Luke Jackson's last quarter

[Roost it far 9,695]

8 minutes ago, Mental Demons said:

 

There is a lot of sense in what I say. if we have to carry him while he learns to be a forward, we will lose too many games to make the finals. Daw is a better forward. Courtney is a better ruck and kicks goals. We have two Browns who are better forwards than Jackson. Weid is a better forward too. Would you hold these guys out for Jackson? I think Chandler would have been more useful last Saturday and he definitely will be against the Saints. Crawl back up your own hole, fool.

 

You’re an I d i o t

[Deebymistake 790]

11 hours ago, Mental Demons said:

The only reason to play Jackson at the moment is to increase his trade value. Jackson is superfluous to need and it was a mistake to draft him. He will never be a first ruck and if he can't make this team as a forward he will be playing at Casey most of the year. We have 2 guys running around Casey that would do Jackson's job better. Majac has been doing well and Andrew Courtney is a better ruck and a better forward. The best hope is that some team sees value in Jackson and take him off our hands. 

Jeepers, a bit rough hey? I sincerely hope Jackson turns out to be our own Bontempelli & you fill yourself with humble pie.

 

[Mental Demons 136]

2 minutes ago, Deebymistake said:

Jeepers, a bit rough hey? I sincerely hope Jackson turns out to be our own Bontempelli & you fill yourself with humble pie.

I don't have anything against Jackson personally and agree he has potential. If he turns out to be another Bontempelli, it will not be with us because he is years away from being a regular first choice, best 22. We just don't really have a job for him to do than be a forward. He will be better if he has to earn his place in the team by kicking lots of goals at Casey. I think it would be better for his career if we traded him at years end. Freo would be a better fit. They are still rebuilding, he would get more of a go.

[Dr.D 1,771]

6 hours ago, 58er said:

You are aptly named poster MD.

There is not an ounce of common sense in your post and didn't you see Jacko in the last quarter?

Yes kicking was wayward but he had a real breakdown poor guy.
 

He is a future star and 99% of Dees fans can see that. 
 

Please Crawl back into your burrow and go to sleep during the winter where you can't post such a cruel and inaccurate opinion.

did you watch the first 3 quarters? 

Logan Mcdonald from Sydney has already played better in his first game than Jackson has a forward. Fact.

[Flower Magic 776]

As the original poster of this thread, I'm glad that 99% of supporters agree with me. MD is clearly wrestling with a different type of demon, I hope he finds the help that he needs. I will be watching Luke Jackson's development closely over the next few years and expect it to be a most enjoyable ride. 

[Roost it far 9,695]

22 hours ago, Mental Demons said:

I don't have anything against Jackson personally and agree he has potential. If he turns out to be another Bontempelli, it will not be with us because he is years away from being a regular first choice, best 22. We just don't really have a job for him to do than be a forward. He will be better if he has to earn his place in the team by kicking lots of goals at Casey. I think it would be better for his career if we traded him at years end. Freo would be a better fit. They are still rebuilding, he would get more of a go.

You play him as first ruck and he becomes a midfielder after that. You have no clue

[Pickett2Jackson 3,904]

22 hours ago, Dr.D said:

did you watch the first 3 quarters? 

Logan Mcdonald from Sydney has already played better in his first game than Jackson has a forward. Fact.

What does Logan farkin McDonald have to do with anything?

 

[Pates 9,680]

I really like the look of Jackson, but right now he is only giving us tantilising "flashes". I really want to see him put in a performance that has him involved in the game for the full 4 quarters. He also needed someone to come after he took that big grab and say, "mate, back yourself". I would've preferred to see him take the shot on and miss it, instead of passing to Petracca.

[DeeSpencer 26,388]

48 minutes ago, Pates said:

I really like the look of Jackson, but right now he is only giving us tantilising "flashes". I really want to see him put in a performance that has him involved in the game for the full 4 quarters. He also needed someone to come after he took that big grab and say, "mate, back yourself". I would've preferred to see him take the shot on and miss it, instead of passing to Petracca.

He should've passed the one previous to Petracca, it was nice to see him make up for it and dish it off. We need to keep encouraging that selfless culture.

[Dees2014 2,377]

On 3/20/2021 at 6:43 PM, Flower Magic said:

Watching this guy in the last quarter, I honestly believe that he is our next bona fide superstar. Quiet for three quarters, then someone or something flicked the switch. His marking became clean and precise, and his delivery by hand was perfect. He will improve his set shot kicking I'm sure, and will boot a few bags in the future. 

Just finished watching the replay again. No doubt Jackson has a very high upside. Some of the marks he took up forward, particularly in the second half were true class. 
 

l still don’t understand though why these guys are such unreliable kicks, particularly for goal. Jackson was the worst offender on Saturday, some awful shanks, but you could also put Tracca, Max, Harmes, Brayshaw, even Fritz at various times times in the second half in that category. 

