The only positive out of watching this rubbish match is its made me very confident we should belt both these teams again this year. 

Caddy is a funny player he's not really good enough to be a full time mid or forward. 

If Richmond beat Carlton last week ,and this is all they've got,we'll do carlton by 100+

Rance is one of those players who, in the media's eyes, gets better during the off season. Finished last year as a very good defender, then next minute he is being compared to SoS as one of the best backmen of all time. Give. Me. A. Spell.

7 minutes ago, Abe said:

Caddy is a funny player he's not really good enough to be a full time mid or forward. 

You are right, he is a nothing player. Depth for an inside mid role in a decent team.

1 minute ago, Forest Demon said:

You are right, he is a nothing player. Depth for an inside mid role in a decent team.

Exactly why the Cats let him go without fuss

Edited March 30, 20179 yr by Sir Why You Little

2 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Exactly why the Cats let him go without fuss

Ditto Gold Coast

13 minutes ago, Abe said:

Caddy is a funny player he's not really good enough to be a full time mid or forward. 

He's a depth player. Decidedly average. 

Can't believe Richmond have gotten this close. Pies should be a mile ahead at half time with how much more ball they had. 

Prestia has vindicated our recruiting team tonight. Has been fairly average and burnt his teammates on two occasions with two misses.

Pies should be 5-6 goals up really. Shows the sort of difference foot skills make 

This is pretty hilarious now

32 minutes ago, america de cali said:

Dustin Martin is starting to love his 'don't argues' too much. Been pinged twice in the second quarter for over embellishing. 

I blame some of his teammates too for giving it to him under pressure instead of kicking long inside fifty, i guess his 'presence' is having a negative effect now.

Hahaha. Richmond have been awful tonight and are leading

this has been a truly rubbish game of football - but it's entertaining, cos they're both rubbish. 

1 hour ago, hardtack said:

I genuinely cannot recall a game where I have seen such poor foot skills from both teams! This is diabolical.

Any number of MFC games over the past 16 years. 

 

1 hour ago, hardtack said:

I genuinely cannot recall a game where I have seen such poor foot skills from both teams! This is diabolical.

 

Just now, hemingway said:

Any number of MFC games over the past 16 years. 

 

 

Melbourne of 2013 would be beating either of these teams.

Buckley is well and truely on the chopping block. I really feel for Nat.... Hahahaha

Wouldn't mind seeing a stat comparison between Moore and Watts for their first 3 years. Wouldn't be a whole lot different I suspect yet everyone thinks Moore will be a superstar.

sideways, sideways, backwards, forwards, turnover

pies have no confidence

15 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Hahaha. Richmond have been awful tonight and are leading

Both Richmond and Collingwood have been poor tonight. Skills below average.

2 bottom of ladder sides 

Collingwood's poor disposal isn't a one off. This is the team Buckley has put together, and this has been their issue for the last 2 or 3 years. He is in big strife.

8 minutes ago, hemingway said:

Any number of MFC games over the past 16 years.

Dees were bad, but I'm talking about both teams in this game...not just one of them. 

Will Hoskin Elliott and James Aish

Collingwood trading for disappointing high picks thinking they will be stars just cos they went high in the draft lol

I'm convinced Buckley can't coach

this 'nominate the ruckman' thing is a farce