2 hours ago, Wadda We Sing said:

BT just said on Talking Footy that Oliver was definitely staging for the free...... FMD....the rest of the panel didnt even pick him up on it. Unbelievable ..

Good god, man, why do it to yourself? 

26 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Irrelevance , in a ' jumped the shark' kinda way.

Exactly the word that crossed my mind too.  Seems to have moved in to the "utter nonsense for a headline" territory.  Shame.  Oh well.

41 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Can someone please make  GIF of when Oliver out his head over to get the ball and Shuey was correctly called for kicking in danger?

It's about 2:58 of the below video:

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/video/2017-06-26/rd-15-all-the-goals

1 minute ago, Chook said:

Shuey was too much of a squib to bend over and pick it up cos he knew he'd get crunched.

And you can guarantee no coach in the game is telling their players to kick it off the ground  (unless in monsoon conditions)

3 minutes ago, Chook said:

Legend.

Looks like Eagles may appeal the 1 week for Schofield. http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-06-26/eagles-consider-challenging-schofield-ban

That is their right but I don't like these comments from Simpson.

"I just hope Clayton's OK. I hope he made the flight back," a tongue-in-cheek Simpson told 6PR".

"We can't dispute the medical report. Also, I'm one of the people who can't comment on it either, so we'll let it run its course and we'll get on with it.  Is he doubting the mfc doctor's report?

He also said: "All the commentary around it, you sort of accept it from media outlets, but when players get involved it's probably another issue that we've got to look into".  Have any current players commented on Oliver reaction?  Or is Simpson grandstanding a bit.

I think it is one thing for commentators to say Oliver embellished the impact but it is another thing to not accept his post game explanation, effectively saying he lied. 

This is becoming quite unpleasant.  More so when the coach takes up the narrative instead.

Edited June 26, 20178 yr by Lucifer's Hero

Goddard on Footy Classified is like having the Grim Reaper on the panel. Has all the charisma of a staph infection.

Haha simpson is a [censored] jockey

 

9 minutes ago, SaberFang said:

Goddard on Footy Classified is like having the Grim Reaper on the panel. Has all the charisma of a staph infection.

He's simply so unlikeable. I try to find the good in most people but......

12 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Looks like Eagles may appeal the 1 week for Schofield. http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-06-26/eagles-consider-challenging-schofield-ban

That is their right but I don't like these comments from Simpson.

"I just hope Clayton's OK. I hope he made the flight back," a tongue-in-cheek Simpson told 6PR".

"We can't dispute the medical report. Also, I'm one of the people who can't comment on it either, so we'll let it run its course and we'll get on with it.  Is he doubting the mfc doctor's report?

He also said: "All the commentary around it, you sort of accept it from media outlets, but when players get involved it's probably another issue that we've got to look into".  Have any current players commented on Oliver reaction?  Or is Simpson grandstanding a bit.

I think it is one thing for commentators to say Oliver embellished the impact but it is another thing to not accept his post game explanation, effectively saying he lied. 

This is becoming quite unpleasant.  More so when the coach takes up the narrative instead.

Bad form by Simpson.

People are forgetting that Schofield elbowed a player at half time to the head. 

Oliver didn't take a dive going for a mark, he was elbowed in the head.

5 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

That is their right but I don't like these comments from Simpson.

"I just hope Clayton's OK. I hope he made the flight back," a tongue-in-cheek Simpson told 6PR".

He also said: "All the commentary around it, you sort of accept it from media outlets, but when players get involved it's probably another issue that we've got to look into".  Have any current players commented on Oliver reaction?  Or is Simpson grandstanding a bit.

Hey, Simmo: how are all those poor little downhill-skiing petals in your team holding up today? After such an embarrassing choke against us, with those pathetic defensive efforts in the dying seconds as 4 of your defenders nonchalantly jogged towards Tom McDonald before kicking the winning goal, are they holding up okay? Any neck injuries from all that excessive ducking, diving and milking for free kicks every week?

How's Darling, by the way? Still cleaning his dacks after [censored] himself in your embarrassing excuse for a Grand Final coaching performance a few years back?

