Who should our next GM be?

[olisik 4,060]

 

With an inexperienced GM at the helm for the last 7 years it’s time to get some experience in. He has received multiple promotions despite being one of our match day coaches during 186 loss. It’s time to go Mahoney.

Mahoney was picked up as an assistant coach for 2008. He served as a forward line coach

In September 2011, Mahoney was appointed Melbourne's Football Manager after Mark Neeld was appointed as senior coach. 

In September 2013, Mahoney was appointed Melbourne's General Manager - Football Operations by CEO Peter Jackson.

[Dwight Schrute 16,750]

I have been a supporter of JM for a while and generally think he's been pretty good but it's becoming obvious the club needs some serious change. 

if we could get Neale Balme or Geoff Walsh in for that role that'd be great, if not i'd be offering it to Alan Richardson. 

[DeeSpencer 23,122]

Someone from Fenway Sports Group, the owners of the Boston Red Socks and Liverpool.

We need to find an edge on the competition and stop being a poor, smaller, dumber version of every other club. Analytics is that edge.

There's going to be assistant coaches out there who will just about work for free given the money crunch. So we can find coaches. We can hire one just to work with a new GM and teach them the game if they don't know anything about it. In fact it's probably better they don't because they won't have any preconceived biases. 

 

[Elegt 872]

27 minutes ago, olisik said:

 

With an inexperienced GM at the helm for the last 7 years it’s time to get some experience in. He has received multiple promotions despite being one of our match day coaches during 186 loss. It’s time to go Mahoney.

Mahoney was picked up as an assistant coach for 2008. He served as a forward line coach

In September 2011, Mahoney was appointed Melbourne's Football Manager after Mark Neeld was appointed as senior coach. 

In September 2013, Mahoney was appointed Melbourne's General Manager - Football Operations by CEO Peter Jackson.

Wasn't he in charge of the internal review conducted? He was also responsible for the recruiting of Jake Lever which hasn't paid off. He's first on the chopping block IMO

[Pickett2Jackson 3,904]

Whos left over from 186?  Mahoney, Jones?  Anyone else?  They all need to be culled.

Edited September 7, 2020 by Pickett2Jackson

[olisik 4,060]

7 minutes ago, Elegt said:

Wasn't he in charge of the internal review conducted? He was also responsible for the recruiting of Jake Lever which hasn't paid off. He's first on the chopping block IMO

Yes he was in charge of marking his own homework as well and list decisions like Harmes 5 years or KK 4 years and Jack Watts coach for first 3 years. Always happy to hide in the shadows to when things don’t go well.

Edited September 7, 2020 by olisik

[Binmans PA 26,021]

23 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

Someone from Fenway Sports Group, the owners of the Boston Red Socks and Liverpool.

We need to find an edge on the competition and stop being a poor, smaller, dumber version of every other club. Analytics is that edge.

There's going to be assistant coaches out there who will just about work for free given the money crunch. So we can find coaches. We can hire one just to work with a new GM and teach them the game if they don't know anything about it. In fact it's probably better they don't because they won't have any preconceived biases. 

 

AFL isn't a big enough business for Fenway.

Would love them to own both my football teams though.

[Supreme_Demon 3,009]

1 hour ago, Patches O’houlihan said:

I have been a supporter of JM for a while and generally think he's been pretty good but it's becoming obvious the club needs some serious change. 

if we could get Neale Balme or Geoff Walsh in for that role that'd be great, if not i'd be offering it to Alan Richardson. 

Yep...sadly Josh Mahoney needs to go too. Been in the position as Football Manager of General Operations for a while now. 

A total clean out of the football department means out with the old amd in with the new.

This needs to be a well thought out process. We need to recruit the best of the best.

i highly doubt Neil Balme would leave Richmond to come back to us. Not after we sacked him as coach in 1997. I am under the assumption there is still bad blood there.

I would go all out for Brad Scott the former North Melbourne coach to be Football Manager of General Operations. Otherwise, someone from a recent Premiership winning club that has a good culture which is also ruthless and demands high standards. Alan Richardson could also be moved to that role if he is shifted from being Director of coaching

Whoever we choose, they need to be a good quality football person who has a hunger to help us win a Premiership at the Demons.

