Best 22 based on Pre Season form

[deeko 952]

The only best 22 definites (if eligible) at present for me are as follows:

FB: Jetta Dunn *****

HB: Salem Tommy HL

C: Vince Jones Viney

HF: Watts Dawes Howe

FF: Jeffy Hoges *****

R: Jamar Tyson Cross

Not sure where Watts and Howe will line up but they are definitely in for my liking.

Frost, Garland, Grimes, Toump, Gawn, Pedo, Kent, Bail, Newton, JKH, Matt Jones, Viv and Brayshaw can all fight to the death for the last couple spots and for the pine.

[P-man 13,366]

The only best 22 definites (if eligible) at present for me are as follows:

FB: Jetta Dunn *****

HB: Salem Tommy HL

C: Vince Jones Viney

HF: Watts Dawes Howe

FF: Jeffy Hoges *****

R: Jamar Tyson Cross

Not sure where Watts and Howe will line up but they are definitely in for my liking.

Frost, Garland, Grimes, Toump, Gawn, Pedo, Kent, Bail, Newton, JKH, Matt Jones, Viv and Brayshaw can all fight to the death for the last couple spots and for the pine.

And Vandenburg.

And quite possibly Stretch.

Good summation and agree with your definites. Some quality players competing for the remaining spots.

The ones I would choose at this stage are Garland, Gawn, Newton, Toumpas, Kennedy-Harris and Kent.

FB: Jetta Dunn Garland

HB: Salem T.McDonald Howe

C: Vince Jones Toumpas

HF: Watts Dawes Kent

FF: Garlett Hogan Gawn

R: Jamar Tyson Cross

Int: Lumumba Viney Newton (Kennedy-Harris)

But we all know Grimes will play. How to squeeze him in is the problem, especially if we finally have found a quality distributor in Salem.

Frost will also be strongly pushing his case I suspect.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

The only best 22 definites (if eligible) at present for me are as follows:

FB: Jetta Dunn *****

HB: Salem Tommy HL

C: Vince Jones Viney

HF: Watts Dawes Howe

FF: Jeffy Hoges *****

R: Jamar Tyson Cross

Not sure where Watts and Howe will line up but they are definitely in for my liking.

Frost, Garland, Grimes, Toump, Gawn, Pedo, Kent, Bail, Newton, JKH, Matt Jones, Viv and Brayshaw can all fight to the death for the last couple spots and for the pine.

I would put Pedo at half forward in the empty space because he can help Jamar with say 10% of the ruck work and Grimes in the back pocket for his experience.

[Winners at last 5,167]

Quite a few posters have omitted Lumumba. Surely a walk up start?

[P-man 13,366]

Quite a few posters have omitted Lumumba. Surely a walk up start?

Every team listed has Lumumba.

H, HL, Prince and Lamumba are all Lumumba.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

And Vandenburg.

And quite possibly Stretch.

Good summation and agree with your definites. Some quality players competing for the remaining spots.

The ones I would choose at this stage are Garland, Gawn, Newton, Toumpas, Kennedy-Harris and Kent.

FB: Jetta Dunn Garland

HB: Salem T.McDonald Howe

C: Vince Jones Toumpas

HF: Watts Dawes Kent

FF: Garlett Hogan Gawn

R: Jamar Tyson Cross

Int: Lumumba Viney Newton (Kennedy-Harris)

But we all know Grimes will play. How to squeeze him in is the problem, especially if we finally have found a quality distributor in Salem.

Frost will also be strongly pushing his case I suspect.

Lumumba and Viney on the pine. I would have Lumumba starting instead of Howe and Salem off half back. Viney definitely over Toumpas.

[P-man 13,366]

Lumumba and Viney on the pine. I would have Lumumba starting instead of Howe and Salem off half back. Viney definitely over Toumpas.

Doesn't make a great deal of difference if starting or on the pine these days. You're not there for long.

Going by Roos' comments, Prince will have a variety of roles as a utility off half back, through the middle and around stoppages. So not entirely sure where to place him, just that he plays.

