52 minutes ago, Demonland said:

 

Last time we had a brownlow winner in the GF was Woey and we finished second. If we get the winner this year we could even it up to 15 all 

Malcolm Blight gave his tip for the brownlow this morning on SEN and his ti[p was a draw. Olly and Trac and he was serious, said it would be the first time two players from the same club have tied in the award.

11 minutes ago, Dante said:

Malcolm Blight gave his tip for the brownlow this morning on SEN and his ti[p was a draw. Olly and Trac and he was serious, said it would be the first time two players from the same club have tied in the award.

Hahaha can you imagine?! 
Not in a million years. 

Melbourne Betting

Round	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10	11	12	13	14	15	16	17	18	19	20	21	22	23	Total
Clayton Oliver	3	3		2	2	1		3	3	3	3	1		B	1		1	2	2	3	1		3	37
Christian Petracca	1	2	2	3	1	3				1		3		B	2		3	1		2	3	1		28
Max Gawn			3	1	3						1	2		B						1		2	2	15
Kysaiah Pickett							1							B										1
Christian Salem									2					B		1								3
Tom McDonald														B			2							2
Bayley Fritsch														B								3		3

Our Top 10 Leaderboard

	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10	11	12	13	14	15	16	17	18	19	20	21	22	23	Total
Clayton Oliver	3	3		2	2	1		3	3	3	3	1		B	1		1	2	2	3	1		3	37
Marcus Bontempelli		3			3	1		3	3	3		3	B	2	3	3		3	3					33
Ollie Wines		3		1	3	3	2		1	1		3	B	2	3		3		3	1	1		2	32
Tom Mitchell		2	2		2			1		3		B	3	1	3			3	1		3	3	2	29
Jack Steele		1		3					2		3		3	B	1	3	3	2		2	3		3	29
Christian Petracca	1	2	2	3	1	3				1		3		B	2		3	1		2	3	1		28
Jarryd Lyons	2		2		2		1	3	3	3			B	2		2			3	1	1	3		28
Zach Merrett	1		2	2		2		3		1	2		B		3		3	2		2	2	1	1	27
Darcy Parish			3			3			3	3	3	2	B			2		3			1	2		25
Travis Boak	3			3	2			3		2		B			3	1				2	1	1	3	24

Clarry should win it.  Predict 32 votes with 7  “3” votes!!  Only danger imv is Bont due to the umps love for the Dogs. 

AFL website has Clarry winning with the Bont as runner up.

On 9/16/2021 at 1:54 PM, durango said:

Sometimes players win the brownlow and their team does not even appear in the finals or if they do they don't play in the Grand Final

I suppose I could look this up, but who was the last player to win the Brownlow when his team didn't make the finals? I'll open the bidding with Bob Skilton, but I assume there have been others since then.

Nat Fyfe 2019

For the first time in VFL/AFL history two players from the same club tie - Oliver/Petracca.

19 minutes ago, Hannibal Inc. said:

For the first time in VFL/AFL history two players from the same club tie - Oliver/Petracca.

Can confirm, I’m also hearing this. 

The first 11 rounds are gonna be fun viewing. Reckon Trac will be first, Clarry second or third and Salem top 10

clarry to come home strong and win it

On 9/15/2021 at 7:22 PM, Bring-Back-Powell said:

He will.

Can just imagine it Clarry 2 votes behind last round votes for the Jeelong vs Dees clash of course read last

Melbourne  C ..... Petracca 1 Vote

Melbourne  C....................... Salem 2 votes 

MELBOURNE......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... C.OLIVER  3 BIG VOTES BABY.😍

Result........

TOTAL PANDEMONIUM!!😁

Edited September 18, 20214 yr by picket fence

2 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Can confirm, I’m also hearing this. 

(Haha - I think - ET)

Anyways, if it happens, I wouldn't mind it being Bontompelli and Macrae - for them, the distraction, and for Oliver and Petracca, the extra, 'we'll-show-'em!' spur!

Sorry to burst your bubble. 
Trac and Clarrie joint runners up. 
Max gets the 3 versus Geelong and wins by one -last vote of the night

most fair result seems to be a 6 way tie between Oliver, Petracca, Bont, Wines, Steele and Gawn

I'm thinking Trac will outpoll Clarrie. Mainly because Trac is so likeable, and Clarrie less so.

20 hours ago, Hannibal Inc. said:

For the first time in VFL/AFL history two players from the same club tie - Oliver/Petracca.

Christian Petracca/Clayton Oliver $26.00 if you want to take it.

On 9/16/2021 at 9:08 PM, Dante said:

Malcolm Blight gave his tip for the brownlow this morning on SEN and his ti[p was a draw. Olly and Trac and he was serious, said it would be the first time two players from the same club have tied in the award.

The man is left field for sure.

But let’s also remember, his lateral thinking on occasion has paid off in spades!

Footscray can have The Brownlow as a distraction. I am only interested in next Saturday 

The Brownlow means nothing to me ever since Dipperdemenico won it in 1986

Since when was that Thug ever the Fairest Player in a season??

Absolute waste of time

I'm interested in how MFC players scored in the Brownlow in our 10 Premierships in 25 years (1939 - 1964).

1939 - Jack Mueller eq 10th (* ineligible)

1940 - Ron Baggott eq 10th

1941 - No MFC player in top 10

1948 - Alby Rodda eq 10th

1955 - Denis Cordner eq 4th

1956 - Ron Barassi eq 4th

1957 - John Beckwith 6th

1959 - Bob Johnson eq 7th

1960 - John Beckwith eq 5th

1964 - Hassa Mann eq 8th

... and some wonder why we have a such a deep-rooted disrespect for umpires' judgement!

Out of sheer desperation my friends and I are playing a drinking game tonight where we drink every time our club’s Brownlow favourite gets a vote. 
My friends barrack for Essendon Carlton and Sydney. 
I’m going to be plastered.

TBH I had forgotten it was on after having spent most of the day looking at the nuances (or lack thereof) of Dan's plan.

Good luck young Oliver but I expect he may have too many team mates pulling votes off him.

It will be sweet if we top the team votes. Not sure if we have done that since the glory days.

On 9/18/2021 at 3:10 PM, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

I suppose I could look this up, but who was the last player to win the Brownlow when his team didn't make the finals? I'll open the bidding with Bob Skilton, but I assume there have been others since then.

Lots

Peter Moore did it for us.

In the old days players from lesser clubs were often favoured as they had less competition from team mates. Not sure why that has turned around but I suppose the game does not allow individual dominance like it once did.

On 9/18/2021 at 4:40 PM, picket fence said:

Can just imagine it Clarry 2 votes behind last round votes for the Jeelong vs Dees clash of course read last

Melbourne  C ..... Petracca 1 Vote

Melbourne  C....................... Salem 2 votes 

MELBOURNE......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... C.OLIVER  3 BIG VOTES BABY.😍

Result........

TOTAL PANDEMONIUM!!😁

althought i love the romance in it. I reckon 

M........ Gawn might poll a vote here lol