Toby Green, the perfect definition of a flawed genius. 

3 minutes ago, loges said:

Greens head pulled off no free

yeah, bad no-call that one

1 minute ago, Damo said:

It shows how much the crowd would influence the umpires if they were screaming. Its just natural. i really hope we have an empty stadium

 

But somehow they are still getting the better of the decisions from the mags

1 minute ago, Damo said:

It shows how much the crowd would influence the umpires if they were screaming. Its just natural. i really hope we have an empty stadium

 

I think you’ll get your wish. Can’t see a VIC crowd by 21 August.

If the AFL make the dreaded Perth September decision, the Geel V Dees game could even be at Perth’s Optus Stadium.

A week for selwood?

5 minutes ago, monoccular said:

Friggin Geelong - appealing for deliberate OOB when the ball didn't even go out.  I guess they thought that the crowd (BT says there is a crowd) would influence the maggot.

Right? Clearly didn’t go OOB but they appealed nonetheless. Pathetic knee jerk reactions from a side that knows the match is lost and instead of galvanising they’ll revert to desperate pleading for something that isn’t there. God, how I hate them. 

How good has Taylor been on Hawkins? He's a nice kick too. You'd expect Hawkins to have most in the contest but Taylor has beaten him a number of times and taken multiple important intercept marks.

9 minutes ago, Pates said:

Geelong are the walking wounded tonight, Giants have just lost Daniel but they should have the fresher legs. 

Walking wounded, from a RSL WW1 retirement home.

Daniel subbed out through concussion from Selwood’s bump. He HAS to be suspended. Minimum one week (give him an extra week to be sure 😉). 

6 minutes ago, monoccular said:

Geelong % won't matter to us (unless they manage a draw sometime soon).

FFS  yet another 50 m free shot at goal - the maggots should get the coach's award from Scott

Green a genuine high tackle (no even a Selwoodesque one) in goal kicking range ignored.

It effects Port who are 1 win behind them. Could be the difference between us playing Port or Geelong finals week 1.

Though Cats now only 4 goals behind, so % might well be moot

2 minutes ago, Demon_spurs said:

But somehow they are still getting the better of the decisions from the mags

But it probs would be two- or threefold had there been a crowd. 

1 minute ago, leave it to deever said:

A week for selwood?

Should be

But Michael Christian is a complete Tattslottery

Just now, Pates said:

Daniel subbed out through concussion from Selwood’s bump. He HAS to be suspended. Minimum one week (give him an extra week to be sure 😉). 

Thought commentators said hammy?

31 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

 

Can someone work out if Geeling lose tonight what does that mean in terms of how many wins we need to secure top 4?

If they lose tonight, and we beat them in 2 weeks time,  we could drop one of the next 2 and still finish above them on the ladder.

Henry is a good player.

He looks like E.T.

Does anybody else hear the pure disappointment from BT and Brayshaw when the Cats don’t score, and the lack of enthusiasm when the Giants score?

I miss Clinton, he got excited for the game, not the club.

Selwood just bought a free far softer than the one ignored (won't say missed as that could imply a degree of impartiality) to Greene.  Almost resulted in a goal.

6 minutes ago, Pates said:

Daniel subbed out through concussion from Selwood’s bump. He HAS to be suspended. Minimum one week (give him an extra week to be sure 😉). 

I see what your saying.😁 and sadly danger not better for the same time.

Edited August 6, 20214 yr by leave it to deever

So strange watching a game at Cat park and no Boos...

11 minutes ago, leave it to deever said:

A week for selwood?

Watch him get off. 

The giants need one more goal to ice this

9 minutes ago, Pates said:

Daniel subbed out through concussion from Selwood’s bump. He HAS to be suspended. Minimum one week (give him an extra week to be sure 😉). 

Give him 3

Taylor having a cracking game for GWS. Bright future for him

GWS need to score

Might have a bit of a problem here fellas.

Only 15 pts down and GWS off a 5 day break.