Toumpas can provide a bit of outside run (going by his fitness reports) and whilst he has his critics, we need elite kicks of the footy as badly as Kamichael Hunt needs a decent lawyer. He's in my side for Round 1, NAB form pending.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Doesn't make a great deal of difference if starting or on the pine these days. You're not there for long.

Going by Roos' comments, Prince will have a variety of roles as a utility off half back, through the middle and around stoppages. So not entirely sure where to place him, just that he plays.

Toumpas can provide a bit of outside run (going by his fitness reports) and whilst he has his critics, we need elite kicks of the footy as badly as Kamichael Hunt needs a decent lawyer. He's in my side for Round 1, NAB form pending.

NAB from means FA to me and always has, I would agree to paying Toumpas and I say okay him for the entire year no matter how bad his form is, at least by the end of 2015 we will know where we are at with him, he has had a full preseason after all, no excuses now.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Doesn't make a great deal of difference if starting or on the pine these days. You're not there for long.

Going by Roos' comments, Prince will have a variety of roles as a utility off half back, through the middle and around stoppages. So not entirely sure where to place him, just that he plays.

Toumpas can provide a bit of outside run (going by his fitness reports) and whilst he has his critics, we need elite kicks of the footy as badly as Kamichael Hunt needs a decent lawyer. He's in my side for Round 1, NAB form pending.

a Yeah but stil l I would like to see Lumumba and Viney both on the ground when they bounce the ball round 1, both absolute competitors and will be vital to the dees in '15.

[Demon Jack 6,741]

FB: Jetta TMac Garland

HB: Salem Dunn Lumumba

C: Vince Viney Toumpas

HF: Watts Hogan Howe

FF: Garlett Dawes Kent

R: Jamar N.Jones Tyson

INT: Cross Gawn Grimes

SUB: JKH

EMG: Brayshaw Bail Fitzy

Guys like Frost, Newton and M.Jones could also find their way in the 22. The NAB Cup will be interesting to watch.

[P-man 13,366]

NAB from means FA to me and always has, I would agree to paying Toumpas and I say okay him for the entire year no matter how bad his form is, at least by the end of 2015 we will know where we are at with him, he has had a full preseason after all, no excuses now.

NAB form isn't the be all and end all. But it's an indicator. You'd rather Toumpas play well than not, especially when he has something to prove in 2015.

I agree that Toumpas needs to be given full opportunity to show his wares, but I wouldn't give him a cart blanche for the entire year. Every player need to earn their spot. If he isn't performing then he goes to Casey and fights for his spot. Hopefully he hits the ground running.

a Yeah but stil l I would like to see Lumumba and Viney both on the ground when they bounce the ball round 1, both absolute competitors and will be vital to the dees in '15.

Fair call. Main thing is they are both comfortably best 22.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

NAB form isn't the be all and end all. But it's an indicator. You'd rather Toumpas play well than not, especially when he has something to prove in 2015.

I agree that Toumpas needs to be given full opportunity to show his wares, but I wouldn't give him a cart blanche for the entire year. Every player need to earn their spot. If he isn't performing then he goes to Casey and fights for his spot. Hopefully he hits the ground running.

Fair call. Main thing is they are both comfortably best 22.

Yeah I agree with you mate... I don't like seeing people play half the year at Casey and half the year in the red and blue, it's hard to know what sort of year they have had. We need to take the approach we have nothing to loose but everything to gain in 2015.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

NAB form isn't the be all and end all. But it's an indicator. You'd rather Toumpas play well than not, especially when he has something to prove in 2015.

I agree that Toumpas needs to be given full opportunity to show his wares, but I wouldn't give him a cart blanche for the entire year. Every player need to earn their spot. If he isn't performing then he goes to Casey and fights for his spot. Hopefully he hits the ground running.

Fair call. Main thing is they are both comfortably best 22.

I'm worried about Toumpas is 2015, if he has a bad year, the pressure is on him and it will be a big challenge to him whether he can live up to expectations or not.

