Do we deserve TOP 8?

[Jack son 5 162]

It looks like MFC will retain a top 8 position. Bar a st.kilda/Richmond massive win and the pies put away the dogs, we stay put. Let's put aside the coach's head on a plate talk, and decide if the club is worthy to retain a top eight inclusion.

With the crows next week at the G, can the side pull thier fingers out and have a "shut the puck UP everyone" win. Surely we are worthy of a bounce back victory. Are we not?

Edited April 30, 2011 by Jack son 5

[Samsara 65]

Position on the ladder matters little this early in year. Only matters at the end of the final round. We have only beaten Brisbane (just) and Gold Coast, so not a lot to ride home about. OUr two losses have both been poor. This week against Adelaide will be very interesting.

[Sir Why You Little 35,223]

who cares...it's round 6. What matters is next week and beyond.

[Jack son 5 162]

Position on the ladder matters little this early in year. Only matters at the end of the final round. We have only beaten Brisbane (just) and Gold Coast, so not a lot to ride home about. OUr two losses have both been poor. This week against Adelaide will be very interesting.

READ HEADING, do we deserve to be in the top eight at this stage?

[Jack son 5 162]

who cares...it's round 6. What matters is next week and beyond.

I care

[Sir Why You Little 35,223]

I care

That's part of the culture problem with this club. You care about being in the 8 at round 6 (Hanging in there by a thread) I care about being top 4 come September.

Time to Harden up Michael, being in the 8 right now means F#$%^k all.

[Jordie_tackles 354]

That's part of the culture problem with this club. You care about being in the 8 at round 6 (Hanging in there by a thread) I care about being top 4 come September.

Time to Harden up Michael, being in the 8 right now means F#$%^k all.

exactly

[monoccular 16,513]

Absolutely NO WAY - the current position, what with byes etc and only round 6 doesn't matter much, but if you mean end of season will we deserve - NO, unless there is some sort of miracle turnaround as happened in the latter half of 2000 when I think we were absolutely disgraced by the Dogs and Carltank mid season but ran home to make to GF.

[Samsara 65]

READ HEADING, do we deserve to be in the top eight at this stage?

No, we do not.

[titan_uranus 22,922]

Crap thread number 2.

[Jerry Lundergard 399]

Rnd 9 - Saints

10 - Carlton

11 - Essendon

12 - Pies

13 - Dockers

If we are in the 8 after rnd 13, then you can assume we deserve to be there. That would equate to a footballing miracle at this stage.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

I think we will struggle to win more than 3 more games this year Port twice and Gold coast here. And none of those games are walk up starts.

We are a seriously ordinary side and it was shown up in the NAB cup just how far off the pace we are and just how far we've slipped this year.

[45HG 1,539]

I think we will struggle to win more than 3 more games this year Port twice and Gold coast here. And none of those games are walk up starts.

[Roost It 1,434]

I think we will struggle to win more than 3 more games this year Port twice and Gold coast here. And none of those games are walk up starts.

We are a seriously ordinary side and it was shown up in the NAB cup just how far off the pace we are and just how far we've slipped this year.

The new coach would snare another good draft pick........perfect......but!

[Dee Fan 3,247]

The new coach would snare another good draft pick........perfect......but!

I know we could draft a 202cm 70kg forward prospect that may be up to his first game in 2020.

Edited April 30, 2011 by RobbieF

[Sir Why You Little 35,223]

I think we will struggle to win more than 3 more games this year Port twice and Gold coast here. And none of those games are walk up starts.

We are a seriously ordinary side and it was shown up in the NAB cup just how far off the pace we are and just how far we've slipped this year.

Not if we got some good coaches into the organization right now, starting next week.

Cheque Book time....

[old dee 23,122]

I think we will struggle to win more than 3 more games this year Port twice and Gold coast here. And none of those games are walk up starts.

We are a seriously ordinary side and it was shown up in the NAB cup just how far off the pace we are and just how far we've slipped this year.

It does look bleak RobbieF, I looked at the fixture today and based on the last 8 weeks form I struggled to find another win to your list.

Maybe one of the Richmond games.

That would make 6.5 wins on that basis quite a few in the FD would be looking for new jobs I would suggest.

So after four years of the much vaunted rebuild we would have risen to the heights of the bottom four.

Not sure were we finished in 2007 but was in that group from memory.

[old dee 23,122]

I know we could draft a 202cm 70kg forward prospect that may be up to his first game in 2020.

Not if he is a no.1 pick then we will play him every week because you have to games into them you know.

Having said that he was one of the few that deserves a game next weekend IMO

Edited April 30, 2011 by old dee

[Deano74 156]

We are in the 8 by default.

We played well against Syd

crap against Hawks, then played Bris and the Suns, which you would expect wins.

AT the moment we look like a bottom 4 side.

Right now we have gone backwards.

Edited April 30, 2011 by Deano74

[45HG 1,539]

I think we will struggle to win more than 3 more games this year Port twice and Gold coast here. And none of those games are walk up starts.

Hrm.

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Hrm.

yes we do because we are in the 8 simple, do i care no, when will i care? if we are in the 8 at the completion of round 24

and i also predict we will win more than 3 more games...

[Rogue 585]

Hrm.

:D

[H_T 2,941]

Not if we got some good coaches into the organization right now, starting next week.

Were they good coaches against Adelaide ?

[Gorgoroth 12,369]

We deserve to be where ever the ladder tells us we are.

Yes I understand we have played terrible and only beaten the easier teams, but you can only beat who you have been drawn to play and only sit where you are due to winning games and how those around you win or lose.

[Pates 9,541]

Those first two wins were fairly nothing victories, they were against average opposition and we didn't look particularly convincing. Adelaide was different, we were all over them and we played with passion. We deserve to be in the 8 now.