David Schwarz

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

I am assuming the ox is passionate about helping out but probably doesn't know much about the behind the scenes of a footy club. Bring the ox in where his passion is best served. Involve him with the players, mentoring forwards and young players and let the ox learn the ropes of a footy department. Don't throw him to the deep end in a already poorly run department.

[dees189227 12,464]

and the difference between the both, so what you are saying is only the Ox can tell the blunt truth but Neeld cannot???

No I meant what the Ox said about Neeld and his coaching. Im not sure Neeld would want to work along side a guy who doesnt think much of him. We all know Neeld can speak the truth and I applaud him for that.

[The heart beats true 18,189]

It's a no for the experience reasons mentioned previously.

I do think he should get involved at board level. I think he'd tell a few home truths.

For what it's worth I think that the senior coaching role needs to be changed psychologically but a lot of the rest of the positions are really hard to evaluate given that the previous CEO had everyone's balls in his purse. It's hard to judge Josh Mahoney and Craig's roles externally anyways, but even more difficult given our previous management 'structure'.

[Craig Drinker 179]

When do you think Jackson will start ringing in the changes? I don't think we will have to wait too long

Maybe a couple more weeks at the most?

[Guest]

For what it's worth I think that the senior coaching role needs to be changed psychologically but a lot of the rest of the positions are really hard to evaluate given that the previous CEO had everyone's balls in his purse.

Apparently, CS was the second coming of Rick James. You were star struck by him. Maybe his aura was orange as well?

[rjay 25,362]

I made the suggestion of Peter Schwab earlier, anyone know what he is doing now? He was running AFL Victoria a few years back.

[dees189227 12,464]

How did Josh Mahoney go from forward line coach to footy manager? Its like we wanted to get rid of Josh but instead we thought hang on why not put him in charge of the department.

[DemonOX 8,837]

It's a gamble, I'll say that.

B)

Comment is in very bad taste chook.

[rjay 25,362]

How did Josh Mahoney go from forward line coach to footy manager? Its like we wanted to get rid of Josh but instead we thought hang on why not put him in charge of the department.

He studying his MBA so I guess that was enough for him to get an assistant mangers role which he effectively was. We need a real football savvy person in this role and someone with experience.

[Chook 15,026]

Comment is in very bad taste chook.

The man has had gambling problems, but let's not be above making jokes please? It's part of what makes living in a free world great.

I've heard it said that comedy = tragedy + time

[DemonOX 8,837]

The man has had gambling problems, but let's not be above making jokes please? It's part of what makes living in a free world great.

I've heard it said that comedy = tragedy + time

Not above making jokes but there are things that u don't need to joke about.

I am sure his family would think it hilarious.

[Chook 15,026]

Not above making jokes but there are things that u don't need to joke about.

I am sure his family would think it hilarious.

I don't want to get into a big thing with you here, but suffice it to say that there are very few things in the world you shouldn't be allowed to joke about. Gambling debts do not fall into that category.

[DemonOX 8,837]

I don't want to get into a big thing with you here, but suffice it to say that there are very few things in the world you shouldn't be allowed to joke about. Gambling debts do not fall into that category.

I agree there are things u shouldn't joke about and this is one of them.

We ain't going to agree on this one chook.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I made the suggestion of Peter Schwab earlier, anyone know what he is doing now? He was running AFL Victoria a few years back.

Terrific bloke as honest as they come.

I doubt he would be interested and he is a Hawks man through and through.

I agree there are things u shouldn't joke about and this is one of them.

We ain't going to agree on this one chook.

Agree D'Ox. I think the Ox should be congratulated for gettiing his life back on track not have to deal with witless slurs on his past.

Having said that I dont think he is Board or Chairman material by a long shot.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,460]

I love Schwarz but exactly what experience/qualifications does he have to head the FD??? Get him back at the club sure but give home something within his capabilities.

[rjay 25,362]

Terrific bloke as honest as they come.

I doubt he would be interested and he is a Hawks man through and through.

Agree D'Ox. I think the Ox should be congratulated for gettiing his life back on track not have to deal with witless slurs on his past.

Having said that I dont think he is Board or Chairman material by a long shot.

Yep, he is a great Hawk... but this is the calibre of person we need at the club and not being an ex MFC person would be a bonus.

[DemonOX 8,837]

Agree D'Ox. I think the Ox should be congratulated for gettiing his life back on track not have to deal with witless slurs on his past.

Having said that I dont think he is Board or Chairman material by a long shot.

I honestly think he would make a great Prez RR with good people behind him.

He would unite all the supporters and would be great with the sponsors. I don't think I have ever spoken to a Dees supporter who has not liked the Ox.

One last thing he would bring the PASSION back to the club in spades.

[bing181 9,436]

When do you think Jackson will start ringing in the changes? I don't think we will have to wait too long

Maybe a couple more weeks at the most?

Think you're going to be disappointed.

Just for starters, if we want people who are already at other clubs - which you would think would be likely given the emphasis on "experience" - they're not going to move till the end of the season.

I feel that the main role we need to finalise is that of CEO. Hard to imagine someone joining us as head of football, reporting to the CEO ... if they don't even know who that person is.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I honestly think he would make a great Prez RR with good people behind him.

He would unite all the supporters and would be great with the sponsors. I don't think I have ever spoken to a Dees supporter who has not liked the Ox.

One last thing he would bring the PASSION back to the club in spades.

There are other attributes you need to be President beside passion.

And I note that you think he would need good people behind him. Its valid qualification.

MFC need better than that. We need a President who has the attributes to be one and not dependent on other catching him if he falls.

[Giles 184]

and the difference between the both, so what you are saying is only the Ox can tell the blunt truth but Neeld cannot???

I've always thought Neeld has been speaking the truth as he knew it at Collingwood. Been external from the start. And we welcomed it.

[Demoneyes 562]

CEO is one P Jackson and in it for a longer haul than expected!

Think you're going to be disappointed.

Just for starters, if we want people who are already at other clubs - which you would think would be likely given the emphasis on "experience" - they're not going to move till the end of the season.

I feel that the main role we need to finalise is that of CEO. Hard to imagine someone joining us as head of football, reporting to the CEO ... if they don't even know who that person is.

[ThreeOneSix 954]

OX would be great in this role, he has a wealth of knowledge and would be really good for the club and the kids.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,460]

CEO is one P Jackson and in it for a longer haul than expected!

Now that I would be glad to hear and was the impression I got from his interviews over the weekend.

[btdemon 482]

This is a joke right!

I love the Ox and love listening to him but he is neither a great strategist or leader. Affable yes, likeable yes, amusing yes, a great player, most certainly, but a FD manager or president? You've got to be joking!

[prymke19 42]

This is a joke right!

I love the Ox and love listening to him but he is neither a great strategist or leader. Affable yes, likeable yes, amusing yes, a great player, most certainly, but a FD manager or president? You've got to be joking!

I don't think coaching experience or uni degrees are necessary to head a fd.. Actually what we seem to lack in our fd are people with heart and drive and thirst for hard work. I think ox brings this to the table and the sooner he is involved the better. We can get these experienced people to replace the other useless fd staff after the season ends. Happy for ox to head the fd, think he will help to improve the culture and let's see how he evolves in the role, can't be worse than what we have now.