POSTGAME: MS01 vs Adelaide

[binman 42,043]

40 minutes ago, McQueen said:

The ball was well gone and Crouch’s intent was to go the man. He propped himself to launch upwards so in reality he had better momentum than an in-flight Oliver. The evidence is there for all to see. 
 

Should cop a week - no questions asked. 

Has to get a week. Should get 2. Stupid decision.

May got a week in the corresponding practice game last year.  Many on here argued he shouldn't have even been reported, let alone cop a week. Crouch has to go

[Hunt29 270]

Sure it was a practice match but we sure ran it out well. (Burgess Effect)

Trac was amazing. Let’s hope this is his breakout. Heard Liam Pickering on radio last night. Said he spoke to Jordan Lewis last week. Lewis said Petracca finally has his act together.

Kozzy looks like he’ll be an excitement machine. 

Viney well. Seems to be covering the ground well and disposed of the footy well. 

Clarry was good however needs to stop looking for a close handball. When he kicks it he kicks it well. Just needs to do it more. 

Brown will be handy. Worked well with Tmac who had his kicking radar on  

We really missed a ruckman. Mids did well despite this. 

Lever Intercepted well early on. We need May though as another exit kick option. 

Pretty happy overall. 

[Dee Zephyr 19,178]

I liked Jackson’s intent at getting the ball. Just a small observation. When he was contesting centre bounces there were a couple of occasions when the ball went forward our way off hands and he took off chasing it really fast, even outran our mids to it after jumping.

On both occasions he didn’t win the ball as the Crows back flankers beat him to it. The slightly more experienced O’Brien ran the other way and ended up being on the end of it at half forward. No concern there, as I’m sure he will learn when to go for the ball and when to follow his direct opponent. I was mainly fascinated by his agility and instinct to compete. 

[deanox 9,718]

1 hour ago, McQueen said:

The ball was well gone and Crouch’s intent was to go the man. He propped himself to launch upwards so in reality he had better momentum than an in-flight Oliver. The evidence is there for all to see. 
 

Should cop a week - no questions asked. 

The ball was well gone but at pace the contact was inevitable given Over tried to shepherd and Crouch wanted to go the man: blocking is legal and at full pace he only has a fraction of a second. 

He absolutley propelled upwards, which was the reason the elbow came up too, so I have no problem with getting a week.

But I really don't think there is much in it. It's sloppy, and a bit worse than May's was, which I think was think was made worse by the fact that Berry didn't look where he was going. 

[BAMF 4,139]

I've been talking Petracca up to my mates and saying he my sneaky Supercoach player that no one else will pick.

Petracca : 188 supercoach points.

Practice match and all that.. but he was up against Brad Crouch for a lot of it.

[MyFavouriteMartian 572]

17 hours ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Before the anti Spargo brigade get going I thought that while he suffered three glaring skill errors that I can recall he was in the right place at the right time.Correct those skill errors and the Spargo we used to know is back.

Langdon looks likely but his hairstyle makes him easy to spot.

I agree.  It was a good busy start for him.   Just misjudged the closing speed of some opposition, as he wayed up his options. Getting the ball to boot a little late.

[Deemania since 56 6,563]

17 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

Lockhart, Vanders and Sparrow

Very good signs from these three, as well as the other improvements. Great signs of depth and competence for the coming season.

[Demon Head 266]

What happened to Joel Smith?

[Demonland 70,358]

4 hours ago, 640MD said:

Its a practice match !    However   are you not glad that we barrack for the Demons rather than the cats  Go Dees

My brother in law, who is a cat's fan, was quick to remind me about what being Feb/Mar Champions means. 

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,642]

4 minutes ago, Demonland said:

My brother in law, who is a cat's fan, was quick to remind me about what being Feb/Mar Champions means. 

Just point him to our 2019 and remind him what Feb/Mar sub par means too!

[Demonland 70,358]

1 minute ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

Just point him to our 2019 and remind him what Feb/Mar sub par means too!

Unfortunately opposition fans and commentators either don't buy that line or forget to mention it when talking about the fall from grace.

[pewpewpew 738]

2 hours ago, demonstone said:

From The Mongrel Punts' review of the game ...

Aaron vandenBerg looked like he was having fun out there today, crashing in to register eight tackles as he used his body as a battering ram to clear the path for teammates. Whilst less impactful, Alex Neal-Bullen started to find the footy as well. These two were sorely missed in 2019, and the Dees look a lot better with them in the team.

What's he talking about regarding Nibbler being "sorely missed" last year?

He's not wrong. Only about the sorely missed. Nibbler was hardly sighted last year.

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,642]

29 minutes ago, BAMF said:

I've been talking Petracca up to my mates and saying he my sneaky Supercoach player that no one else will pick.

Petracca : 188 supercoach points.

Practice match and all that.. but he was up against Brad Crouch for a lot of it.

I think you can just about kiss goodbye to that.

