Time to release Trengove as Captain and let him realise his full potential as a B-Grade midfielder

[Sleeve 67]

Today was his 64th game, he is coming off a very serious injury, clearly underdone and a massive off field distraction and those are the factors we know of.

he has had what 17 touches 10 tackles i'd say that's acceptable

the biggest problem is we expect him to play like a 164 game player, he isn't it's a big effort to be out there at all

Not where i'd like him to be as a footballer either but to say he is deserving of the comments that are being made about him is insane.

Your dancing around the major issues like a bad politician.

The fact remains he's struggling and he's an integral part of our side,

It says a lot about the state if our club, which is what i take outbid the OP's

slant. Martin, Rohan, Cunnington , Fyfe, are making hay in less than

Impressive football sides.

10 tackles is all well and good, quality possession along with that is better.

It isn't there and not is our midfield.

[waynewussell 5,748]

Reminds me of the conversation we had here about Brock. Where is he these days?

[waynewussell 5,748]

Come to think of it, there were a lot who wanted to get rid of Moloney on last season's form.

[Soidee 1,496]

Another one of Neelds failures. Neeld has screwed any half decent player on this list.

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

I am struggling to see what attributes he brings that will make him great.

I think his overhead marking for his size is something he excels at, but besides that, I would say he is below par in all other areas.

He isn't really a great clearance player or have speed to spread on the outside, so I am left wondering what is it that will make him great for us?

[Tricky 341]

Reminds me of the conversation we had here about Brock. Where is he these days?

Was thinking that myself...shudder.

[ThreeOneSix 954]

He got rewarded the captaincy coming off a bad year.

I think a B-Grade midfielder is a fair assessment, if he could live up to that, I'd take it.

[rjay 24,928]

I don't rate a lot of what Mathews says, but his one comment I do agree with is what has happened to the player we had in season one, where has his leg speed gone. It's not just leg speed that's at issue now it's decision making when he has the ball, this wasn't a problem in his first season. It's not that he was lightning quick but he could cover ground and use the ball well.

Unfortunately the FD and coach seem married to the idea of him as captain and it just may not be the right thing. What are they going to do? nothing of course. It would prove them wrong and you can't have that.

I hope Jack has some really good advisors outside of the club that he can trust, who is his manager? He needs to work out what is the right thing for him and if that's stepping down then he should no matter what the club say. A kid who is just making his way in football doesn't need this pressure but if his people (not the club) say it is not having an adverse effect then he should stay the course.

From the outside looking in it seems to be effecting his football and we need him to develop into the player he is capable of being and that's not a B-Grade mid.

[Watts Jurrah Dunn? 735]

The club is going no where in a hurry with Grimes, Trengove and McKenzie in the midfield.

They don't have the bodies to compete as inside midfielders, nor the skills or pace to hurt the opposition on the outside.

They are just good ordinary players.

[rhaz 342]

The excuse of being "underdone" is running into a second year. Why isn't he rested then?

He had a mare today. Looks slow and clumsy.

[Deemotivated 550]

The club is going no where in a hurry with Grimes, Trengove and McKenzie in the midfield.

They don't have the bodies to compete as inside midfielders, nor the skills or pace to hurt the opposition on the outside.

They are just good ordinary players.

Grimes is an attacking halfback that can rotate through the guts when required but should not be a permanent mid.

Trenners is not currently the player we had hoped for weather that's captaincy, injury/fitness or skill set I don't know. I still have faith in him for the future.

McKenzie is a stopper and that's it. His disposal is just crap.

The captaincy appointments were a bloody awful decision but its done and they'll stick with them for at least this year. We need our experienced guys to stand up this year and support the jacks.

