Changes vs Brisbane

[Damo 3,376]

We certainly cant have Watts and Strauss both squibbing it in the back half.

Watts Gawn and Davey in the forward line might very well work.

Anyway, its the last stop before Casey for Watts.

Gawn goes hard for contested spillages and it might galvanize Jack Watts.

[leehow 303]

Can someone tell me who Spencer rucked against at Essendon? I've read a few ppl say he dominated against a quality ruckmen. Hille and Bellchambers were in the seniors and Ryder was suspended, so not sure who it would have been.

Edited April 23, 2013 by leehow

[Satyriconhome 10,879]

Why is Merrett playing up forward for the Lions, we putting a team of midgets in our forward line are we.

There is also a pic on Twitter from 2 days ago with Sellar with a pressure bandage on his right calf so might be sore

"Watts and Strauss squibbing",some posters must really watch the game through beer goggles, Watts did some excellent presure work last week without being caught out, going to ground etc, you don't have to crash and bash to create pressure, that is why some commentators use the words implied pressure....the coaches must see something we don't see whouldn't you say, one week out and straight back in.

Also Strauss was excellent for Casey in the game I watched live

The only in that I can put down as definite in my opinion is McKenzie

[Satyriconhome 10,879]

Can someone tell me who Spencer rucked against at Essendon? I've read a few ppl say he dominated against a quality ruckmen. Hille and Bellchambers were in the seniors and Ryder was suspended, so not sure who it would have been.

Watched him live, he was better than the Essendon ruckman (don't know who it was) and this showed in the tap work, but it was all his other work, he was all over the ground, did one of his famous chases of a smaller player down the wing (which had contingent of Casey/MFC supporters applauding him when he came to the bench just after), did some good work when he was resting in the goal square, and defending

Stats: Jake Spencer 10 kicks, 9 handballs, 19 disposals, 3 marks, 7 tackles, 36 hit outs, 0 goals, 1 behind.

MFC website review Jake Spencer: Jake had a real impact on this game. His work ethic to compete in all aspects was really pleasing. He had 19 disposals, 37 hit outs, as well as six tackles, which was a great return, (slightly different stats)

Again spoken to coaches about him, they just want him to develop his game when resting forward, this is only area they regard as 'lacking', Max Gawn has jump on him in this area

Edited April 23, 2013 by Satyriconhome

[prymke19 42]

We certainly cant have Watts and Strauss both squibbing it in the back half.Watts Gawn and Davey in the forward line might very well work.Anyway, its the last stop before Casey for Watts.Gawn goes hard for contested spillages and it might galvanize Jack Watts.

Watts + Strauss = private school soft

[leehow 303]

Watched him live, he was better than the Essendon ruckman (don't know who it was) and this showed in the tap work, but it was all his other work, he was all over the ground, did one of his famous chases of a smaller player down the wing (which had contingent of Casey/MFC supporters applauding him when he came to the bench just after), did some good work when he was resting in the goal square, and defending

Stats: Jake Spencer 10 kicks, 9 handballs, 19 disposals, 3 marks, 7 tackles, 36 hit outs, 0 goals, 1 behind.

MFC website review Jake Spencer: Jake had a real impact on this game. His work ethic to compete in all aspects was really pleasing. He had 19 disposals, 37 hit outs, as well as six tackles, which was a great return, (slightly different stats)

Again spoken to coaches about him, they just want him to develop his game when resting forward, this is only area they regard as 'lacking', Max Gawn has jump on him in this area

It's good to hear he had a good game. Think he has definitely improved. Can't see them playing all three big guys as others have suggested, so would think for him to get a game he's going to have to replace Jamar.

[Damo 3,376]

Better than Rose coloured glasses...

Watts does do some things well but he scouts the pack and doesnt attack the ball too often.

We are better with Jack Watts than without him IMO, but he needs understand he isnt David Rhys-Jones who only looked like he was half hearted. Gawn eagerly fights for the pill which would put the acid on Jack if they were both deep in the forward line.

[PJ_12345 1,098]

Watts + Strauss = private school soft

You = a bigot

Strauss has come back from a shoulder reconstruction and a more recent broken leg- tell me how that is soft.

Edited April 24, 2013 by PJ_12345

[dbj1983 138]

Watts + Strauss = private school soft

Stupid comment. Judd, Goddard, Watson and Ball all went to Private schools and they are not soft!

[prymke19 42]

Stupid comment. Judd, Goddard, Watson and Ball all went to Private schools and they are not soft!

Youre right also hannebury, viney, many more as well. Im wrong.

[prymke19 42]

Stupid comment. Judd, Goddard, Watson and Ball all went to Private schools and they are not soft!

