Can anyone tell me what these MFC players have in common?

[Reality Bus 17]

Morton

Bruce

Bartram

Grimes

Sylvia

Garland

Wonaeamirri

Moloney

Rivers

Jones

Scully

Jurrah

Petterd

Bate

Gysberts

Trengove

Davey

Green

[Dreamin' Demon 10]

I'll have a guess.

Nothing?

[Eth 4]

They're all awesome.

[hardtack 10,514]

They all have a name containing at least one letter of the alphabet.

[Eth 4]

If the answer is that they've all had threads about them, then you're missing Watts

[Stigga 25]

They are all very promising players.

[Hobbits's 17]

all part of the club's 13th premiership ?

[stranga 328]

Going to the Gold Coast/GWS.

[Reality Bus 17]

hmmm. well some of you are right, in the way that they all do have a letter of the alphabet in their names; they are promising; they are all hopefully part of our next premiership; and that we have written extensively on all of them. Unfortunately, not the answer I'm after.

I'm hoping I can add Watts to this list.

Bonus hint: Nathan Jones should be listed twice

[stranga 328]

Bingo, Rising star nominations.

[hardtack 10,514]

I'm hoping I can add Watts to this list.

Bonus hint: Nathan Jones should be listed twice

You are stalking all of them on either Facebook or Twitter?

[Reality Bus 17]

Bingo, Rising star nominations.

We have a winner!! Get the man a gold star and a cold beer.

Not sure what the purpose of the exercise was. Maybe to procrastinate from what I should really be doing? Maybe to highlight the immense amount of talent in our side?

But yes, 18 current-day listed MFC players have earnt themselves a Rising Star nomination. Not a bad 18 if you ask me!

[Red Sox 2]

Hopefully in 20 years time they are all returning to the club to celebrate that historic Melbourne three-peat of premierships....2012, 2013, 2014!!!

I'm expecting some attrition and changes to the flag winning sides of 2016, 2018 and 2019.

Not that I'm greedy!

[Redleg 40,842]

Morton

Bruce

Bartram

Grimes

Sylvia

Garland

Wonaeamirri

Moloney

Rivers

Jones

Scully

Jurrah

Petterd

Bate

Gysberts

Trengove

Davey

Green

Well lets take a serious look at this conundrum.

None of them wear Warnock's jumper.

They have all had consecutive games this year.

None of them has climbed Mt. Everest.

All of them were born very close to their mother.

They all wear two boots in a game.

They are all right handed except for the ones that are left handed.

They are all under 63 years of age.

None of them play for the Pies.

They all enjoy dinner.

They all play their football on grass.

All of them can kick a footy further than 23 metres.

Everyone of them has been in a car.

None of them has walked on the moon.

Every one of them has a birthday each year.

All of them were or are teenagers.

All of them wear pants.

None of them are jockeys.

All of them weigh more than 46 kilos.

Everyone of them has touched a football in the last week.

Everyone of them has visited the suburb of Casey.

All of them are married,have a girlfriend or are single.

None of them eat sardines and icecream for breakfast.

Everyone of them has watched TV in the last year.

All of them have sat on a chair in the last 3 weeks.

Did I get the correct answer or should I keep guessing?

PS. Damn someone got the correct answer while I was typing.

Edited June 11, 2010 by Redleg

[Reality Bus 17]

Well lets take a serious look at this conundrum.

None of them wear Warnock's jumper. - Can't verify

They have all had consecutive games this year. - Jurrah disagrees

None of them has climbed Mt. Everest. - Can't verify

All of them were born very close to their mother. - I assume so

They all wear two boots in a game. - Unless they aren't tied on tight enough

They are all right handed except for the ones that are left handed. - or ambidexterous

They are all under 63 years of age. - James McDonald was unlucky to miss out on a nomination

None of them play for the Pies. - Davey and Jurrah did

They all enjoy dinner. - Except for those that dont

They all play their football on grass. - The MCG is more a carpet

All of them can kick a footy further than 23 metres. - Brock shipped himself off to Carlton, and we missed out on Ball, so I'll pay that

Everyone of them has been in a car. - How do you expect them to get to Casey

None of them has walked on the moon. - Most likely

Every one of them has a birthday each year. - Correct

All of them were or are teenagers. - Correct

All of them wear pants. - Bruce wears them out on to the ground

None of them are jockeys. - Probably

All of them weigh more than 46 kilos. - Morton says hello

Everyone of them has touched a football in the last week. - You'd hope so

Everyone of them has visited the suburb of Casey. - True

All of them are married,have a girlfriend or are single. - Except for any that may be gay.

