,

all things are subject to interpretation,

whichever interpretation prevails at a given time is a function of power and not truth.

Gotta love Neita - one of footy's greatest philosophers.

[Macca 17,032]

Just another point re Lucas Cook - what if the 2010 draft had looked like this? ...

12 - Tom McDonald

33 - Jeremy Howe

50 - Troy Davis

53 - Lucas Cook

81 - Jordie McKenzie (promoted rookie)

96 - Jake Spencer (promoted rookie)

We'd almost certainly wear the late picks and be very happy with the first 2 picks (especially the first pick)

Spin

[Undeeterred 3,124]

Just another point re Lucas Cook - what if the 2010 draft had looked like this? ...

12 - Tom McDonald

33 - Jeremy Howe

50 - Troy Davis

53 - Lucas Cook

81 - Jordie McKenzie (promoted rookie)

96 - Jake Spencer (promoted rookie)

We'd almost certainly wear the late picks and be very happy with the first 2 picks (especially the first pick)

Spin

Excellent, excellent point.

[Melbman2 226]

so play each game with 21?

I reckon most folks would think seasons end would be more strategic ;-)

Or I could have gone with we already are playing 21 (but that wouldn't be nice)