10 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

That's like saying Joe Daniher would have been best on ground if he kicked straight in front of goals.

McDonald had a shocker, needs to keep it simple and know is role in the team.

Some posters are very forgiving of his kicking. His turnovers today were poor even by his standards, and better teams would've punished them.

6. Jones

5. Trac

4. Lewis

3. Oliver

2. Watts

1. Pederson

NB: special mention to Tyson and Viney who were both much improved on last week particularly after half time.

6. Watts

5. Oliver

4. Hibberd

3. Petracca

2. McDonald

1. Pederson

 

6. Watts

5. Oliver

4. Salem

3. T-Mac

2. Viney

1. Petracca

6. Pedo

5. Lewis

4. Watts

3. T. Mac

2. Oliver

1. Hunt

Tough one this week, for the good reasons.

6. Oliver 

5. Watts

4. Pederson

3. Lewis

2. Petracca

1. Viney

Apologies to Jones, Jetta, Hibberd & Hunt.

6- lewis

5- pedo

4- watts

3- petracca

2- jones

1- tmac

Loved that the match report on afl.com.au listed TMac as our best player and did not have Watts in the best!! Anyway

6. Watts - according to the Essendon supporters around us he was the main man.

5. Oliver

4. Pederson

3. Lewis

2.Petracca

1. Hunt

Special mention to Vince who proved in the second half that he still has it as a midfielder.

6 -  The Messiah  (aka C.Pedersen)

5  -  J.Watts

4 -   C.Oliver

3 -   T.McDonald

2  -  J.Lewis

1  -  C.Petracca

6 Watts

5 Pedersen

4 Oliver

3 Petracca

2 Jones

1 T-Mac

6. T Mac (Those of you who didn't have him in the votes "WAKE UP")

5. Clarry (Darcy who???)

4. Watts (Getting consistent)

3. Pederson (Welcome back)

2. Lewis (Welcome back)

1. Viney (Played the ball instead of the man)

What is good about this post is that there are so many players in contention.

6. Pederson

5. Watts

4. Oliver

3. Petracca

2. Lewis

1. Viney

6 Watts

5 Pederson

4 Oliver

3 Petracca

2 Lewis

1 T Mac (but oh the kicking)

6: Watts

5: Oliver

4: Pederson

3: Petracca

2: Frost

1: Lewis

Add Garlett, Viney, Jones, Tom Mac Hannan: a good effort.

6  Watts

5  Peder

4  Petracca

3  Oliver

2  Frost

1  TMac

 

Salem Lewis Viney  all great too.

 

 

6. Pedersen

5. Oliver

4. Watts

3. Hibberd

2. Lewis

1. Petracca

6.Watts 

5. Trac

4. Pedersen

3. Oliver

2. Lewis 

1. Tmac

6. Pederson

5. Watts

4. Lewis

3. Clarence Oliver

2. Trac

1. Jones

If only there was an extra six places - honourable mentions to T Mac, Jeffy, Jones, Tyson, Frost, Viney

Surely Daniher deserves a vote or two -- was clearly one of our best all game ...

6 T-Mac - Really strong in air, covered heaps of territory and his cameo in ruck was impressive.

5 Frost - Boy has he improved his kicking and his dash and tackling is huge.

4 Oliver - Shades of Dusty with his second quarter forward cameo and prominent all day. Still wish he'd take game on more.

3 Watts - Lost his way in second term, but his class won through and like everyone I spotted that early tackle that created Jeffy's goal.

2 Pederson - A slow burn but significant when he went back into ruck in third term.

1 Trac - Our Jake Stringer, hopefully without the low off-field acts.

2 hours ago, Deespicable said:

6 T-Mac - Really strong in air, covered heaps of territory and his cameo in ruck was impressive.

 

T-Mac, really couldn't hit the side of a barn yesterday.  Would have been BOG if he could kick, as Garry Lyon said today you have to know your limitations, T-mac should be a 45m kick and never kick into the corridor  

1. Pedestal

2.Claratyne

3. Gary Busey

4.Jack Watts

5.Chewtracca

6.Big Mac

then "Iron" DomTyson(better game), "Michael" Jordan Lewis(presence) etc..

6.  Watts

5.  Pedersen

4.  Oliver

3.  Lewis

2.  Petracca

1.  Frost

Can a teenager with the Demonland Player of the Year.

Progressive tally -

70. Clayton Oliver

54. Jack Watts

44. Nathan Jones

28. Jayden Hunt

23. Jeff Garlett

20. Michael Hibberd Christian Petracca

16. Christian Salem

11. Max Gawn Jordan Lewis Tom McDonald Dom Tyson

7. Alex Neal-Bullen

6. Cam Pedersen Bernie Vince          

5. Dean Kent Billy Stretch 

4. Sam Frost Jesse Hogan Neville Jetta 

3. Jack Viney

2. Jake Melksham