Changes v GWS Giants

[Big Col 1,347]

8 minutes ago, Petraccattack said:

Talk of resting players is crazy.....  a win here will mean a final vs Geelong at the MCG, a loss will possibly mean playing GWS again up in Sydney with the confidence they will take out of just having rolled us 12 or so days earlier and with Toby Greene and others coming back.

We must hit this game at full steam.  The season aint over yet!

Exactly!  I really really want to watch the dees play in a final at the G. (though id consider a flight to Sydney it aint the same)

[Garbo 1,547]

We look so slow once the ball is on the outside, the number of times swans last week and eagles this week just ran it up the wing with out us getting a hand on it is infuriating. Don’t know who we have to fit that bill but we need pace in the middle badly 

[WERRIDEE 5,534]

no change

[Redleg 41,627]

4 hours ago, Wrecker45 said:

Out: Gawn and Oliver rested

Show the league we are one of the big boys

We need to beat GWS so we can play the Cats at the G, or would you prefer to play GWS again at their home ground in an elimination final?

[rjay 25,158]

1 hour ago, the rolling fog said:

Viney is further away than we think I reckon

We'd be [censored] crazy to drop Tyson right now

 

51 minutes ago, GCDee said:

It's not that I'm a Tyson basher... 

Its just to make way for a fit viney its Tyson that would go.

Viney if fit will come in for Spargo...

[rjay 25,158]

5 minutes ago, Redleg said:

We need to beat GWS so we can play the Cats at the G, or would you prefer to play GWS again at their home ground in an elimination final?

With that massive home crowd they will draw...only joking 'Red'..

It would be justice to knock the Cats out of the finals.

[MudDogs Gawn Win.. someday 499]

No Change for mine.

Lets lock in a home final!!

(I’ve booked a hotel in Sydney as a fail safe.)

[MudDogs Gawn Win.. someday 499]

9 minutes ago, rjay said:

 

Viney if fit will come in for Spargo...

Tyson is playing to his 2014 form. Absolute top shelf.

[Redleg 41,627]

1 minute ago, MudDogs Gawn Win.. someday said:

Tyson is playing to his 2014 form. Absolute top shelf.

Not sure if that is completely correct, but he is playing well and getting a lot of contested ball. He has well and truly earned his spot.

[nosoupforme 3,085]

Maybe one change and give Spargo a  rest needs it to freshen up. Bring in Garlett  he might be the X factor.

I have a feeling Viney will play his first final. Nothing to lose and all to gain. He will take that chance if  foot feels ok.

[bing181 9,332]

Not for GWS, but I'd be getting Joel Smith back in ASAP so we can move Fritsch back up the field (wing/forward) where he can do more damage. He's handy as a sweeper/loose man across the back line, but isn't strong/experienced enough to be playing as a one-on-one defender - Exhibit A being that mark that LeCras took on him.

With finals looming though, none of Hannan, Kent or VDB would want to put in a dud game next week.

[bing181 9,332]

16 minutes ago, nosoupforme said:

Maybe one change and give Spargo a  rest

Sure, but who do you bring in? Apart from JKH who's not much of an upgrade on Spargo in any case, cupboard is pretty bare at Casey.

[Rogue 585]

I rate Garlett over Spargo, but I can't see how we'll now choose Jeff after we dropped him for round 22. By all reports Garlett put in a stinker at Casey, while Spargo was better than in the Sydney game.

Hibberd is a worry. Who's left? I don't rate Wagner very highly, but he's the next man in and I reckon we need Hibberd for finals, so if he needs the two weeks off we've got to give it to him.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

I'd like to see Bugg given one run before finals. I dunno if Viney will play again this year, and noone else jumps out from Casey.

The big ifs are guys like Weed and Spargo. Spargo since he didn't do a whole lot, and Weed as he might not be the matchup Goody wants.

Man. The week off before finals, the media, the fact our season extends by a fortnight at least. What an incredible time to be a demons supporter.

