I'm a bit confused !

[Sydee 3,636]

I read the quote below from Mark Neeld and I just wonder why Cook was selected as an emergency against Richmond in Rd 15 if clearly he is "not ready to go". Not trying to be critical but it does seem an odd statement now. Perhaps there was simply nobody left worthy of even being named emergency that round due to injuries ?

“We think that Lucas is going reasonably well at VFL level, but he hasn’t played yet enough footy to really warrant AFL selection. It’s not the correct thing to do by Lucas to put him into the side just yet, because he’s not ready to go.”

[old dee 22,929]

I read the quote below from Mark Neeld and I just wonder why Cook was selected as an emergency against Richmond in Rd 15 if clearly he is "not ready to go". Not trying to be critical but it does seem an odd statement now. Perhaps there was simply nobody left worthy of even being named emergency that round due to injuries ?

“We think that Lucas is going reasonably well at VFL level, but he hasn’t played yet enough footy to really warrant AFL selection. It’s not the correct thing to do by Lucas to put him into the side just yet, because he’s not ready to go.”

No one else left perhaps that week?

[Harcourt 146]

Is there ANY DANGER AT ALL we can pick players in this next draft who are ready to go FROM DAY 1???

We don't have time for %$&%ing bean pole project players this year, we need a quick fix and we need it right now otherwise we might as well shut the bloody door now.

This is just another frustration that is pi$$ing a lot of people off.

[Devo 104]

Another possibility is that coaches sometimes use that sort of thing as a tactic to fire up certain players. A player on the fringe might see their name listed in the emergencies, come to the conclusion that they are close to a senior game and then push that little bit harder on the track and in the VFL. Maybe Neeld thought that might spur Cook on a bit.

[old dee 22,929]

Is there ANY DANGER AT ALL we can pick players in this next draft who are ready to go FROM DAY 1???

We don't have time for %$&%ing bean pole project players this year, we need a quick fix and we need it right now otherwise we might as well shut the bloody door now.

This is just another frustration that is pi$$ing a lot of people off.

Yep

[binman 38,504]

Is there ANY DANGER AT ALL we can pick players in this next draft who are ready to go FROM DAY 1???

We don't have time for %$&%ing bean pole project players this year, we need a quick fix and we need it right now otherwise we might as well shut the bloody door now.

This is just another frustration that is pi$$ing a lot of people off.

Like, for example Darling. Joking - please all ignore, i was feeling a little trolly!

Edited August 2, 2012 by binman

[The heart beats true 16,239]

You'd be even more confused if you've seen much of Cook playing at Casey.

Looooong way to go.

[olisik 4,060]

You'd be even more confused if you've seen much of Cook playing at Casey.

Looooong way to go.

seriously wtf. first round draft pick and 2 years in cant even make it into the team as a sub.

kid should be put up as trade bait in my opinion

[andrewlamprill37 24]

I saw him at training this morning and he looks like a school kid, he is going down the Morton path but i cant see him being given the same 7 years before patience is lost!!

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Is there ANY DANGER AT ALL we can pick players in this next draft who are ready to go FROM DAY 1???

We don't have time for %$&%ing bean pole project players this year, we need a quick fix and we need it right now otherwise we might as well shut the bloody door now.

This is just another frustration that is pi$$ing a lot of people off.

I understand the frustration but people will also be unhappy if we dont take the best long term option as we are not going to play in premierships and win the by taking short cuts along the way, it just doesnt happpen

[Pennant St Dee 11,324]

Is there ANY DANGER AT ALL we can pick players in this next draft who are ready to go FROM DAY 1???

We don't have time for %$&%ing bean pole project players this year, we need a quick fix and we need it right now otherwise we might as well shut the bloody door now.

This is just another frustration that is pi$$ing a lot of people off.

Scully, Trengove, Tynan to name a few.

[Clark_Kent 315]

I do remember during the Daniher era he was drafting players in the hope they could come in

and be a player straight away searching for that elusive premiership. Look where that got us.