[Dees2014 2,377]

On 3/20/2021 at 7:10 PM, Little Goffy said:

A very young ruckman able to develop while playing a role adequately at the top level is nothing to be scoffed at.  Would be entirely happy if over the course of this season he just became enough of a potential headache that opponents have to take him seriously and make our mix of talls even harder to plan for.

Heard Max earlier in the year describing his breakout game (l think in 2013) down at Geelong when everything clicked for him. I remember it: clearly BOG, we won well, and Max’s became thereafter one of the elite players in the game. Before that he was good at times, but hardly elite, and inconsistent. 
 

Jackson will have one of those days in the next year or so, but l think he will be more Carey than Gawn. Huge potential.

[Macca 17,120]

13 minutes ago, Dees2014 said:

Just finished watching the replay again. No doubt Jackson has a very high upside. Some of the marks he took up forward, particularly in the second half were true class. 
 

l still don’t understand though why these guys are such unreliable kicks, particularly for goal. Jackson was the worst offender on Saturday, some awful shanks, but you could also put Tracca, Max, Harmes, Brayshaw, even Fritz at various times times in the second half in that category. 

A lot of our players have technical issues with their actions ... we should have had a biomechanics expert down at the club over a decade ago

On top of that not many want to take on the big sticks (they'd rather hand it off) So a lack of confidence intensifies the issue.  And that in turn sends a clear message to the opposition

And many here have being saying as such (here) for a decade or more.  Not that the club would take any notice of what those on a fans site would say but can't they have thought of it themselves?

One of the most important aspects for a footballer is his ability to kick well under pressure (either perceived pressure or actual pressure)

Hit targets or turn the ball over ... miss an easy shot for goal (choke) and you hand the ball back to the opposition (an 11 point turn around can often result)

Do that against the good sides and you lose the game 

We will not beat the best sides until we sort out our poor kicking skills

It's terrific that we defeated Freo but the club needs to look at the bigger picture and become a lot more professional with regards to our disposal issues

 

[Pates 9,680]

1 hour ago, DeeSpencer said:

He should've passed the one previous to Petracca, it was nice to see him make up for it and dish it off. We need to keep encouraging that selfless culture.

Encouraging selfless footy is great, and I'm all for it. But when you're ticking on to the final kicks of the game, the young bloke has taken a ripping mark, and Petracca wasn't actually in a much better position (he actually got called play on from his kick!), I would really have liked someone to give him a pat on the head and say, "well done mate, now kick the goal".

[58er 6,829]

On 3/21/2021 at 8:37 PM, Mental Demons said:

 

There is a lot of sense in what I say. if we have to carry him while he learns to be a forward, we will lose too many games to make the finals. Daw is a better forward. Courtney is a better ruck and kicks goals. We have two Browns who are better forwards than Jackson. Weid is a better forward too. Would you hold these guys out for Jackson? I think Chandler would have been more useful last Saturday and he definitely will be against the Saints. Crawl back up your own hole, fool.

 

See my posts before and after on this and you are still crucifying a 7 mane player if 19 years who is being developed as a ruck/ forward / on baller.

Perhsps you should consider your own medicine by looking for your own brain which as I don't  think your post displays any Useful contribution to this topic.

Not one person has  agreed about your ridiculous trading idea and I can't understand what LJ has done  ( more likely not done) for you to be so judgemental on a youngster.

[Macca 17,120]

6 hours ago, 58er said:

See my posts before and after on this and you are still crucifying a 7 mane player if 19 years who is being developed as a ruck/ forward / on baller.

Perhsps you should consider your own medicine by looking for your own brain which as I don't  think your post displays any Useful contribution to this topic.

Not one person has  agreed about your ridiculous trading idea and I can't understand what LJ has done  ( more likely not done) for you to be so judgemental on a youngster.

MD's last major target was none other than Steven May

So perhaps we should be looking at the positives (opposite outcomes lol)

So we could point MD towards an out of form player like Harmes in order to get James back into top form!

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,058]

10 hours ago, Dees2014 said:

Just finished watching the replay again. No doubt Jackson has a very high upside. Some of the marks he took up forward, particularly in the second half were true class. 
 

l still don’t understand though why these guys are such unreliable kicks, particularly for goal. Jackson was the worst offender on Saturday, some awful shanks, but you could also put Tracca, Max, Harmes, Brayshaw, even Fritz at various times times in the second half in that category. 

Yes, we have a problem, and, yes, some of the kicking on Saturday was appalling. Not just shots at goal but also around the ground, particuarly the last kick into the forward line and especially in the final quarter.

For those who were not at the ground, though, it may be worth pointing out that there was a very fluky, strong wind blowing. Ostensibly toward the city end, but by the time it gets into the cauldron it seems to blow every which way. It was quite obvious that many of the kicks (from both teams) toward the goals at the city end were affected by the wind. And not in a good way.