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,511]

Is Viney running on solid ground yet?

Last I heard he was only on a treadmill, but that was a couple of weeks back... anyone know is he’s progressed?

[samcantstandya 1,061]

5 hours ago, nosoupforme said:

Maybe one change and give Spargo a  rest needs it to freshen up. Bring in Garlett  he might be the X factor.

I have a feeling Viney will play his first final. Nothing to lose and all to gain. He will take that chance if  foot feels ok.

Forget Garlett he wouldn't have kicked that Kent goal when the pressure was on he just wants the goal out the back & no contact - rather have Bugg as a pest at least he gives 100%.

[monoccular 17,594]

10 hours ago, Chook said:

Absolutely no chance of a suspension for Oscar.
AVB is a chance for a week for his errant elbow to the head o (I think?) Rioli. No chance of a penalty for the tunnelling/spoiling incident. Barely even a free kick that one.

Never ever forget that Christian was a Collingwood player, and that he has been all over the place re his inconsistency this year, and that we will be perhaps threatening the AFL’s pet project’s top 4 position, so

a week for each of them

Totallly unjust, but that is the AFL. 

[Demons11 7,061]

12 hours ago, Wrecker45 said:

Out: Gawn and Oliver rested

Show the league we are one of the big boys

There is a break before finals, don’t rest anyone.  We need to finish as high up as possible to play a home final.

[loges 6,767]

38 minutes ago, monoccular said:

Never ever forget that Christian was a Collingwood player, and that he has been all over the place re his inconsistency this year, and that we will be perhaps threatening the AFL’s pet project’s top 4 position, so

a week for each of them

Totallly unjust, but that is the AFL. 

The club would appeal if Oscar was to get suspended.

[SPC 3,554]

I think Vanders gets 1 week and Hibberd gets a 2 week rest. Wagner in for Hibbo, no idea who comes in for Vanders, not Garlett by the sounds of the VFL report. 

[nosoupforme 3,085]

1 hour ago, monoccular said:

Never ever forget that Christian was a Collingwood player, and that he has been all over the place re his inconsistency this year, and that we will be perhaps threatening the AFL’s pet project’s top 4 position, so

a week for each of them

Totallly unjust, but that is the AFL. 

I don't think any of the 2 will be looked at l can't see any wrong doing as the game was a mini final hard fought and the Demons stood up when it counted. IMO they will be fine Mono and not intentional. Keep fingers crossed.

[Demon17 5,207]

9 hours ago, Redleg said:

We need to beat GWS so we can play the Cats at the G, or would you prefer to play GWS again at their home ground in an elimination final?

Exactly. No if and buts, the GWS game winner gets 5th spot and home final.

Huge upside if Dees get up.

Keep going hard, maybe excepting Hibberd who is mandatory for first final. No other changes after yesterdays heroics.

Having seen Garlett against the swans he's done for the year if Goodwin is consistent. 

Spargo stays in for the experience and Tyson is a lock. He's been great on the inside - set up first goal yesterday.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

9 hours ago, Garbo said:

We look so slow once the ball is on the outside, the number of times swans last week and eagles this week just ran it up the wing with out us getting a hand on it is infuriating. Don’t know who we have to fit that bill but we need pace in the middle badly 

We do lack leg speed, but what you are referring to is often a result of having too many players running forward of the ball because we always look to play-on.

If we actually stop, prop and kick our way forward (instead of just playing on and handballing at every opportunity) we would be far less likely to give up these loose goals out the back.

[Tom Dyson 1,633]

spargo on thin ice, possibly replaced by garlett or bugg 

jack viney, please get your bloody foot right for september...

[Deeoldfart 8,067]

I very much doubt that Hibbo will be an out.  If he had any sign of a hammy niggle, there's no way they would have risked sending him back out yesterday.  Besides, I'm sure Goody said in his presser that it was cramp, caused by playing his first game for a month in a pretty warm temperature.