Our best player in 3 years time?

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Something a bit fun imo, name the player and one smokey

I am going with the no surprises option, or one of them and will say,

Jack Watts - Has everything required to be not only the best player on the MFC list but one of if not the best in the AFL in 3 years time imo.

He is tall, getting strong, fast, has footy smarts, and exception skills and disposal.

He can play forward back or in the middle/wing if required, i just think he is building reasonably quietly and people everywhere will just go hang on he is actually that good.

SMOKEY - Tom Mcdonald, This kid really impressed me late last season, is another tall player, who was a forward/ruck in the TAC cup.

Is only a KPP at AFL but has shown his versatile down back and by reports Neeld also sees potential in him as a forward. was cool under pressure, and kicked and marked well.

This pre-season, his first full one, he came second in the 3KM time trial for a big bloke, being shaded by the distance specialist Bail.

How good he will be, i really dont know...

Thoughts?

Edited February 6, 2012 by Jordie_tackles

[Deeoldfart 8,061]

It's very hard to go past Jack Watts Jordie, but just to be different I'll stick with Chip Frawley to still be our best in 3 years time (no real surprises there either, I guess). I also very much like the look of Tom McD., but I'll put out the bait to Old Dee and suggest Jamie Bennell as my smokey. I know it's a very long bow to draw, but he could be our Andrew McLeod, and two Norm Smiths would have to put him right up there!

[Roost It 1,434]

Grimes

[Roost It 1,434]

Wait Trengove

[Roost It 1,434]

Ummm Frawley

[Roost It 1,434]

No Watts

[Roost It 1,434]

Hang on that Viney kid

[John Dee 445]

Jack Watts; Max Gawn

[Lutz 76]

Tom McDonald?

Don't wanna put a ceiling on the guy, but I don't think so.

I'll go with Gysberts.

[Damo 3,374]

Trengove and Howe.

[deesrule 104]

Watts

Gawn

Trengove

Martin

[Maldonboy38 6,406]

Has to be out of Grimes, Watts and Trengove. I choose Trengove. If you put a scale together of every skill and quality required of every footballer, regardless of position or size, Trengove would rate very highly in every category. I see him as a cross between Bartel and Gibbs.

Smokey: Jordan Gysberts. He just keeps getting to where the ball is. A few more kgs and a bit more aerobic capacity and the sky is the limit.

.

Edited February 7, 2012 by Maldonboy38

[Roger Mellie 4,102]

Gysberts would be nice

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Tom McDonald?

Don't wanna put a ceiling on the guy, but I don't think so.

I'll go with Gysberts.

I like him

do you have a roughy Lutz?

[olisik 4,060]

Gysberts would be nice

The guy is trying to model his game off pendlebury, I can see him being as good.

[Thrice 216]

Only three players have the tools to be elite of players currently on our list. Watts and Trengove are two and the third is Sylvia. There's your smoky.

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Only three players have the tools to be elite of players currently on our list. Watts and Trengove are two and the third is Sylvia. There's your smoky.

that would be shattering...... finds his best at 29 and wasting his whole career

[Guest Gotzy15]

This is a great thread and extremely tough to answer.

I'm going to go with trenners and wattsy. Trenners will certainly finish top 5 in a brownlow as an elite on baller and wattsy is just a freak. I was very critical of wattsy early on but every game he plays now he makes me look like a goose!

The smokeys are Howe and bennell.

[furious d 472]

Morton

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,233]

Only three players have the tools to be elite of players currently on our list. Watts and Trengove are two and the third is Sylvia. There's your smoky.

James Frawley not having the tools to be elite? I think he is close already. I would not be surprised to see Gysberts, Howe and Trengove duking this out in 3 years time.

[Guest Gotzy15]

Only three players have the tools to be elite of players currently on our list. Watts and Trengove are two and the third is Sylvia. There's your smoky.

Are you serious?? What about frawley, mitch Clark, Howe.....

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Are you serious?? What about frawley, mitch Clark, Howe.....

Agree with Frawley but the term ELITE means top few players in the league.

I couldnt name our last elite player......

[Thrice 216]

Are you serious?? What about frawley, mitch Clark, Howe.....

Frawley - an elite defender, maybe. Even the best full backs (Fletcher, Scarlett, etc) are never considered their side's best player.

Howe - Seriously, get over yourselves everyone. He's (very) good ordinary but will never, ever be in Judd, Hodge, Ablett, Pendlebury category.

Clark - An interesting one. He will be very important to our structure, but best player in three years? I'd be concerned if Watts and Trengove haven't surpassed him.

Gysberts - An elite ball winner, yes, but his disposal isn't that great. He's not a great mark either. Has claims at smoky status, though, if he can improve his disposal. (just not my pick)

[The Chazz 4,077]

Watts - has all the tricks to be a match winner, there aint many players in the league that have that skill. Can he deliver it though? I think he will.

The smoky is Tapscott. He will be a favourite of the coach providing he can get his body right, and I have no doubt MN is in the ear of Misson about making sure he's 100% before he plays him. This is the type of player that every club would want, and especially our coach. Tappy could play a very important role in Neeld's quest for a premiership.

[PaulRB 6,411]

Funny how everyone has dropped off Liam Jurrah for elite...

LJ - Aged 23 - 35 Games 81 goals - freakish talent with clear areas for improvement.

JW - Aged 21 - 40 games 33 goals - loads of upside...