Keep up the great work though! You're doing a fantastic job treading water in the middle of the ladder with zero impact in finals.

20 hours ago, CityDee said:

He went down feeling for his teeth . That elbow flicked him on the way through he had his arms down wasn't clenching his jaw anticipating a contact situation . 

He obviously went back at the weagle [censored] with anger and it  looked real to me .

Garry Lyon should apologise for the criticism and more so after the mrp outcome . 

I was talking to a current players partner this evening who told me that her boyfriend was standing very close to Clarry when that bully descended on him and caught him totally unawares. He definitely did not see the contact coming and his first thought was that he had his top row of teeth broken.

Edited June 27, 20178 yr by jane02
grammar

3 minutes ago, SaberFang said:

Hey, Simmo: how are all those poor little downhill-skiing petals in your team holding up today? After such an embarrassing choke against us, with those pathetic defensive efforts in the dying seconds as 4 of your defenders nonchalantly jogged towards Tom McDonald before kicking the winning goal, are they holding up okay? Any neck injuries from all that excessive ducking, diving and milking for free kicks every week?

How's Darling, by the way? Still cleaning his dacks after [censored] himself in your embarrassing excuse for a Grand Final coaching performance a few years back?

Keep up the great work though! You're doing a fantastic job treading water in the middle of the ladder with zero impact in finals.

Those defenders cricked their necks watching the ball sail over their heads.

Just now, america de cali said:

Those defenders cricked their necks watching the ball sail over their heads.

Surprised the umpires didn't pay a free for high contact!

6 hours ago, John Lord said:

Demon 77 just ask your Essesendon lot to recall the 2000 GF and look at how their players go about business. Do not back down. I would have let fly as well. Demon supporters and the club will no longer be bullied. Attacking you at work for supporting a team is bullying and unacceptable. You now feel how Clarrry is feeling. The victim is apparently at fault. Go Dees

I would have dropped to the floor, clutching my chest shouting Defibrillator, Please, get the Defibulator for this idiot Essendon Man, he's spreading FIbs...

32 minutes ago, SaberFang said:

Goddard on Footy Classified is like having the Grim Reaper on the panel. Has all the charisma of a staph infection.

 

21 minutes ago, jane02 said:

He's simply so unlikeable. I try to find the good in most people but......

He couldn't have moved to a nicer club :-)

Hey, Brendon, how are the pretzels and the gummy bears, you petulant prjck?

And, how is the kicking in going?  Years of experience and leadership to the poor young victims of ASADA.

Edited June 26, 20178 yr by monoccular

Been copping a bit of flack from some very salty eagles supporters over here due to the Oliver incident. They quickly shut up when I show them this clip. 

Edited June 26, 20178 yr by Ethan Tremblay

Saw Clarry at the supermarket tonight. He's actually a much smaller build than i expected.

11 minutes ago, low flying Robbo said:

Saw Clarry at the supermarket tonight. He's actually a much smaller build than i expected.

Was he in the fish section?

47 minutes ago, monoccular said:

He couldn't have moved to a nicer club :-)

The only silver lining to Essendon returning to finals will be Brendon Goddard being delisted the year before it happens.

Simmo weighing in on this is pretty pathetic. I suppose it's a convenient deflection from his teams abysmal record in Victoria and a nice excuse if the Dogs beat them 

2 hours ago, Chook said:

Oliver clearly staged the kicking in danger even though he failed to get a basic free. 

Look in his left hand and you will see a calculator which he used to calculate when to pull the string in his right hand, which was attached to Shuey's boot, to draw it toward his hands as he reached for the footy. 

Where is the AFL outrage at this pre meditated attempt to draw a free?

Simpson's comment shows the difference in class between him and Goodwin.

When Hogan got rubbed out because of the Carlton Dr's report of a delayed concussion he didn't get involved.

The silver lining in all this is that I expect a fired up Clarry against the Swans.

35 touches coming up.

19 minutes ago, Is Dom Is Good said:

The silver lining in all this is that I expect a fired up Clarry against the Swans.

35 touches coming up.

So, just a normal game then.

The media [censored] storm over this is amazing lol 

selwood ducks to get free kicks every week which I consider a form of staging and no one says a word