Demonland Podcast Returns 29/11 @ 8:00pm w/Special Guest Recruiting Manager Jason Taylor

[Demonland 72,081]

The Demonland Podcast Returns Wednesday Night 29/11 at 8:00pm with Special Guest Melbourne Recruiting Manager Jason Taylor. 

http://demonland.com/Podcast

[DeezNuts 624]

Well done DL, that's another great landing - keep it up!

[FarNorthernD 5,861]

Fantastic get. I'll be all ears. Thanks

[Demonland 72,081]

Any questions Demonlanders want to ask?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

It's a shame we couldn't get him on last week so that we could all call him and tell him who to draft.

[In Harmes Way 7,764]

Agree DL, another super guest!

I’d be keen to know how many years ahead of next years draft they are tracking juniors

and how they manage regions

[Dee Zephyr 19,267]

13 minutes ago, Demonland said:

Any questions Demonlanders want to ask?

There was talk about West Coast being into Fritch.

Were we always drafting him at 31 or was that to trump West Coast at 32? 

I noticed the Eagles asked for extended time with pick 32.

[george_on_the_outer 7,590]

12 minutes ago, Demonland said:

Any questions Demonlanders want to ask?

Do the current TAC cup arrangements and rules enhance the selection of youngsters, or is it too open and free to make judgements which reflect the needs of AFL?

Is it easier for a recruiter to have top draft picks, or do you prefer the analysis required for those picks further down?.

Why do rucks take so long to develop? And what do you look for if selecting one of them?

 

[In Harmes Way 7,764]

Oh - I forgot. Pump him up big time for taking Clarry. Positively. Inspired. 

[McQueen 17,864]

Question:

Is “good as gold” his favourite saying?

[Drunkn167 5,093]

1 hour ago, Demonland said:

Any questions Demonlanders want to ask?

Did the MFC take Fritsch at pick 31 so WCE couldn't get him at pick 32?

Edit: Oh Demon77 already asked this 

Edited November 28, 2017 by Drunkn167

[mattjm 151]

are we eager to trade back into the 2018 1st round?

[Demonland 72,081]

15 minutes ago, mattjm said:

are we eager to trade back into the 2018 1st round?

Good question. 

[Fear the beard 6]

• Is there any player Jason was particularly disappointed another club ‘stole’ ahead of a planned pick? 
• Is there a smokey Jason is most proud of?
• Which of the draftees does Jason think will be ready for an AFL game next year?
• Are there any potential future father-son picks Jason is keeping an eye on?
• Are there any prior year draftees Jason is bullish on making an impact in 2018?
• Why was adding a ruckman not a priority for the club in the offseason? Do we think King/Filipovic would be ready in the event of a Gawn injury?
• Should we expect Balic to be a regular in the AFL side?
• Is Jason tracking other category B rookie possibilities given the recent Maynard and Smith successes? 
• How far ahead of time did Jason determine Oliver was out target for pick 4?

Edited November 28, 2017 by Fear the beard

[puntkick 325]

7 hours ago, Demonland said:

Any questions Demonlanders want to ask?

Will being a redhead club again get a premiership before I die ?

[Demonland 72,081]

3 hours ago, Fear the beard said:

• Is there any player Jason was particularly disappointed another club ‘stole’ ahead of a planned pick? 
• Is there a smokey Jason is most proud of?
• Which of the draftees does Jason think will be ready for an AFL game next year?
• Are there any potential future father-son picks Jason is keeping an eye on?
• Are there any prior year draftees Jason is bullish on making an impact in 2018?
• Why was adding a ruckman not a priority for the club in the offseason? Do we think King/Filipovic would be ready in the event of a Gawn injury?
• Should we expect Balic to be a regular in the AFL side?
• Is Jason tracking other category B rookie possibilities given the recent Maynard and Smith successes? 
• How far ahead of time did Jason determine Oliver was out target for pick 4?

May ask a couple of these. Time permitting. 

[Demonland 72,081]

2 hours ago, puntkick said:

Will being a redhead club again get a premiership before I die ?

Would love to know the answer to this but we have limited time. 

