Training Ground?

[whatwhat say what 22,031]

20 minutes ago, drdrake said:

Very easy, you need to show a community benefit, you can't just go in with we want money for AFL training base.  Look back at most my posts on this, there needs to be some community benefit.

Geelong will add in indoor netball courts or something.  Kardina Park has a netball outdoor facility, plus the home of AFL barwon umpires.  They will add in upgrade to the umpire facility add inside cricket nets, netball courts.  They are add ons to get the money.

function and events facilities is seemingly a big part of this pitch too

[Sir Why You Little 36,569]

Jeeelong is a City 

The Cats are the only Team down there

they get what they want. 
 

The Ghost of Frank Costa still pulls a few strings…

[demon3165 2,560]

Some of you have no idea how complex the dealings are with all this regarding the council, government all the different sporting and community groups the opposition to it by community groups plus you have a state government budget shortage money wise, but we still have Goshs paddock and Casey until it's sorted out.

 

[Dr. Gonzo 23,665]

1 hour ago, drdrake said:

Very easy, you need to show a community benefit, you can't just go in with we want money for AFL training base.  Look back at most my posts on this, there needs to be some community benefit.

Geelong will add in indoor netball courts or something.  Kardina Park has a netball outdoor facility, plus the home of AFL barwon umpires.  They will add in upgrade to the umpire facility add inside cricket nets, netball courts.  They are add ons to get the money.

Team up with Reach, Jim Stynes Centre for disadvantaged youth or something like that. It's a no-brainer, not sure why we aren't pursuing it! His legacy on both organisations recognised in one development.

[chookrat 4,200]

1 hour ago, whatwhat say what said:

function and events facilities is seemingly a big part of this pitch too

Function and event facilities are really commercial spaces and offer no real community benefit. I'm staggered thay Geelong are pushing for this given the amount of State Government funding they have received in the past 20 years. Hopefully it gets knocked back and the GFC and Local Government are asked to contribute the majority of funding.

[beelzebub 23,168]

2 hours ago, biggestred said:

corruption

Same thing ;) 

[beelzebub 23,168]

1 hour ago, demon3165 said:

Some of you have no idea how complex the dealings are with all this regarding the council, government all the different sporting and community groups the opposition to it by community groups plus you have a state government budget shortage money wise, but we still have Goshs paddock and Casey until it's sorted out.

 

Quite possibly....  and Roffey spruiked herself as the Queen of Stadia..    that's her gig.  She would know all of this.... 

And here we are.

So D3165..    i call bs

[demon3165 2,560]

2 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Quite possibly....  and Roffey spruiked herself as the Queen of Stadia..    that's her gig.  She would know all of this.... 

And here we are.

So D3165..    i call bs

If you know anything about the Glen Eria council there has been problems from the moment they announced it, so tell me what are the problems then?

[drdrake 3,114]

2 hours ago, demon3165 said:

Some of you have no idea how complex the dealings are with all this regarding the council, government all the different sporting and community groups the opposition to it by community groups plus you have a state government budget shortage money wise, but we still have Goshs paddock and Casey until it's sorted out.

 

Yep, Vic government is basically broke, the big build is coming with a big debt.  This means the positioning for any state money needs to show big community impact and votes.  Geelong will be targeting federal money commitments from both parties for 2025 election promises.

 

Our concern doesn't seem to be funding as yet, we still don't have a firm location as yet.  Caulfield racecourse is the latest but really this is still a maybe.

I wonder how much money the club has burnt doing the feasibility studies on various options

Edited August 16 by drdrake

[beelzebub 23,168]

2 hours ago, demon3165 said:

If you know anything about the Glen Eria council there has been problems from the moment they announced it, so tell me what are the problems then?

If that paragraph actually made coherent sense I'd be happy to.

The beef, for want of a better word, is Roffey campaigned on her abilities and experience. Irrelevant of whatever obstacles , met and still hindering, we have been told next to zip about progress and whatever is hurting the project/proposal.

The membership is entitled to clear and timely updates even if they are  constrained. It's not good enough to provide little to nothing.That's performing poorly

All councils , governments, interested parties, stakeholders can be buggers to deal with. This is hardly an unknown nor peculiarly specific to Glen Eira.

Edited August 16 by beelzebub

[Diamond_Jim 12,330]

Life was not meant  to be easy

A rebel board member has called for a spill of the Melbourne Racing Club committee following scathing criticism of Caulfield Racecourse’s new $160 million mounting yard facilities as well as the club’s $250 million plans to replace the Rupert Clark Grandstand.

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/racing/rebels-call-for-spill-of-melbourne-racing-club-board-saying-caulfield-revamp-in-disarray-20240822-p5k4mk.html

Toss up as to how this might affect/delay our plan

[chookrat 4,200]

7 hours ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Life was not meant  to be easy

A rebel board member has called for a spill of the Melbourne Racing Club committee following scathing criticism of Caulfield Racecourse’s new $160 million mounting yard facilities as well as the club’s $250 million plans to replace the Rupert Clark Grandstand.