[Winners at last 5,167]

Every team listed has Lumumba.

H, HL, Prince and Lamumba are all Lumumba.

Oh, duffer me!!!

[What 18,810]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-02-23/fantasys-most-popular-picks

Seems like theres some hype for Aaron Vandenberg from opposition fans

Must admit I know little about him, well besides that hes a big midfielder whos AFL ready in body size.

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-02-23/fantasys-most-popular-picks

Seems like theres some hype for Aaron Vandenberg from opposition fans

Must admit I know little about him, well besides that hes a big midfielder whos AFL ready in body size.

Hype?

It's a fantasy footy article..

[What 18,810]

Hype?

It's a fantasy footy article..

Yeah I know, and i hate fantasy footy,

But it says hes one of the most popular picks in fantasy footy sides, why would that be?

[mo64 5,514]

FB: Jetta Dunn Howe

HB: Lumumba T. Mac Salem

C: Toumpas Tyson Newton

HF: Watts Dawes Vince

FF: Garlett Hogan JKH

Ruck: Jamar N.Jones Viney

Int: Gawn, Cross, Grimes, M.Jones

Unlike most, I'm not convinced about Kent as a mid just yet, and I believe that JKH has greater potential to be a mid. He'd be battling with M.Jones for a spot on the bench.

Rotations:

Grimes rotates with Jetta, Lumumba, Salem.

Cross rotates with N.Jones, Tyson, Viney.

M.Jones rotates with Toumpas, Newton, Vince.

Gawn rotates with Jamar, Dawes, Hogan.

N.Jones, Tyson, Viney have spells in the forward line.

Lumumba, Newton, Vince, JKH, Cross all being part of the midfield rotation.

Edited February 23, 2015 by mo64

[Go the Biff 3,360]

So if this is supposed to be based on pre-season form, why do people have Vince in their team ?

All he's done is run laps !

[mo64 5,514]

So if this is supposed to be based on pre-season form, why do people have Vince in their team ?

All he's done is run laps !

Because he'd still be more useful than some of the other options.

I doubt that he'll play round 1, but he's a certainty to be picked if fit.

[P-man 13,366]

Yeah I know, and i hate fantasy footy,

But it says hes one of the most popular picks in fantasy footy sides, why would that be?

It means he should earn people some money in fantasy footy compared to other similarly priced rookies, which can simply mean he will get gametime. I wouldn't label it as "hype".

[rjay 24,632]

Unlike most, I'm not convinced about Kent as a mid just yet, and I believe that JKH has greater potential to be a mid. He'd be battling with M.Jones for a spot on the bench.

I think it's a big year for Kent to establish himself. I don't see him as a walk up for game one unless he has some impressive NAB form.

[Bobby McKenzie 2,332]

FB: Jetta Dunn Howe

HB: Lumumba T. Mac Salem

C: Toumpas Tyson Newton

HF: Watts Dawes Vince

FF: Garlett Hogan JKH

Ruck: Jamar N.Jones Viney

Int: Gawn, Cross, Grimes, M.Jones

Unlike most, I'm not convinced about Kent as a mid just yet, and I believe that JKH has greater potential to be a mid. He'd be battling with M.Jones for a spot on the bench.

Rotations:

Grimes rotates with Jetta, Lumumba, Salem.

Cross rotates with N.Jones, Tyson, Viney.

M.Jones rotates with Toumpas, Newton, Vince.

Gawn rotates with Jamar, Dawes, Hogan.

N.Jones, Tyson, Viney have spells in the forward line.

Lumumba, Newton, Vince, JKH, Cross all being part of the midfield rotation.

You don't rate Bail despite him playing most games last season?

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Garlett will still be wearing the navy blue (and white) come round 1, so perhaps exclude him. Has some lose ends to tie up before joining us:

Edited February 24, 2015 by The Song Formerly Known As

[old dee 23,506]

You don't rate Bail despite him playing most games last season?

In a team that won four games it is not that big of a wrap BM.

Would he get a game at the 16 sides above us?