You = a bigot

Strauss has come back from a shoulder reconstruction and a more recent broken leg- tell me how that is soft.

Can't imagine either will be on our list next year though.

[PJ_12345 1,098]

Can't imagine either will be on our list next year though.

Watts will still be contracted next year

Strauss is yet to play more than two games but still retains alot of interest from other clubs - might want to give him a chance to prove himself?

[Robbie57 2,022]

Dunn in down back and can play forward if required.

Watts to run throught the middle or down forward.

Davey as sub.

McKenzie in.

Strauss in.

[McQueen 17,867]

What will be interesting is to see if Jamar can back up last weeks good performance. Having Gawn as the extra big man in the team may have given him the spells he need throughout the game to maintain a decent work rate and influence contests. With the loss of Clark though that may upset the balance so I'm tipping Spencer will get a guernsey this weekend.

In: Spencer, McKenzie, Kent

Out: Clark, Jetta, Viney

A lot of conjecture about Kents defensive work has been interesting reading. However, on the back of that last quarter effort (against GWS) on Sunday, I can see a player like Kent carving it up and driving the ball into the forward 50 similar to Daniel Rich.

Give the kid a go as a sub at least.

Edited April 24, 2013 by McQueen

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

Who does Mckenzie go to assuming he plays? Rich, rockliff, moloney, zorko, black? not sure which other mids they have.

James frawley has a huge job with jonothan brown

[Satyriconhome 10,879]

Kent would replace either Bail. Evans or Tapscott, can't see it happening

[dee-luded 2,959]

Dean Terlich stays in. Couple of 2nd and 3 efforts on sunday in the last Q were great.

Reward him for it and encourage the same.

totally.

we can't drop anyone who is having a 'fair dinkum' crack at the contests.

We are approaching the business games, after the Lions game... a run of 6 important games, starting with the 'Blues', & ending with the QB/day game, followed by our midseason bye.

... we need to get Blease in for the Carlton game, after a couple of weeks of solid form, from both Blease @ Casey, & our senior team...

if watts is still in this week, he'd make a good swap for Blease, against the Blues... different types I know, but neither at this point, are main bearings of the drive train. We need as many drivers right now,,, & we can add the flair, along the journey.

[PaulRB 6,411]

I'd be hoping Clark and Dawes will be ready for the Carlton game.

[dee-luded 2,959]

I think a few here have gone for this -

In Blease McKenzie, Strauss

Out Jetta (suspended) Viney (rest) Clark (ankle)

I would move Jack Watts forward but accept that's probably unlikely based on the coach's apparent desire to make him a defender.

Jack as I remember it watts was moved to defence because he wasn't having a crack. last year he started to improve but this year seems to have gotten Too thoughtful again.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Who does Mckenzie go to assuming he plays? Rich, rockliff, moloney, zorko, black? not sure which other mids they have.

James frawley has a huge job with jonothan brown

I'd like to see him go to Black. I rate Rich and Rockliff more highly, but Black always tears us up.

[PaulRB 6,411]

I'd like to see one of our mids given the role of nailing N Jones tag at every opportunity...

[rjay 25,093]

I'd like to see him go to Black. I rate Rich and Rockliff more highly, but Black always tears us up.

...and if Black was playing that would be a good call but he's yet to play a game this year.

by the way there is no way if he was playing you could rate Rich or Rockliff more highly,Black is one of the great players of the modern game.

Edited April 24, 2013 by rjay

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

...and if Black was playing that would be a good call but he's yet to play a game this year.

by the way there is no way if he was playing you could rate Rich or Rockliff more highly,Black is one of the great players of the modern game.

I've read several reports saying Black is a chance to play this weekend.

I don't think Rich and Rockliff will ever reach the heights that Black did, and there's no doubt that Black is one of the greatest mids in the last 25 years. At this point in his career, though, I don't see him as being as good as Rich or Rockliff. While he is still very good, he is not the player he once was. He is 34, after all.

[rjay 25,093]

I've read several reports saying Black is a chance to play this weekend.

I don't think Rich and Rockliff will ever reach the heights that Black did, and there's no doubt that Black is one of the greatest mids in the last 25 years. At this point in his career, though, I don't see him as being as good as Rich or Rockliff. While he is still very good, he is not the player he once was. He is 34, after all.

If he does play we will have to keep a close watch, as you say he has taken us apart many times in the past. Rich seems to be the one getting the tag these days and is not handling it well, if he is let loose like in the NAB series he is dangerous.

Sorry for reading your post the wrong way, Black is often underrated for such a great player, I love watching him play but hopefully we don't get to see him this weekend.

[DeeZee 7,445]

Terlich will stay in all year, unless injured, mark my words.