Edited September 7, 2020 by Supreme_Demon

[whatwhat say what 18,908]

 

1 hour ago, Supreme_Demon said:

Yep...sadly Josh Mahoney needs to go too. Been in the position as Football Manager of General Operations for a while now. 

A total clean out of the football department means out with the old amd in with the new.

This needs to be a well thought out process. We need to recruit the best of the best.

i highly doubt Neil Balme would leave Richmond to come back to us. Not after we sacked him as coach in 1997. I am under the assumption there is still bad blood there.

I would go all out for Brad Scott the former North Melbourne coach to be Football Manager of General Operations. Otherwise, someone from a recent Premiership winning club that has a good culture which is also ruthless and demands high standards. Alan Richardson could also be moved to that role if he is shifted from being Director of coaching

Whoever we choose, they need to be a good quality football person who has a hunger to help us win a Premiership at the Demons.

dunno how there can be bad blood with balme considering everyone from that time is well and truly gone

scott has just been appointed boss of football victoria as the afl shift jobs around to find jobs for the boys, hasn't he?

also a bit contradictory to ask for "someone from a recent Premiership winning club that has a good culture which is also ruthless and demands high standards" and then also say "Alan Richardson could also be moved to that role"

in terms of managing the soft cap i agree that richardson going into that position makes sense...i can't fathom how we gave him a five year deal

mind you, i have no idea what he actually does - what is a director of coaching?

whatever way - mahoney has got to go

Edited September 7, 2020 by whatwhatsaywhat

[Dr. Gonzo 22,412]

Richo has a 5 year deal? This club is stuffed beyond repair

[dazzledavey36 48,714]

Neil Balme 

[layzie 28,708]

7 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

Someone from Fenway Sports Group, the owners of the Boston Red Socks and Liverpool.

We need to find an edge on the competition and stop being a poor, smaller, dumber version of every other club. Analytics is that edge.

There's going to be assistant coaches out there who will just about work for free given the money crunch. So we can find coaches. We can hire one just to work with a new GM and teach them the game if they don't know anything about it. In fact it's probably better they don't because they won't have any preconceived biases. 

 

Good thinking but the success of FSG and their model is that they own the club and bring in the right people who know the game back to front for these positions. 

We do need to find the edge though.

[Demon Dynasty 15,395]

6 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Neil Balme 

I like the idea but why would he bother coming back to the club that treated him so poorly Dazzle?

[Demon Dynasty 15,395]

8 hours ago, olisik said:

 

With an inexperienced GM at the helm for the last 7 years it’s time to get some experience in. He has received multiple promotions despite being one of our match day coaches during 186 loss. It’s time to go Mahoney.

Mahoney was picked up as an assistant coach for 2008. He served as a forward line coach

In September 2011, Mahoney was appointed Melbourne's Football Manager after Mark Neeld was appointed as senior coach. 

In September 2013, Mahoney was appointed Melbourne's General Manager - Football Operations by CEO Peter Jackson.

Not just Mahoney.  Pert needs to go as well.  He's been a disaster from day one with his first major effort the signing and anointing of SG into a rediculous extension that has committed this club to 3 further years of failing.

This club has stuffed up its coaching selections/contracts on plenty of other occasions but this ranks up there with the best of the worst decisions it's witnessed.

The fish rots from the head.

[layzie 28,708]

Let's get someone from NASA. They could put a man on the moon quite easily I'm sure reaching the 8 would be a piece of cake for them. 

[dazzledavey36 48,714]

10 minutes ago, Rusty Nails said:

I like the idea but why would he bother coming back to the club that treated him so poorly Dazzle?

Time heals wounds Rusty. Plus the club has changed internally since his days at the club with fresh faces etc.

What hasn't changed is the culture as a whole. It sucks. 

[Waltham33 409]

5 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Time heals wounds Rusty. Plus the club has changed internally since his days at the club with fresh faces etc.

What hasn't changed is the culture as a whole. It sucks. 

he did leave 24 years ago.  If he has the fire to still do it - it would be great to have him back