On a similar note, it's hard to believe that Slone got picked to represent the big V over either Trac or Oliver.  Blinkered selectors much?  I'm quite ok that Trac doesn't play in this game for now though.

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,642]

I don't really want to start or add to an Oscar pile on, but was quite disappointed in not only his game, but Hibbo's as well.  Thought that Hibbo turned the ball over galore by foot and sold team mates into trouble by hand, in the first quarter in particular.  Oscar played with a real lack of confidence, intensity or both, typified by spilling an absolute sitter of a mark over the boundary line under little to no pressure in the last quarter when we had the game well under control.

I really do hope that both these players can find confidence, form and turn things around quickly and hopefully May and Hore back into the side will steady the side down back, because I think we looked pretty exposed down there, particularly against good opposition.

[MyFavouriteMartian 572]

26 minutes ago, Demonland said:

My brother in law, who is a cat's fan, was quick to remind me about what being Feb/Mar Champions means. 

We've beaten no-one yet, and its still Summer.

[Neitz the Great 555]

Was confused RE the Hore situation. Would’ve thought he would be a good third tall option with lever and may. Anyone with any info? 

[jnrmac 19,910]

58 minutes ago, Demonland said:

My brother in law, who is a cat's fan, was quick to remind me about what being Feb/Mar Champions means. 

I have one of those too....

[DubDee 24,528]

6 hours ago, Demonland said:

If May got one what does Crouch get?

One at the very least. I don’t get how the media are questioning it. Clear contact with the head. Clarry is as tough as nails

[MO FINE 160]

I would like to see Bedford get a chance as a small forward, not at the expense of Pickett but instead of Spargo so we can compare where these two are at.

[Deemania since 56 6,563]

1 hour ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

I don't really want to start or add to an Oscar pile on, but was quite disappointed in not only his game, but Hibbo's as well.  Thought that Hibbo turned the ball over galore by foot and sold team mates into trouble by hand, in the first quarter in particular.  Oscar played with a real lack of confidence, intensity or both, typified by spilling an absolute sitter of a mark over the boundary line under little to no pressure in the last quarter when we had the game well under control.

I really do hope that both these players can find confidence, form and turn things around quickly and hopefully May and Hore back into the side will steady the side down back, because I think we looked pretty exposed down there, particularly against good opposition.

From time to time, Hibbo shows a little bit more resolve, more concentration, more desire to do stuff for the team. He will get back to this more consistent play, surely. He does feed out a good ball and can run with purpose to set something up. Whereas the other one, well, I was very surprised that he got into the team/onto the field. One spoil, one kick, six leaks or non-contested regionalisations do not make a guernsey in my opinion but I have said that type of thing many times before.  May, Hore and a utility backman will make a whole difference down there now that Nev and HIbbo are getting on in years. I'd also expect a rather quick rise from a couple of our new young'uns - the backline seems to be a potential breeding ground at the moment - certainly in times of need. 

[loges 6,767]

2 hours ago, Demonland said:

My brother in law, who is a cat's fan, was quick to remind me about what being Feb/Mar Champions means. 

He's only saying that to cover for their dismal effort yesterday.

[Nelo 813]

2 hours ago, BAMF said:

I've been talking Petracca up to my mates and saying he my sneaky Supercoach player that no one else will pick.

Petracca : 188 supercoach points.

Practice match and all that.. but he was up against Brad Crouch for a lot of it.

I think your smoky supercoach tip is blown!

[Robbie57 2,003]

A lot to like from that game. When Weed was at CHF in the last he looked good very comfortable he will do well this year. Jones looked like he was enjoying himself. Please sign trac to a big deal this week. What impressed was we were even across the ground with few obvious shockers and more importantly we ran out the game the much fitter team. It became obvious in the last we would not be run down even as we went against the wind. The coaches have got the pre season right which bodes well for a decent year. 
 

[Sargent Shultz 267]

14 hours ago, picket fence said:

Spargo is a substandard AFL Player. Has limited skills and as you have alluded to "Glaring Skill Errors"

How he gets a game in front of Hunt is "Perplexing"

The issue i have with Spargo is he cant get a contested ball- which is fine not all players need to do that- so he is in the team to recieve a ball from someone who "gets the ball" and distribute it to a player who can do something with it- goal or move it forward when he is playing high OR kick a goal when he is playing forward (he kicked 2 goals in 8 matches last year) The problem is his disposal is often (at best 50/50) appaling and results in a turnover. A "link up player" like Spargo must have an efficency ratio more like 90/10. He is now in his 3rd year and will always be a fringe player who gets a game when all other options are injured. He may have worth a try but its now time to cut our losses and move him on next year. Kozzie has showm more in 10 minutes than Charlie has shown in 26 games, and we seem to have a few small forwards now.

[FireInTheBennelly 4,060]

Have we unearthed our new forward/ruck?

Can we play TMac and Brown forward and have Weids rotating with Gawn?