Carroll, Holland in Mad Monday scuffle

[Satan 2,786]

Heat on AFL, Ben Holland, Brendan Fevola over wild behaviour

THE AFL is under pressure to ban Mad Mondays after another drunken disgrace left a footballer in trouble.

Melbourne forward Ben Holland was allegedly injured after a scuffle broke out when he tried to help teammate Nathan Carroll into a taxi...

Melbourne football manager Chris Connolly said the club had been working on policy that not only limited players' alcohol intake, but encouraged them to support those who drank too much.

"It's that very situation that might have led to (the incident)," Connolly said.

"I think Ben was trying to encourage Nathan (to go home) when he may have had too much to drink."

Connolly said the club had tried to put an end to the Mad Monday binge sessions.

"My understanding is the behaviour of all the players was outstanding except . . . for the behaviour of Nathan."

Thats all we need as a club, not :angry:

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,410]

Geez Caroll's a first class idiot.

Sack the list clogger or trade him for a seventh round draft pick.

[BAMF 3,809]

Un-needed player. Even if he stays on the list, I doubt he would get a game next year. Should just pay out his contract and send him on his way.

I doubt anyone would pick him up in the PSD.

[Courtney_Fish 183]

Fev's just upholding Carlton tradition.

[Whispering_Jack 28,094]

Carroll was involved in bar fights in Greece and Germany last summer and was at one stage locked up in jail.

Greece, Germany and now Holland.

My advice to Nathan is that, in the future, he should stay away from anything to do with Europe !

[Guest Chopper]

Dissapointing, very dissapointing.

Team mates stick together, they do not fight Chop. He needs to put his dead down and concentrate on football instead of always trying to be a macho man.

[Nasher 33,166]

Nathan Carroll in trouble? What a surprise

[LeBron James 41]

He's gawn.

[Mousey 47]

He is the bad influence we dont need at this club with so many young guys.

Good riddance.

[Neita3000 37]

What an idiot. I've heard alot of bad things about Nathan Carroll, perhaps some of them true, his behaivour certainly indicates it.

[Gouga 512]

Hitting a teamate who is trying to do the right thing by you is very poor form.

This year started badly with alcohol related incidents and it looks like it is going to end the same way. I'm a Carroll fan, but enough is enough. The right thing to do is to delist him and pay out his contract.

[WonnaJurah 5]

swap to freo for warnock? all the bad boys go there, farmer,johnson,carr,tarrant,headland etc

[Gouga 512]

swap to freo for warnock? all the bad boys go there, farmer,johnson,carr,tarrant,headland etc

Fremantle would not want Carroll. Especially since they've had him before and got rid of him.

Like I said before, I like "Disco" but he has probably stamped his own ticket.

[WonnaJurah 5]

Fremantle would not want Carroll. Especially since they've had him before and got rid of him.

Like I said before, I like "Disco" but he has probably stamped his own ticket.

this is the frreo who picked up hack keper bradley

i hope he goes, players who do that again n again have to place in the team imo

bewsides we got warnock,garland ,frawley ahead of him

[Gouga 512]

this is the frreo who picked up hack keper bradley

i hope he goes, players who do that again n again have to place in the team imo

bewsides we got warnock,garland ,frawley ahead of him

Don't forget Martin and Rivers.

We have a surplus of key backs for the first time ever. Not a good time for a fringe key back to [censored] up. But then again, that is Carroll's style.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Carroll is a known and avoided serial social problem amongst all other AFL Clubs.

Carroll's brother played for Freo. Any hints why they avoided Nathan like the plague back then?

He had poor off field form then in WA. He is known amongst other Clubs to be someone to avoid socially.

Its does raise a question of judgement over MFC players who choose to socialise with Carroll when alcohol is involved given his habitual incidents.

You are fooling yourself if you think a Club will trade for a delinquent like that.

I know the Club is financially stretched but over the past year Carroll puts a compelling case on and off the field for an early payout of his contract.

[Tigers Dayz 2]

I'm a Carroll fan, but enough is enough. The right thing to do is to delist him and pay out his contract.

I'm not interested in wasting money paying anyone's contract out. We've done enough of that in recent times. Find another resolution.

[Gouga 512]

I know the Club is financially stretched but over the past year Carroll puts a compelling case on and off the field for an early payout of his contract.

Carroll wouldn't be on 'Harris' money.

Considering we'll be paying well short of the salary cap next year I'm sure we could afford to pay him out.

Especially consiering a kid on $35,000 will probably take his spot.

[Gouga 512]

I'm not interested in wasting money paying anyone's contract out. We've done enough of that in recent times. Find another resolution.

The other resolution is keep him on the list.

Would it be a waste of money paying out a bloke DB decides he doesn't want at the club for whatever reason (ability or behaviour)?

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

The other resolution is keep him on the list.

Would it be a waste of money paying out a bloke DB decides he doesn't want at the club for whatever reason (ability or behaviour)?

Is there a 3 strike behaviour policy in the player's contract?

Surely if there is, he must be on very shaky ground.

[Nasher 33,166]

I'm not normally one for hanging players -- I haven't done so for McLean/Sylvia/Carroll's indescretions in the past, but this is just getting ridiculous now. Give him the bullet immediately.

[jacey 333]

Is there a 3 strike behaviour policy in the player's contract?

Surely if there is, he must be on very shaky ground.

I thought his brother played for WCE but i agree with you. CUT him loose. I'll try to find a loophole so we don't have to pay him out but if we can't, just DELIST.

[freo2008 0]

I thought his brother played for WCE but i agree with you. CUT him loose. I'll try to find a loophole so we don't have to pay him out but if we can't, just DELIST.

Trent Carroll played at both Freo and West Coast. Nathan was on Freo's rookie list but was discarded and ended up at Melbourne. I don't think there's a snowball's chance in hell of him coming anywhere near Freo (we just sacked Farmer, why would we pick up Carroll)

[do it 4 robbie 1]

The same thing happened at my footy club a few years ago.

The lesson to be learn`t here is that you don`t take old farts on [censored]-ups.

See ya Chopper !

[Gorgoroth 12,361]

Dump the dud.