Your votes please!

Just don't know why we bother....

Terlich

Gawnius maximus

Sylvia

Evans

Edited April 28, 201312 yr by monoccular

6 Byrnes

5 Grimes

4 Tierlich

3 Sylvia

2 Evans

1 Watts

Edited April 28, 201312 yr by waynewussell

6. Byrnes

5. Garland

4. Terlich

3. Sylvia

2. Gawn

1. Watts

6.Byrnes
5.Terlich
4.Sylvia
3.Watts

2.Trengove

1.Gawn

Sylvia

Byrnes

Matt Jones

Garland

Grimes

Watts

Byrnes

Garland

Gawn

Sylvia

Tapscott

Evans

Edited April 28, 201312 yr by Pennant St Dee

Garland

Tapscott

Frawley

Evans

Byrnes

Bail

This exercise gets harder by the week. Sadly, the top six on the ground all played for the opposition.

6. Garland

5. Evans

4. Byrnes

3. Sylvia

2. Gawn

1. Tapscott

Watts kicked a couple of goals and looked better forward, but he was so bloody lazy today, refused to run and chase again and again. Imagine if he was playing under Joel Selwood and put in the efforts he did today, none of his teammates would even talk to him.

How anyone can give him votes is beyond me.

6. Garland

5. Sylvia

4. Bail

3. Byrnes

2. Gawn

1. Grimes

EDIT: Notable mention to the umpires who gave Melbourne the rub of the green.

Edited April 28, 201312 yr by Clint Bizkit

6 garland

5 byrnes

4 sylvia

3 trengove

2 watts

1 gawn

Terlich
Byrnes
Sylvia
M.Jones
Pickles

Watts

6 . Moloney - 35 possies. Really worked a treat and was back to his best today and really drove the side forward....Oh wait we ditched him.

5, Garland.

4, Gawn

3. Terlich

2. Evans

1. Watts

6. Byrnes

5. Terlich

4. Sylvia

3. Watts

2. Gawn

1. Evans

6- Garland

5- Byrnes

4- Gawn

3- Sylvia

2- Frawley

1- Evans

6. Garland

5. Gawn

4. Terlich

3. Byrnes

2. Evans

1. Watts

Col Garland back to his best today.

Gawn seemed to run harder and faster than most of our small men.

Terlich coughs it up a bit but has a genuine crack at every contest.

Hopefully Watts will get a bit of confidence from his two goals, the second of which was a ripper.

6. Garland (assured and confident)

5. Byrnes (close to our best but lost points for kicking to man on mark at crucial stage)

4. Trengove (worked hard all day)

3. Gawn (played well and boosts team)

2. Silvia (worked hard especially when momentum against us)

1. Evans (really rate the guy)

I also thought Jamar was pretty good, Grimes kicking let him down, Frawley kept J Brown quiet,, Tappy added quite a bit and Rodan worked hard but struggled to find space.

6. Garland

5. Byrnes

4. Terlich

3. Grimes

2. Evans

1. Sylvia

Honerable mentions to Jamar, N.Jones, Gawn and Watts.

6. Garland

5. Terlich

4. Gawn

3. Evans

2. Sylvia

1. Byrnes

I'm all for Terlich getting votes, but he remains in my mind a liability to the side due to his awful ball use. I have absolutely no confidence in him any time he has the ball, just none. I do like his endeavour, run and strength, though, so hopefully if he can work on his disposal he'll be a useful long term player. Right now, I just cringe whenever I see him pick it up and take off.

6- Garland

5- Sylvia

4- Byrnes

3- M.Jones

2. Evans

1. Watts

Grimes and Trengove let me down a bit too much today

Anyone who votes Terlich as the best is looking at the stats sheet and not the actual game. His disposal and decision-making needs a hell of alot of work. But he tries and he cares, so good on him.

Comfortable top two were:

6. Garland

5. Byrnes

4. Gawn

3. Evans

2. Sylvia

1. Terlich

6 Byrnes

5 Garland

4 Terlich

3 Sylvia

2 Watts

1 Evans

6. Garland

5. Byrnes

4. Terlich

3. Evans

2. Gawn

1. Sylvia