None of them eat sardines and icecream for breakfast. - It's a breakfast of champions

Everyone of them has watched TV in the last year. - Can't verify

All of them have sat on a chair in the last 3 weeks. - Can't verify

Did I get the correct answer or should I keep guessing? - I'll give you a B overall. I know, I'm a hard marker.

PS. Damn someone got the correct answer while I was typing. Probably the most accurate answer you gave, Either that, or being born close to their mother.

[Hobbits's 17]

Bonus hint: Nathan Jones should be listed twice

you should get the gold star and the cold beer after virtually handing the answer on a silver platter with that clue.

good question nevertheless. well done.

[Reality Bus 17]

Trust me, the Cascade Lagers are chilling away nicely waiting for it to tick down to 5pm.

[Steamin Demon 392]

Trust me, the Cascade Lagers are chilling away nicely waiting for it to tick down to 5pm.

Cascade ?? At least no one will drink them on you

[praha 11,236]

Goes to show how having d-grade facilities has hurt this team. Our drafting has never been an issue imo. It's giving players the opportunity to take the next step up from being just a good player. We just can't do it. Hopefully the tide is turning with Casey, Olympic Park, etc. People really underestimate its affect on this club. It's almost killed it in every way (on and off the field).

[ox_5 163]

Its a great stat. I mentioned this on the Gysberts thread the other day. Its really promising for the future, as most are long term players starting out their career.

[45HG 1,539]

Goes to show how having d-grade facilities has hurt this team. Our drafting has never been an issue imo.

I agree.

[Sir Why You Little 36,983]

Goes to show how having d-grade facilities has hurt this team. Our drafting has never been an issue imo. It's giving players the opportunity to take the next step up from being just a good player. We just can't do it. Hopefully the tide is turning with Casey, Olympic Park, etc. People really underestimate its affect on this club. It's almost killed it in every way (on and off the field).

Yes i agree with that completely. So does The Ox's knees. If only we had A Grade training facilties when he was a young boy.

Would have given that Carey Tool a run for his money B)

[Daz's Dee's 113]

ha ha great response!

[Dinosaur Rover 197]

We have a winner!! Get the man a gold star and a cold beer.

Not sure what the purpose of the exercise was. Maybe to procrastinate from what I should really be doing? Maybe to highlight the immense amount of talent in our side?

But yes, 18 current-day listed MFC players have earnt themselves a Rising Star nomination. Not a bad 18 if you ask me!

Can someone run a correlation analysis on this and see if it positively correlates to finals success?

[The Chazz 4,077]

Can someone run a correlation analysis on this and see if it positively correlates to finals success?

If someone really, really has too much time on their hands, can they report on other clubs and how many nominations they have on their lists? Be interesting to see if we are a standout, or if our numbers are industry standard.

One other thing for discussion - people are always talking about our lack of decent facilities playing a big part in the development of our players, but the question I am throwing out there is how much? My personal opinion is that we are using this as an excuse. While it isn't ideal when you compare it to the power clubs, we have had it for many years so why didn't we do something about it? What I mean by that is that while the Junction Oval facilities were very basic, why didn't we use that to our advantage and have a number of state-of-the-art locations across Melbourne. Again, this is not ideal as it could involve splitting the team up at various stages throughout the week (ie. a group of players could be doing rehab in one location, while the other group could be doing weights in another location). I have not seen the facilities at Geelong, but I'm pretty sure they use multiple locations each week.

While player development is so important in the quest to win a flag, a lot of it still depends on the success of recruiting.

This is just an opinion!