[Giles 181]

Essendon (Watson)

Port Adelaide (Boak)

Geelong (Selwood)

Hawthorn (Hodge)

Sydney (Jack, McVeigh)

Richmond (Cotchin)

Fremantle (Pavlich)

Collingwood (Maxwell)

Carlton (Murphy)

Adelaide (van Berlo)

Gold Coast Suns (Ablett)

Brisbane Lions (Brown, Adcock)

North Melbourne (Swallow)

St Kilda (Riewoldt)

West Coast (Glass)

Western Bulldogs (Boyd)

Melbourne (Grimes, Trengove)

GWS (Davis, Ward)

[chookrat 4,250]

Trengove is an excellent choice for co-captian and I think will be of the best players (most inflential in winnig) in the league in the next 5 years. He does the team things, is tough, works hard is consistent and can be relied on to lift in key moments. As the team improves he will look better.

A real positive I took from today about our direction is Silvias work rate. I think this is a reflection of more acountable culture.

[Mac7 309]

Delist. Bad draft pick. Their is nothing that he has shown to indicate he will be an AFL standard player. Slow, poor kick, can not kick long, poor awareness and uninspiring as a teammate. He was never seen as a high draft pick until late in the national championships, and Melbourne got caught up in the hype of his SANFL finals game. He was an early developer that could play well against jouniers or state players, but not up to it. Can't believe he was gifted the captaincy as a marketing play, embarrassing as a club. Should not play AFL again, cut the loses and move on.

What a load of over reaction crap. Drip.

[Matt Demon 1,431]

Love his tackling but that's about all he's offering at the moment.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Trenners is the least of our worries being only 21 years of age, no pre-season, average 16-20 disposals per game with 6 tackles and generally quite a reliable goal kicker.
Next topic please...

Edited April 28, 2013 by The Song Formerly Known As

[Yourenextdipper 19]

Trenners is the least of our worries being only 21 years of age, no pre-season, average 16-20 disposals per game with 6 tackles and generally quite a reliable goal kicker.

Next topic please...

As a fourth year midfielder, regardless of draft pick, he is below average. To think that he was pick number 2 and gifted the captaincy is shocking.

[Hero1 74]

Trengove is dud and a spud. There is no way this guy deserved to be a number two draft pick. He is a joke player. Jack watts looks lost on the field except when he goes forward when he can slot goals. Grimes needs to stop kicking the ball direct to the opposition. We need our 2 tall forwards back desperately. Hopefully we can trade well at the end of the year.

[binman 42,972]

Delist. Bad draft pick. Their is nothing that he has shown to indicate he will be an AFL standard player. Slow, poor kick, can not kick long, poor awareness and uninspiring as a teammate. He was never seen as a high draft pick until late in the national championships, and Melbourne got caught up in the hype of his SANFL finals game. He was an early developer that could play well against jouniers or state players, but not up to it. Can't believe he was gifted the captaincy as a marketing play, embarrassing as a club. Should not play AFL again, cut the loses and move on.

Troll. Goodbye.

[Giles 181]

Essendon (Watson)

Port Adelaide (Boak)

Geelong (Selwood)

Hawthorn (Hodge)

Sydney (Jack, McVeigh)

Richmond (Cotchin)

Fremantle (Pavlich)

Collingwood (Maxwell)

Carlton (Murphy)

Adelaide (van Berlo)

Gold Coast Suns (Ablett)

Brisbane Lions (Brown, Adcock)

North Melbourne (Swallow)

St Kilda (Riewoldt)

West Coast (Glass)

Western Bulldogs (Boyd)

Melbourne (Grimes, Trengove)

GWS (Davis, Ward)

Point being, where do you rate him in the competition as an onfield leader / performer / inspirer? Is it the long goals, the gut running, the run down chases, the pack marks, the smothers... or maybe the blistering bursts through the centre... What is it that you see that I don't that see that grants his captaincy... I have no doubt he's trying hard. His performances at press conferences are second to none.

[Hero1 74]

Trengove is too small. Grimes clearly pulls out on contests gutless gutless gutless both of them. How long so we have to suffer this crap?

[Hero1 74]

Clever response

[Hero1 74]

He's z grade not b

[Roost It 1,434]

Clever response

Talking to you I didn't feel the need to be clever.

[Roost It 1,434]

He's z grade not b

Now that's clever