[The Chazz 4,077]

I think given the constant "we should've taken "X" player instead of "y" player", I'd like to know who has the biggest say in the recruitment of the players we take.  Is it the coach that goes to the recruiters and says "we need this type of player, find us the best one", or do the recruiters come back with a priority list and say "here's the best 5 players in the land, who do you like best?".

With all the hindsight recruiting that a lot of us do on here, I'd be interested to know the above.

And if you do ask it, please don't let him get away with the "best available" line.  There has to be more to it than that.  There has to be!

[Guest]

On a different note, would it be possible to do a ‘No T$ No B$’ version of the podcast? Where we can just fire random questions towards the hosts (within the bounds of good taste and common sense of course)?

[Glenn Molloy 494]

9 hours ago, Fear the beard said:

• Is there any player Jason was particularly disappointed another club ‘stole’ ahead of a planned pick? 
• Is there a smokey Jason is most proud of?
• Which of the draftees does Jason think will be ready for an AFL game next year?
• Are there any potential future father-son picks Jason is keeping an eye on?
• Are there any prior year draftees Jason is bullish on making an impact in 2018?
• Why was adding a ruckman not a priority for the club in the offseason? Do we think King/Filipovic would be ready in the event of a Gawn injury?
• Should we expect Balic to be a regular in the AFL side?
• Is Jason tracking other category B rookie possibilities given the recent Maynard and Smith successes? 
• How far ahead of time did Jason determine Oliver was out target for pick 4?

This is a key question for me.  I know we have Pedo to help out but we don't have Watts to help as a 2nd ruck anymore......I assume we'd use TMac but am a little surprised we didn't get an experienced ruck to replace Spencer and back up Gawn.  

[Melb-A-Toast 257]

question to ask: "With Simon Goodwin taking the helm, even though they had similar philosophies, did you tweak the focus on the types of players to recruit this year or even last year?"

"Some teams are looking at Richmond and Bulldogs' less reliance on pure rucks. As Max Gawn has a big advantage for tap work, does the recruitment look to develop another Max Gawn, or more of the Hybrid as the future primary ruck role? (Hoping of course that Max is fit and well for many years at Melbourne)"

[DeeSpencer 25,658]

19 minutes ago, Glenn Molloy said:

This is a key question for me.  I know we have Pedo to help out but we don't have Watts to help as a 2nd ruck anymore......I assume we'd use TMac but am a little surprised we didn't get an experienced ruck to replace Spencer and back up Gawn.  

Surprised so many are bothered by this. I doubt there was a player available better than what Pedersen and McDonald did and there's always Weideman who can be used alongside one of those 2 if needed. 

Having a back up would take away from Mitch King's development time at Casey and he started coming on in the VFL last year. If he gets a solid preseason now he'll relish the playing time at VFL level. It would also all but rule Filipovic out as a viable AFL player because without the VFL reserves there's no where for him to play besides riding the pine at Casey and maybe getting a few minutes game time forward or in the ruck.

I like that we've backed a couple of young guys in and it might not take that long for them to become worthy back ups and if/when that happens we'll have a much stronger list than if we stunted their growth with a dud. 

[Grimes Times 1,278]

Any Melbourne interest in the Irish again??

I hear Melbourne  had interest in  Will Powell who GC took at 19. Was he earmarked for one of our picks???

[Grimes Times 1,278]

Just now, DeeSpencer said:

Surprised so many are bothered by this. I doubt there was a player available better than what Pedersen and McDonald did and there's always Weideman who can be used alongside one of those 2 if needed. 

Having a back up would take away from Mitch King's development time at Casey and he started coming on in the VFL last year. If he gets a solid preseason now he'll relish the playing time at VFL level. It would also all but rule Filipovic out as a viable AFL player because without the VFL reserves there's no where for him to play besides riding the pine at Casey and maybe getting a few minutes game time forward or in the ruck.

I like that we've backed a couple of young guys in and it might not take that long for them to become worthy back ups and if/when that happens we'll have a much stronger list than if we stunted their growth with a dud. 

I'm the same. how many other clubs have 3 21yo and under developing ruckman on there list.

[DeeSpencer 25,658]

Yeah I want to know about Cat B rookies. 3 spots open. Surely we fill at least 1 of them.

Then a bit of talk about the 4 new recruits of course.

And if you could ask if the club have used analytics in recruiting.