2012 Draft Top 10: Nearest the pin comp.

[Guest NoMoreMrNiceGuy]

A week to go until the big dance. Let's see who can drop a tee-shot near the cup.

1. Whitfield (GWS)

2. Grundy (GWS)

3. Toumpas (GWS)

4. Wines (MFC)

5. O'Rourke (Dogs)

6. Plowman (Dogs)

7. Mayes (Port)

8. Macrae (Bris)

9. Stringer (Rich)

10. Daniher (Ess)

[Brayshaw Self 847]

1. Whitfield (GWS)

2. Grundy (GWS)

3. Toumpas (GWS)

4. Wines (MFC)

5. O'Rourke (Dogs)

6. Stringer (Dogs)

7. Mayes (Port)

8. Plowman (Bris)

9. Macrae (Rich)

10. Daniher (Ess)

[olisik 4,060]

1. Whitfield (GWS)

2. Toumpas (GWS)

3. Plowman (GWS)

4. Wines (MFC)

5. O'Rourke (Dogs)

6. Stringer (Dogs)

7. Mayes (Port)

8. Macrae (Bris)

9. Grundy (Rich)

10. Daniher (Ess)

[Clark_Kent 315]

1. Whitfield

2. Toumpas

3. Plowman

4. Wines

5. O'Rourke

6. Menzel

7. Grundy

8. Macrae

9. Mayes

10. Daniher

[red and blue forever 807]

1. Whitfield (gws)

2. Grundy (gws)

3. Toumpas (gws)

4. Wines. (Melb)

5. O'Rourke (dog)

6. Plowman (dog)

7. Stringer (port

8. Mayes (bris)

9. Macrae (rich)

10. Daniher (Ess)

[Og Seed 3]

1. Whitfield (GWS)

2. Toumpas (GWS)

3. O'Rourke (GWS)

4. Wines (MELB)

5. Grundy (WBD)

6. Plowman (WBD)

7. Mayes (PORT)

8. Macrae (BRIS)

9. Stringer (RICH)

10. Daniher (ESS)

[dee-luded 2,958]

A week to go until the big dance. Let's see who can drop a tee-shot near the cup.

I'll have a blind shot at it.

ROUND ONE

1. Greater Western Sydney - Whitfield

2. Greater Western Sydney - Toumpas

3. Greater Western Sydney - Plowman

4. Melbourne (GWS compensation - Tom Scully) - Wines

5. Western Bulldogs - O’Rourke

6. Western Bulldogs (GWS compensation - Callan Ward) - Kristian Jaksch

7. Port Adelaide - Brodie Grundy

8. Brisbane Lions - Jake Stringer

9. Richmond - Jackson Macrae

10. Essendon (father-son selection committed to Joe Daniher)

[The Lobster Effect 845]

I want to pose another question, what would the top 10 look like if the draft wasn't compromised, i.e no 17 year old selections last year and no father son.

So the actual ten best undrafted 18 year olds in order, as opposed to factoring in club selections.

Would it be something like:

1. Whitfield

2. Daniher

3. O'Meara

4. Toumpas

5. Crouch

6. Grundy

7. O'Rourke

8. Viney

9. Wines

10. Plowman

[Guest NoMoreMrNiceGuy]

I want to pose another question, what would the top 10 look like if the draft wasn't compromised, i.e no 17 year old selections last year and no father son.

So the actual ten best undrafted 18 year olds in order, as opposed to factoring in club selections.

Would it be something like:

1. Whitfield

2. Daniher

3. O'Meara

4. Toumpas

5. Crouch

6. Grundy

7. O'Rourke

8. Viney

9. Wines

10. Plowman

Let's not confuse the thread TLE. Suggest start a new one if you want to ask that question.

[GrandOld 367]

1. Whitfield

2. Toumpas

3. Menzel

4. Wines

5. O'Rourke

6. Stringer

7. Grundy

8. Garlett

9. Vlastuin

10. Daniher

[Hannibal 5,814]

1. Whitfield (GWS)

2. Toumpas (GWS)

3. Plowman (GWS)

4. O'Rourke (MELB)

5. Macrae (WBD)

6. Mayes (WBD)

7. Grundy (PORT)

8. Wines (BRIS)

9. Vlastuin (RICH)

10. Daniher (ESS)

[Arrow 1,257]

Whitfield

Toumpas

Plowman

Wines

Macrae

Stringer

Grundy

O'Rourke

Jaksch

Daniher

[The Lobster Effect 845]

Let's not confuse the thread TLE. Suggest start a new one if you want to ask that question.

ok fair enough...

[BIG JIM 508]

1. Whitfield

2. Wines

3. Plowman

4. Toumpas ( part of the hogan deal)

5. O'Rourke

6. Grundy

7. Mayes

8. Menzel

9. Vlastuin

10. Daniher (FS)

[Tatu 416]

1. Whitfield

2. Grundy

3. Toumpas

4. Stringer

5. O'Rourke

6. Plowman

7. Mayes

8. Wines

9. Macrae

10. Daniher

[Supreme_Demon 3,065]

This is my tip for the top 10 in the 2012 AFL National Draft. I think that GWS have more than enough midfielders and they will take Grundy to help their ruck stocks and Plowman to help their embattled defence. Leaving the Demons to swoop on Toumpas.

1) Whitfield (GWS Giants)

2) Grundy (GWS Giants)

3) Plowman (GWS Giants)

4) Toumpas (Melbourne Demons)

5) O'Rourke (Western Bulldogs)

6) Stringer (Western Bulldogs)

7) Wines (Port Adelaide Power)

8) Macrae (Brisbane Lions)

9) Menzel (Richmond Tigers)

10) Daniher (Essendon Bombers)

Either way, I'll be happy with the Demons getting either Toumpas, Wines or O'Rourke with our number 4 pick.

Edited November 15, 2012 by Supreme_Demon

[Alcho Dee 269]

WHITFIELD GWS

TOUMPAS GWS

GRUNDY GWS

WINES MEL

MAYES WB

STRINGER WB

MACRAE POR

O ROURKE RIC

MENZEL BRIS

DANNIHER ESS

[hayz 27]

1. Whitfield (GWS)

2. Toumpas (GWS)

3. Plowman (GWS)

4. Wines (Melb)

5. O' Rourke (WB)

6. Stringer (WB)

7. Grundy (Port)

8. Macrae (Bris)

9. Vlastuin (Rich)

10. Daniher (Ess)

[Josh 1,420]

I've got my money on Daniher going No. 10 to Essendon

[Little Richard 5,943]

Whitfield

Grundy

Plowman

Wines

Toumpas

Menzel

O'Rourke

Macrae

Stringer

Daniher

[Roger Mellie 3,669]

GWS Whitfield

Toumpas

Plowman

Melb Wines

WB O'Rourke

Menzel

Port Mayes

Bris Stringer

Rich Grundy

Ess Daniher

[Little Richard 5,943]

Ps is this Range Rover?

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

1. Whitfield

2. Toumpas

3. Plowman

4. Wines

5. O'Rourke

6. Stringer

7. Grundy

8. Mayes

9. Menzel

10. Grundy

[rpfc 27,692]

Is Toumpas an inside-outside dynamic midfielder?

Because that is what we need. Outside of that I want the hardest inside mid out there.

We need some explosiveness in our midfield - but through a bloke who can win his own footy.

[stranga 328]

If we dont take Wines it would surely be one of the biggest draft surprises since Freo took Hill over Rich in 08. Nearly every news source claims we are into him in a big way so unlikely they are all wrong.

Edited November 15, 2012 by stranga