Cloke and Collingwood - to part or not to part?

[speed demon 689]

I can't see Cloke leaving. A respected player at a rock solid club whose premiership window is wide open. The only motivation could be financial, and I don't see the difference between $850,000/yr and $1million/yr as being much of an incentive.

I think the situation with Ablett and Scully was different. For Ablett, in addition to the $, GC presented the opportunity to prove himself in a weak team and lead them to success. For Scully, it was $6million for an unproven player with a chronic knee injury at a dysfunctional club.

However, I would still pursue him. A forward of his quality is more scarce than premiership quality midfielders. We are more likely to be able to draft/trade/develop the midfield we need than we are a player of Cloke's ability.

[Range Rover 1,935]

I can't see Cloke leaving. A respected player at a rock solid club whose premiership window is wide open. The only motivation could be financial, and I don't see the difference between $850,000/yr and $1million/yr as being much of an incentive.

It's not so much the cash amount as the number of years he can be guaranteed (4 or 5).

[Roost It 1,434]

If he leaves collingwood his dad should be shot

[bing181 8,204]

Nah, forget Cloke and the big bucks, get this guy:

http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/afl/all-the-action-as-brendan-fevola-bagged-seven-final-quarter-goals/story-e6frg1xu-1226394602304

[wattsup 470]

Was told from a reliable sauce tonight who is very good friends with a collingwood player, Melbourne have offered cloke a 7 year deal worth 1 million a year, I would assume his 1st year would be heavily front ended maybe 1.5 to 2 mill

[Roost It 1,434]

Was told from a reliable sauce tonight who is very good friends with a collingwood player, Melbourne have offered cloke a 7 year deal worth 1 million a year, I would assume his 1st year would be heavily front ended maybe 1.5 to 2 mill

If that were true then Harrington should be shot

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Was told from a reliable sauce tonight who is very good friends with a collingwood player, Melbourne have offered cloke a 7 year deal worth 1 million a year, I would assume his 1st year would be heavily front ended maybe 1.5 to 2 mill

I bloody hope not.

[wattsup 470]

Yeah I would rather chase mids, just passing on what I was told I guess if the club is serious they will use all there pics on mids, or they are making this offer so a beams or sidebottom gets pushed out only time will tell

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Yeah I would rather chase mids, just passing on what I was told I guess if the club is serious they will use all there pics on mids, or they are making this offer so a beams or sidebottom gets pushed out only time will tell

I Bloody hope so!

[beelzebub 22,269]

smoke mirrors

[Juicebox 628]

Yeah I would rather chase mids, just passing on what I was told I guess if the club is serious they will use all there pics on mids, or they are making this offer so a beams or sidebottom gets pushed out only time will tell

I'd also happily take either Wellingham or Goldsack

[dee-luded 2,958]

Yeah I would rather chase mids, just passing on what I was told I guess if the club is serious they will use all there pics on mids, or they are making this offer so a beams or sidebottom gets pushed out only time will tell

Now your talking. I'd rather chase Beams &/or Sidebottom if we have to have some Pie.

[daisycutter 28,640]

Now your talking. I'd rather chase Beams &/or Sidebottom if we have to have some Pie.

So would I. Both A graders

But it will cost us picks/players as well as money

I don't think we would give up pick 4 so it would have to be pick 12/13(?) plus player(s)

Or would we use pick 4 (or whatever the no after Viney)?

[olisik 4,060]

this thread is about Cloke, not collingwood players in general. I dont understand whats with demonland posters suddenly sayin they want every 2nd collingwood player. Cmon fellas, there are 16 other teams to pick from, why only harp on abt how good collingwood players are

[daisycutter 28,640]

this thread is about Cloke, not collingwood players in general. I dont understand whats with demonland posters suddenly sayin they want every 2nd collingwood player. Cmon fellas, there are 16 other teams to pick from, why only harp on abt how good collingwood players are

I thought the connection could be that we are not really interested in Cloke per se but trying to force Collingwood to pay more for Cloke thus less available to renew contracts with other ooc players e.g. Beams, Sidebottom

This could be a tactic to get some good midfielders

Just saying

[dazzledavey36 49,025]

Nah, forget Cloke and the big bucks, get this guy:

http://www.perthnow....u-1226394602304

lol i was playing in that game too. this bloke should be still in the afl. sad reality actually.

[JT9 104]

Nah, forget Cloke and the big bucks, get this guy:

http://www.perthnow....u-1226394602304

Kicked 18 today!

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

The Dees are offering $5m over 5+ years according to this morning's Age.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/demons-weigh-in-with-5m-cloke-bid-20120709-21s1g.html

[Bring Back Barassi 540]

we either get a monster forward line, or we blow out the filth's salary cap

brilliant

[Fork 'em 6,558]

we either get a monster forward line, or we blow out the filth's salary cap

brilliant

And blow out our own salary cap.

Not so brilliant.

[Lobe Dogg 2]

Too much money. Plus I hate him.

We apparently have also given him the option of 6 years. I don't like it.

No thanks.

[Fork 'em 6,558]

If were gonna throw stupid money around , throw it at Franklin.

At least a bloke like him will bring people through the gates .

[jnrmac 19,207]

The Dees are offering $5m over 5+ years according to this morning's Age.

http://www.theage.co...0709-21s1g.html

No No No No NO No No NO No No No No No No and No..

Repeat after me. We need:

Mids

Mids

Mids

Mids

Mids

Mids

Mids

Mids

Mids

This can't be true, Please don't be true. He's not that good, He can't kick and has an elite midfield passing it on a silver platter. He would kick 20goals a year at the Dees.

[Mazer Rackham 14,970]

Five years too long.

Five mill too much.

I hope we are doing this to game Collingwood and force them to take him for 5 years and 5 mill. Eddie is panicking.

[olisik 4,060]

His free in a sence that no draft picks need to be lost to bolster the forward line. I honestly would have preferred going for hogan and working with him and i still hope we do.

Power forwards are a dime a dozen whole there is an abudance of mids out there waiting to be drafted. I like this play by the dees.