Hoskin-Elliot was impressive. Should improve with more football. He has some great skills. Few kicks turned over, but is a real player - no doubt. Funny to see some pot him on here, clearly they didn't watch the game tonight, or know much about football.

 

Shocking game of football, I thought Collingwood were very stiff with the umpiring in the last quarter.

6 minutes ago, KingDingAling said:

Hoskin-Elliot was impressive. Should improve with more football. He has some great skills. Few kicks turned over, but is a real player - no doubt. Funny to see some pot him on here, clearly they didn't watch the game tonight, or know much about football.

 

he has his moments, but he's pretty outside

What the pies need is a good solid stopper in the backline.  Someone like Lynden Dunn for instance...

It's funny, I tipped Richmond but them winning went almost exactly as I expected. Collingwood shooting themselves in the foot, Richmond having good enough flashes to get he job done. I doubt either teams fans would look at this  and feel confident for the year. 

Happy I got the tip though!

2 minutes ago, RalphiusMaximus said:

What the pies need is a good solid stopper in the backline.  Someone like Lynden Dunn for instance...

Throw him forward and drop Jesse White 

 

Can't see collingwood winning many games, l have been saying for ages they are overated they can't beat Sydney next week,  they will be 0 and 5 and bucks will be gone. 

I thought the game was very entertaining - in a perverse sort of way.

28 minutes ago, radar said:

Then a despondent FIGJAM

I have more time for Buckles than his Pres. 

I doubt it will happen, but the Pres should fall before Buckles.

Buckles is a decent person.

5 minutes ago, Pates said:

It's funny, I tipped Richmond but them winning went almost exactly as I expected. Collingwood shooting themselves in the foot, Richmond having good enough flashes to get he job done. I doubt either teams fans would look at this  and feel confident for the year. 

Happy I got the tip though!

No pies are awful tigers have more score's the pies are  the worse kicking side in the competition.

5 minutes ago, The Great Pretender said:

I thought the game was very entertaining - in a perverse sort of way.

Your username is spot on about these two sides 

Need Bucks to win some games before the break, dont want him to be fired.  With him as coach and Eddie as president they will stay mediocre forever.    Shows how great Malthouse was for them,  easy to forget as he was so bad as Carlton coach.

1 hour ago, Ted Fidge said:

I do enjoy a well framed TV shot of Eddie doing his nut.

 

I just love this Thursday night FTA TV. Richmond on 2 weeks in a row at the G.

The AFL creating a new way for them to finish 9th !

21 minutes ago, puntkick said:

I just love this Thursday night FTA TV. Richmond on 2 weeks in a row at the G.

The AFL creating a new way for them to finish 9th !

Unless they get pipped by St Kilda or the Hawks.

58 minutes ago, puntkick said:

I just love this Thursday night FTA TV. Richmond on 2 weeks in a row at the G.

The AFL creating a new way for them to finish 9th !

Incidentally I'm pretty sure I heard the commentators say something about the pies being 0-8 playing on Thursday nights. Keep giving that time slot! 

I forgot how footy is played watching that [censored].

59 minutes ago, Deestroy All said:

I forgot how footy is played watching that [censored].

I didn't even see the game and that's still funny. Assume there's no need to chase up a replay?

1 minute ago, Kumamoto_Ken said:

I didn't even see the game and that's still funny. Assume there's no need to chase up a replay?

Unless you want to laugh at the absolute butchery in the first 3 quarters, give it a miss. 

There were a few goals in the last 15 when it opened up a bit. But compared to almost every game in round 1 it was truly horrible. I wish we played either of them tonight. Me and you that is KK, we would've beat them. 

What a pathetic crowd for two teams that have so many members.

If Melbourne had as many members and supporters as these two teams we'd get 80,000 people per game.

9 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

What a pathetic crowd for two teams that have so many members.

If Melbourne had as many members and supporters as these two teams we'd get 80,000 people per game.

Gee I think you are being a little tough on them Clint.

58 000 on a Thursday night ain't that bad. It was Thursday night, people have to work the next day and kids go to school etc.

As well Thursday nights are about the Broadcast rights not attendance. 

58k on a thursday night btw two sides with a combined 170k members or whatever it is is pathetic.

8 hours ago, daisycutter said:

he has his moments, but he's pretty outside

They have plenty of inside, he should complement them well, and he did a couple of nice things last night but he does need to develop a little something extra.

Its funny as Buck finally looks comfortable being a coach and delegating to his deputies and yet he could be gone pretty quickly if the players performance really drops off a cliff.

8 hours ago, Pates said:

It's funny, I tipped Richmond but them winning went almost exactly as I expected. Collingwood shooting themselves in the foot, Richmond having good enough flashes to get he job done. I doubt either teams fans would look at this  and feel confident for the year. 

Happy I got the tip though!

You are very wrong my friend. One would reasonably  think neither team would be up and about but oh my oh my  the tiger mates i know are excited/delusional.

Its good though, it makes their eventual downfall much much sweeter. Bring on anzac eve

59 minutes ago, old dee said:

Gee I think you are being a little tough on them Clint.

58 000 on a Thursday night ain't that bad. It was Thursday night, people have to work the next day and kids go to school etc.

As well Thursday nights are about the Broadcast rights not attendance. 

No, it's pathetic.