I am also unhappy that we didn't pick up Darling but at least we are going after players with

the potential to be very good players rather than someone who can come in and fill a hole for us.

[praha 10,287]

I read the quote below from Mark Neeld and I just wonder why Cook was selected as an emergency against Richmond in Rd 15 if clearly he is "not ready to go". Not trying to be critical but it does seem an odd statement now. Perhaps there was simply nobody left worthy of even being named emergency that round due to injuries ?

“We think that Lucas is going reasonably well at VFL level, but he hasn’t played yet enough footy to really warrant AFL selection. It’s not the correct thing to do by Lucas to put him into the side just yet, because he’s not ready to go.”

I guess just a lack of players at the selection table for Cook's position and he was a last resort.

I don't think he'd have been the first player in the first 22 to not be fit enough for AFL level.

[Harcourt 146]

I understand the frustration but people will also be unhappy if we dont take the best long term option as we are not going to play in premierships and win the by taking short cuts along the way, it just doesnt happpen

Our best long term option is SURVIVAL right now. We are 10 billion miles away from willing a premership, possible more. I would settle for simply winning a game against a side that isn't a bunch of bloody 15 year olds right now. If we keep winning <5 games a year we will not survive 10 years. As I said in my previous post we need a quick fix and we need it now. We simply can't afford to be complete rubbish for ANOTHER 6 years. Draft players who are ready to go not boney girl armed players who MIGHT be superstars in 300 god damn years (if we're lucky and if they haven't buggered off elsewhere by then).

Sorry for my ranting but I'm as fed up as most of you guys.

[thaipantsman 180]

I do remember during the Daniher era he was drafting players in the hope they could come in

and be a player straight away searching for that elusive premiership. Look where that got us.

I am also unhappy that we didn't pick up Darling but at least we are going after players with

the potential to be very good players rather than someone who can come in and fill a hole for us.

Got us close but no biscuit!

[thaipantsman 180]

Keep saying it! How about leigh williams? Worth the risk?

[Junior 46]

Is there ANY DANGER AT ALL we can pick players in this next draft who are ready to go FROM DAY 1???

We don't have time for %$&%ing bean pole project players this year, we need a quick fix and we need it right now otherwise we might as well shut the bloody door now.

This is just another frustration that is pi$$ing a lot of people off.

We probably will do that this year, but you can't do it every year or you'll end up with a side with no talls. Have to either draft them or trade them in!

[olisik 4,060]

Keep saying it! How about leigh williams? Worth the risk?

worth the risk of de listing seasons end? i say yes

[picket fence 15,273]

Is there ANY DANGER AT ALL we can pick players in this next draft who are ready to go FROM DAY 1???

We don't have time for %$&%ing bean pole project players this year, we need a quick fix and we need it right now otherwise we might as well shut the bloody door now.

This is just another frustration that is pi$$ing a lot of people off.

Is there ANY DANGER AT ALL we can pick players in this next draft who are ready to go FROM DAY 1???

We don't have time for %$&%ing bean pole project players this year, we need a quick fix and we need it right now otherwise we might as well shut the bloody door now.

This is just another frustration that is pi$$ing a lot of people off.

And just another reason to have kept "Juice"

25 games for 35 goals people not bad from a bloke who never ever got an extended run!!

Ah well what could have been! Eh

[daisycutter 28,601]

!%$^#@*&^#

[Guest José Mourinho]

Is there ANY DANGER AT ALL we can pick players in this next draft who are ready to go FROM DAY 1???

We don't have time for %$&%ing bean pole project players this year, we need a quick fix and we need it right now otherwise we might as well shut the bloody door now.

This is just another frustration that is pi$$ing a lot of people off.

Yeah, that's exactly what this club needs - quick fixes.

FFS...

And this rubbish of survival - we've survived much worse.

Quit the baseless hysteria.