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/racing/rebels-call-for-spill-of-melbourne-racing-club-board-saying-caulfield-revamp-in-disarray-20240822-p5k4mk.html

Toss up as to how this might affect/delay our plan

Boards should listen to people who know what they are talking about and not members. Imagine if the MFC board listened to the nuffies on Demonland.

[The Jackson FIX 2,661]

5 minutes ago, chookrat said:

Boards should listen to people who know what they are talking about and not members. Imagine if the MFC board listened to the nuffies on Demonland.

We’d have 36 tall forwards on the list, we’d have KPIs centred around ‘kicking the bloody thing’ but there would be ongoing indecision about whether the coach is the right person for the job.

[pitmaster 3,426]

8 hours ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Life was not meant  to be easy

A rebel board member has called for a spill of the Melbourne Racing Club committee following scathing criticism of Caulfield Racecourse’s new $160 million mounting yard facilities as well as the club’s $250 million plans to replace the Rupert Clark Grandstand.

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/racing/rebels-call-for-spill-of-melbourne-racing-club-board-saying-caulfield-revamp-in-disarray-20240822-p5k4mk.html

Toss up as to how this might affect/delay our plan

A change of committee could only be bad news for us bringing more delay and uncertainty.

[deanox 9,620]

8 hours ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Life was not meant  to be easy

A rebel board member has called for a spill of the Melbourne Racing Club committee following scathing criticism of Caulfield Racecourse’s new $160 million mounting yard facilities as well as the club’s $250 million plans to replace the Rupert Clark Grandstand.

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/racing/rebels-call-for-spill-of-melbourne-racing-club-board-saying-caulfield-revamp-in-disarray-20240822-p5k4mk.html

Toss up as to how this might affect/delay our plan

I can't help but read this as "a board member who was in the minority/lost the vote, has called for a spill of the entire board so that it can (hopefully) be replaced by a new board that agrees with them".

[Grr-owl 1,168]

On 11/04/2024 at 14:36, ElDiablo14 said:

Just let the Caulfield project go through, I may be moving there next year 🤞🏻

I am moving in permanently tomorrow. Well, to Glen Huntly, next door to Caulfield the Lesser (South) and nearby Caulfield itself. A 15 min stroll passed the brand new station and that excellent Asian restaurant that looks like a takeaway but is always booked out and has Chinese food that people come for miles around to eat....

[Demon Dynasty 17,080]

6 hours ago, Grr-owl said:

I am moving in permanently tomorrow. Well, to Glen Huntly, next door to Caulfield the Lesser (South) and nearby Caulfield itself. A 15 min stroll passed the brand new station and that excellent Asian restaurant that looks like a takeaway but is always booked out and has Chinese food that people come for miles around to eat....

To be fair this could be just about anywhere in Noodleville's eastern suburbs right now.

[KozzyCan 289]

How has there been no update yet? According to the pdf the council put up the report was supposed to be produced in June.

[FreedFromDesire 563]

On 23/08/2024 at 14:43, KozzyCan said:

How has there been no update yet? According to the pdf the council put up the report was supposed to be produced in June.

I believe there may have been some kind of progress in the last few days. Apparently there was a board meeting last night, not sure if that was just a regular one or a special one given everything going on, but there's talk that Caulfield was raised and an investment budget spoken about. I'm not completely sure what that means - If we needed to provide an amount to council or if council had requested something from us - but if true it sounds like at least something is happening.

I'll be interested to see who provides an update from the club, if they do update us soon, as this has apparently not had the level of involvement from Roffey as many of us would have thought.

[whatwhat say what 22,031]

On 23/08/2024 at 08:20, Grr-owl said:

I am moving in permanently tomorrow. Well, to Glen Huntly, next door to Caulfield the Lesser (South) and nearby Caulfield itself. A 15 min stroll passed the brand new station and that excellent Asian restaurant that looks like a takeaway but is always booked out and has Chinese food that people come for miles around to eat....

name of restaurant pls

[BLWNBA 680]

Sounds like there might be some movement on this soon. MFC to contribute a further $20m - $25m towards the development of a training facility at Caulfield. 

[KozzyCan 289]

2 minutes ago, BLWNBA said:

Sounds like there might be some movement on this soon. MFC to contribute a further $20m - $25m towards the development of a training facility at Caulfield. 

Where are you hearing this?

[No. 31 1,009]

5 minutes ago, BLWNBA said:

Sounds like there might be some movement on this soon. MFC to contribute a further $20m - $25m towards the development of a training facility at Caulfield. 

To be called OnTrac5 Oval ... solving two problems with one hit 😁

[ElDiablo14 4,873]

4 minutes ago, No. 31 said:

To be called OnTrac5 Oval ... solving two problems with one hit 😁

And a bronze statue scale 5:1

 

[picket fence 16,624]

For the circus that is becoming the MFC what about Luna Park!