Demonland Player of the Year - Round 5 voting

[Demonland 72,187]

Normal deal - first three sets of serious votes on a 6,5,4,3,2,1 basis. Weighted average this week .6832.

[WonnaJurah 5]

6.Mclean

5.Macdonald

4.Rivers

3.Whelan

2.Green

1.Jones

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

6. Rivers

5. Green

4. Whelan

3. McLean

2. Aussie

1. Robertson (for his mark only)

[CHAMP 347]

6 Green 5 McLean 4 Rivers 3 McDonald 2 Sylvia 1 Wonna

[Jaded No More 68,915]

6- McLean

5- Green

4- Rivers

3- Sylvia

2- Whelan

1- McDonald

[mclean sweep 0]

6. Green

5. Rivers

4. Mclean

3. Whelan

2. Mcdonland

1. Frawley

[IWAP 170]

no votes so far for Bruce? Apart from that kick, thought he was easily one of our best

[Hannabal 4]

I was at a Christening unfortunately today.

SEN had Bruce as our best and only winner for the number he did on Stevens. Yet he's not recognised as I post.

Hmmm

[Dee Dee 1,108]

no votes so far for Bruce? Apart from that kick, thought he was easily one of our best

Agree with you:

McLean 6

Green 5

McDonald 4

Bruce 3

Frawley2

Whelan 1

[Gouga 569]

6. McLean

5. Green

4. Bruce

3. Sylvia

2. McDonald

1. Frawley

[ucanchoose 1,816]

6. Green

5. Sylvia

4. Frawley

3. McLean

2. Rivers

1. McDonald

[QueenC 74]

6. Green

5. McLean

4. Rivers

3. Whelan

2. Bruce

1. Frawley

[drdrake 3,163]

6. Sylvia

5. Green

4. Mclean

3. Frawley

2. Whelan

1. Rivers

Sylvia beat Fisher created of half back then did OK in the last up forward. Mclean would have been best but considering the impact of Judd he had to be put down a liitle.

[Nasher 33,616]

6 Green

5 McLean

4 Bruce

3 Rivers

2 McDonald

1 Whelan

Thought Frawley showed some very promising signs also.

[DaveyJones'sLocker 647]

no votes so far for Bruce? Apart from that kick, thought he was easily one of our best

u should know by now everyone hates this bloke ... is the smartest man in our team...

jaded mclean 6?

he played on judd and got destroyed... he did get alot of the ball and tried hard but u have to be kidding me.

6.Green

5.Sylvia

4.Bruce

3.Mclean

2.Whelan

1.macca

[Yze_Magic 3]

6 - Brad Green

5 - Brock Mclean

4 - Colin Sylvia

3 - Matthew Whelan

2 - Austin Wonemarri (and well done on the 7 tackles, young fella)

1 - David Neitz (for being a loyal servant of the MFC for so long. The great man playes his last game today)

[Jaded No More 68,915]

jaded mclean 6?

he played on judd and got destroyed... he did get alot of the ball and tried hard but u have to be kidding me.

Why am I getting singled out? Plenty other people gave him 6.

Besides, if you think McLean got destroyed by Judd, you have obviously never seen Judd on fire. Faster, more experienced players have suffered much worse at the hands of Chris Judd. His 3 goals were very influential, as was some of his forward delivery, but he certainly didn't rip us apart like I have seen him rip us apart before.

McLean had a huge job to do. To his credit he didn't go too defensive, and still got plenty of his own ball, while at the same time limiting Judd to the best of his ability. McLean more than held his own in the clearances, but obviously struggled for pace in the one on one situations.

Very few, if any, can stop Judd, and not many find themselves amongst the top possession winners while playing against him.

[Maybe next year 170]

I would love to give green 6, 5, 4, 3, 2 and 1 votes but it is against the rules. My votes are:

6 - Green (you guessed it) - he tries his guts out and i hope they leave him on the HF line

5 - Rivers - has the smarts

4 - Austin - his chasing was great today and is one of the best disposals in the team

3 - McDOnald - primarily for the chase down

2- Bruce - easily accounted for Stevens

1 - Bartram - would have like to see him on Judd

Mclean was well beaten by Judd - cannot give him votes. For those who thought Judd did not rip us apart, in the words of "The Castle", tell them they're dreaming

[Demonland 72,187]

I would love to give green 6, 5, 4, 3, 2 and 1 votes but it is against the rules. My votes are:

6 - Green (you guessed it) - he tries his guts out and i hope they leave him on the HF line

5 - Rivers - has the smarts

4 - Austin - his chasing was great today and is one of the best disposals in the team

3 - McDOnald - primarily for the chase down

2- Bruce - easily accounted for Stevens

1 - Bartram - would have like to see him on Judd

Mclean was well beaten by Judd - cannot give him votes. For those who thought Judd did not rip us apart, in the words of "The Castle", tell them they're dreaming

In spite of MNY's criticism, Brock got the votes and took the lead -

25.7634 Brock McLean

19.984 Paul Wheatley

14.504 Paul Johnson

12.013 Cameron Bruce

11.86 Cale Morton

11.196 Aaron Davey

11.0726 Brad Green

10.0644 Jared Rivers

9.4428 James McDonald

7.38 Nathan Carroll

7.148 Colin Sylvia

6.6112 Austin Wonaemirri

5.904 Matthew Whelan

5.88 Brad Miller

5.2332 Nathan Jones

4.1 Jeff White

2.925 Brent Moloney

1.866 Lynden Dunn

0.732 Clint Bartram

0.65 Colin Garland

0.325 Simon Buckley

[Nasher 33,616]

Mclean was well beaten by Judd - cannot give him votes. For those who thought Judd did not rip us apart, in the words of "The Castle", tell them they're dreaming

Judd having a good game and his opponent having a good game are not mutually exclusive. McLean went head to head with Judd, and came out second best (because Judd is a better player), but that doesn't mean his game was bad. His role was more than just "stop Judd" and I think he did a damn good job.

If the role was just "stop Judd" it would have been Bartram or McDonald playing on him, not our best ball winner.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Judd having a good game and his opponent having a good game are not mutually exclusive. McLean went head to head with Judd, and came out second best (because Judd is a better player), but that doesn't mean his game was bad. His role was more than just "stop Judd" and I think he did a damn good job.

Off the ball, Judd killed him and he was probably only running at about 70-80%.

McLean wasn't bad, but Judd is in a league of his own.

[Dannyz 2,757]

6 - Green

5 - McLean

4 - Whelan

3 - Bartram

2 - Frawley

1 - Bruce

[deanox 9,915]

he played on judd and got destroyed... he did get alot of the ball and tried hard but u have to be kidding me.

...

3.Mclean

...

if he got 'destroyed' why did you give him 3 votes?

Off the ball, Judd killed him and he was probably only running at about 70-80%.

McLean wasn't bad, but Judd is in a league of his own.

judd is in his own league yes. but that isnt a reason why not to give mclean votes. the issue here is 'who were our best players' not 'how good was judd?'