1 hour ago, Petraccattack said:

Hogan will get 2 weeks, maybe 3.  That was really silly stuff and the MRP will make an example of it.

Lewis has nothing to worry about, surely.

There is no chance in the world he will get 3 weeks, what incident were you watching.  2 down to 1 at worst 

Yep, 3 weeks would be ludicrous.

 

Are everyone watching a different video clip to me on the Lewis hit, I can't see him do anything cripps only goes down when viney bumps him from behind, if you can't see any hit how can you make a call on it, hogan on the other hand if they offer a week we'll just take it and move on 

6 minutes ago, brendan said:

Are everyone watching a different video clip to me on the Lewis hit, I can't see him do anything cripps only goes down when viney bumps him from behind, if you can't see any hit how can you make a call on it, hogan on the other hand if they offer a week we'll just take it and move on 

Is it that hit or the one Cripps afterwards while on the deck? I only saw it live yesterday but I thought Cripps copped another hit after Lewis got pushed onto him. 

2 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Is it that hit or the one Cripps afterwards while on the deck? I only saw it live yesterday but I thought Cripps copped another hit after Lewis got pushed onto him. 

I have no idea I'm just going by the video of n afl website that says is lewis in trouble for this hit, problem is I can't see him do anything, looks like he is being singled out because he has a bad record so he must have hit him  

9 minutes ago, brendan said:

Are everyone watching a different video clip to me on the Lewis hit, I can't see him do anything cripps only goes down when viney bumps him from behind, if you can't see any hit how can you make a call on it, hogan on the other hand if they offer a week we'll just take it and move on 

I'm with you. I think Lewis will get off - insufficient force. Hogan will probably get a week (intentional, high, low impact). He could get off also if the Carlton docs give a nice favourable medical report. It seems that injury to the player is the biggest determinant of the MRPs decision-making - and luckily for these two it looked like they did little damage

Both should go. Hogan for 1, Lewis for 2 due to his record.

Both boys very silly and I hope it does not cost us the game against Geelong. it certainly won't help having them both out

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-04-03/match-review-panel-full-statement-round-two

Hogan: 2 with an early plea. Quote: The incident was classified as a three-match sanction.

Lewis: 4 down to 3 (includes a one week carryover penalty).  Quote: The incident was classified as a three-match sanction. The player has an applicable bad record which impacts the penalty, increasing it by one match to a four-match sanction. An early plea enables the player to accept a three-match sanction.

Absolutely ridiculous.  This is a repeat of the Trengove on Dangerfield tackle.  Melbourne being made an example of. 

Club should appeal!!

Edited April 3, 20178 yr by Lucifer's Hero

3 weeks for Lewis, 2 weeks for Hogan.

Hogan 2 into 1

Lewis 3 into 2

ripped hard

Lewis has been given three weeks.

Hogan has been given two weeks.

Well done boys.

Just now, Lucifer's Hero said:

Hogan: 2 down to 1

Lewis: 3 down to 2 and no discount because of bad record.

Absolutely ridiculous.

Club should appeal!!

Hogan is 3 down to 2..  lol what a joke

Just now, Lucifer's Hero said:

Hogan: 2 down to 1

Lewis: 3 down to 2 and no discount because of bad record.

Absolutely ridiculous.

Club should appeal!!

Yea club should appeal Lewis, i thought lewis went for shoulder and it hit and skipped up into face. so a 3 week suspension for hitting someones shoulder (would be my appeal).

Jesse two weeks down to one and Lewis three weeks with no discount due to his record.

Just announced.

Was always going to happen, too many one-eyed supporters on 'land.

Just on SEN - Hogan 2 match ban (can accept down to 1 I think) and Lewis 3 match ban, no reduction due to record... WTF.

No consistency 

How the fark did Scott Thompson only got 1 week yet Hogan got 2!?

Useless [censored]

The MRP have decided to ream us a new one. Pathetic.

ouch, that hurts - way more than rowe and cripps got hurt!

Just dumb.

If it was our boys on the receiving end we would be beying for blood. 

Could be costly

No chance we appeal, no clubs do anymore.. The AFL has made it so you have to accept their rubbish. Facial you can't plead your case without the risk of further weeks

Scott Thompson deliberately elbowed Dangermouse in the head = 1 week.

Well done Jordan Lewis.

Great that you can bring all that leadership from Row S in the stands for 3 weeks.

1 minute ago, Demonland said:

Just ridiculous