[DistrACTION Jackson 10,328]

2 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

Yes, we have a problem, and, yes, some of the kicking on Saturday was appalling. Not just shots at goal but also around the ground, particuarly the last kick into the forward line and especially in the final quarter.

For those who were not at the ground, though, it may be worth pointing out that there was a very fluky, strong wind blowing. Ostensibly toward the city end, but by the time it gets into the cauldron it seems to blow every which way. It was quite obvious that many of the kicks (from both teams) toward the goals at the city end were affected by the wind. And not in a good way.

I was sitting down that end and it was really strong. The flags were blowing all day.

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,297]

10 hours ago, Dees2014 said:

Just finished watching the replay again. No doubt Jackson has a very high upside. Some of the marks he took up forward, particularly in the second half were true class. 
 

l still don’t understand though why these guys are such unreliable kicks, particularly for goal. Jackson was the worst offender on Saturday, some awful shanks, but you could also put Tracca, Max, Harmes, Brayshaw, even Fritz at various times times in the second half in that category. 

I’m not sure how many people questioning the goal kicking (rightly so) were at The G , but there was a pretty constant strong breeze all day.

It swirls inside the stadium and many times the ball came off the boot straight and then went rapidly in a complete different direction to the flags on the scoreboard.

Both teams had the same problem.

I’ll hazard a guess “Mental Demons” wasn’t at the ground this weekend.

 

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,297]

9 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

Yes, we have a problem, and, yes, some of the kicking on Saturday was appalling. Not just shots at goal but also around the ground, particuarly the last kick into the forward line and especially in the final quarter.

For those who were not at the ground, though, it may be worth pointing out that there was a very fluky, strong wind blowing. Ostensibly toward the city end, but by the time it gets into the cauldron it seems to blow every which way. It was quite obvious that many of the kicks (from both teams) toward the goals at the city end were affected by the wind. And not in a good way.

Beat me to it!

[JimmyGadson 3,455]

10 hours ago, Dees2014 said:

Jackson will have one of those days in the next year or so, but l think he will be more Carey than Gawn. Huge potential.

Carey?! Hahaha.

[PaulRB 6,435]

Also, re goal kicking accuracy, it was evident that fatigue was hitting most players late in quarters and last 10 min of each half. 

Nothing like real game pressure to push the players (who've not played 20 min quarters for over a year) into muscle burn while trying to settle for a shot on goal.

Also, it seemed to happen across the competition to greater or less degrees...

Hopefully, our goal kicking will improve as we acclimatise to the longer format and players "harden" during the season.

Oh, and on Jackson, will be a gun as he matures and realises his evident talents, but will take another year or two to do so...

Edited March 22, 2021 by PaulRB

[DeePressed 114]

On 3/21/2021 at 9:07 PM, Mental Demons said:

I don't have anything against Jackson personally and agree he has potential. If he turns out to be another Bontempelli, it will not be with us because he is years away from being a regular first choice, best 22. We just don't really have a job for him to do than be a forward. He will be better if he has to earn his place in the team by kicking lots of goals at Casey. I think it would be better for his career if we traded him at years end. Freo would be a better fit. They are still rebuilding, he would get more of a go.

I'm assuming this is actually a baiting/stitch up account

 

[Docs Demons 1,792]

10 hours ago, Pates said:

Encouraging selfless footy is great, and I'm all for it. But when you're ticking on to the final kicks of the game, the young bloke has taken a ripping mark, and Petracca wasn't actually in a much better position (he actually got called play on from his kick!), I would really have liked someone to give him a pat on the head and say, "well done mate, now kick the goal".

Agree. Selfless footy is great but in my view when in range you take ownership and kick the bloody goal (unless someone is in goal square by themselves) then everyone will get around you after a good mark and more importantly slotting it through the big ones. 

[Go the Biff 3,468]

1 hour ago, Hell Bent said:

I’m not sure how many people questioning the goal kicking (rightly so) were at The G , but there was a pretty constant strong breeze all day.

It swirls inside the stadium and many times the ball came off the boot straight and then went rapidly in a complete different direction to the flags on the scoreboard.

Both teams had the same problem.

I’ll hazard a guess “Mental Demons” wasn’t at the ground this weekend.

 

This. There were a few shots from both teams where the ball swung violently to the left as it got near the goal line. Looked like someone left a door open !

[Pickett2Jackson 3,904]

11 hours ago, Pates said:

Encouraging selfless footy is great, and I'm all for it. But when you're ticking on to the final kicks of the game, the young bloke has taken a ripping mark, and Petracca wasn't actually in a much better position (he actually got called play on from his kick!), I would really have liked someone to give him a pat on the head and say, "well done mate, now kick the goal".

Watched the replay last night and you could hear the entire crowd groan as one when LJ passed it off.  Everyone wanted him to kick a big goal after taking that grab.  Imagine the confidence he would have gotten.