Simple. If one club uses their sub the other club can use their sub without an injury

20 minutes ago, hank said:

Simple. If one club uses their sub the other club can use their sub without an injury

That is an interesting idea.  The trouble with 'can't play the next game' idea is that it could endanger players.  For example, coaches might be encouraged to keep a player on the ground with a minor injury (which would be OK in a week), but after playing-on the injury might get much worse. I guess you could argue if the coach wants to take the risk with injuring his players, so be it .

How about KISS principles?

1.No sub at all.

2.or 23rd Man, who can be used any time.

Coaches would have 10 on the bench if they could. Games used to be played with only an 18th and 19th man. 

Or how about forget the “injury” rule altogether?. you could have a 23rd man that can only come on when one player goes off permanently. Ie once subbed there is no return to the ground fr the eat of the match. Do it too soon and the club risks losing a player to injury w no replacement. 

Edited July 25, 20223 yr by Wells 11

 

I thought the that initially the sub rule was in place for concussion only and that if a player was subbed off they would automatically be unavailable for the next week.

Then the rule allowed for other injuries no matter how minor without the week off stipulation.

Perhaps put a 1 or 2 week ban on the subbed off player. This of course doesn't account for the use of it in Grand Finals.

Perhaps they could also release the oppositions subbed player if a club activates theirs. It is only fair that both teams have access to a fresh player.

On 7/25/2022 at 8:59 AM, Mr Steve said:

Just like dropping your knees to get a free it's cheating. AFL has to step in now and stop it. Not sure how you stop it but they have to. The rule was for concussed players when it was brought in and should never have been changed.  

They just have to enforce their own rule.  Players subbed off can't play for 12 days.

 

On 7/25/2022 at 2:48 PM, Wells 11 said:

Or how about forget the “injury” rule altogether?. you could have a 23rd man that can only come on when one player goes off permanently. Ie once subbed there is no return to the ground fr the eat of the match. Do it too soon and the club risks losing a player to injury w no replacement. 

Interesting concept - it would also mean that guys like Bedford could get a run late in a game without having to spend (I think it was at one stage 5) weeks without a game.

On 7/26/2022 at 2:14 PM, Demonland said:

I thought the that initially the sub rule was in place for concussion only and that if a player was subbed off they would automatically be unavailable for the next week.

Then the rule allowed for other injuries no matter how minor without the week off stipulation.

Perhaps put a 1 or 2 week ban on the subbed off player. This of course doesn't account for the use of it in Grand Finals.

Perhaps they could also release the oppositions subbed player if a club activates theirs. It is only fair that both teams have access to a fresh player.

Specifying the number of days could disadvantage teams with multiple short breaks, and advantage those with longer breaks.  Maybe missing one (or two) matches would be a more equable rule.

What a surprise that this could happen with a rule that wasn't thought through properly 

What a surprise.  AFL introduces new rule then allows it to be abused or tweaked by those using it... then changes the rule again to counter it's initial errors or to  appease the clubs/masses and/or denies it was ever intended to do what they first indicated was the reasoning behind its introduction in the first place.

Great example .... dissent rule

First half of the season "don't raise your arms like that...50 meters!"

Second half of season...players in ump's face arguing and remonstrating ... "what dissent rule!?.. play on!!"

Edited July 27, 20223 yr by Demon Dynasty

On 7/25/2022 at 10:01 AM, mauriesy said:

The rule should be that if a player is subbed off, they can't play the following week. That would limit it to serious injuries.

Agree, or they should just make it sub at will.

I think Tomlinson is our most versatile sub.

1 hour ago, old55 said:

I think Tomlinson is our most versatile sub.

Smith... when fit....until then probably Hunt

Should just rename it the "Tactical super sub" which can be implemented at anytime during game once.....Should be able to be used if someone is tired/sore/injured/whatever.   Farcical rule atm.

@crow_data_sci posted some interesting stats on Twitter regarding the use of the medi-sub. Port Adelaide has had the most players subbed off and play the next week in both of the last two years (5 in 2021, 4 in 2022). Melbourne and Sydney have had no player subbed off and play the next week at all across the last two seasons.

 

Source:

 

Bump. Again our sub unused and an important player as well who could have made a difference in the last quarter. 

8 minutes ago, John Crow Batty said:

Bump. Again our sub unused and an important player as well who could have made a difference in the last quarter. 

And the Pies subbed off a non contributor under pretence of an injury.

We need to start being a bit more willing to bend the rules like every other side. 

 Clubs have realized it’s used to get fresh legs on. It was used by the Dogs and by Pies (and I think Pies used it to get the underperforming Hoskin-Elliott off). 

Our Coach/s still asleep at the wheel sadly.  Might have made a difference last night.  Not ruthless enough MFC

Edited August 6, 20223 yr by Demon Dynasty

Agree, MFC missing a trick yet again as we are too nice.

1 hour ago, Clintosaurus said:

And the Pies subbed off a non contributor under pretence of an injury.

Yep Hoskin Elliott 0 possessions in the 1st qtr, 4 in the next 1 and a half.

I would've subbed sparrow for harmes

28 minutes ago, Demon Dynasty said:

Our Coach/s still asleep st the wheel sadly.  Might have made a difference last night.  Not ruthless enough MFC

No, not asleep, but a coach playing by the rules. 

Goodwin talks a big game about being ruthless. How about we be ruthless and use the sub like every other team. 

Edited August 6, 20223 yr by Fat Tony