Jarryd Lyons

[Machsy 2,858]

Should we have another crack at this kid again come years end?

Crow fans think he hss been unfairly treated. Been made the sub a fair few times this year.

Inside ball winner who has been impressive when I have watched him this year?

Wouldn't have thought so.

How good can he really be?

We already have Riley, Michie, Evans, McKenzie, M. Jones as middling midfielders.

We need topline mids. And you don't recruit players to be flankers.

[hulkhogan666 142]

I am fairly keen to get Lyons to the club. I think he'd prove to be a better pick up than Vince

How many games has Lyons played this year? Vince has proved much more than just a pick up for us.

If we get Vince I don't think we need Cross.

Do you eat your words now?

[MadAsHell 4,212]

Wouldn't have thought so.

How good can he really be?

We already have Riley, Michie, Evans, McKenzie, M. Jones as middling midfielders.

We need topline mids. And you don't recruit players to be flankers.

Agreed, don't see where he'd fit in the grand scheme of things. But hey if cross calls an early retirement and one or two midfielders want out then who knows?

[DeeSpencer 25,687]

Agreed, don't see where he'd fit in the grand scheme of things. But hey if cross calls an early retirement and one or two midfielders want out then who knows?

Half forward/outside midfield. Ultimately we need to add top end quality to the list but we are still at the stage where we can add more guys around that 22-24 year old mark who have some experience and match fitness to contribute. If you had 5 or 6 first and second round draft picks you'd go for top end kids or trades only. But we dont so we have to gamble on at least one more guy who's in the same redemption category as Riley and Michie.

On the weekend we had:

Bail and Matt Jones - good effort players but lacking in skill

Salem and Riley - both not fit enough to play at the level

Kent - only in his second year and needs time to find consistency

Plus Tyson and Viney playing big midfield minutes when more mature bodies should spell them

And now we are talking about bringing in Blease. Plus Byrnes played earlier in the year!

We will likely have to cut 6 or 7 from the list who just at the end of the year. Jetta gets elevated. After that it's still 5 or 6 spots and can't fill them all with 18 year old draft picks unless it's a super super draft. Once you get to pick 50 in the draft you usually get the same player with pick 70 or PSD anyway. So if we still think he has a future then Lyons is worth a shot.

[Mickey 4,684]

How many games has Lyons played this year? Vince has proved much more than just a pick up for us.

Can't believe I said that! How embarrassing!

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,817]

I am fairly keen to get Lyons to the club. I think he'd prove to be a better pick up than Vince

Oh dear

[DeeSpencer 25,687]

Oh dear

He hasn't come yet. But I can't wait for Lyons to come next year and have 42 possessions and 4 goals.

[Ted Lasso 19,513]

Not a huge fan personally, I feel like outside skill and speed is what we need, we are probably okay on the inside Tyson, trengove and viney should be better next year and Vince Jones and cross are handy

[Mickey 4,684]

Oh dear

I have seen the obvious error of my ways... Vince had been massive

[spirit of norm smith 16,450]

Our clearance rate is still dead last in the league. It kills us.

Jarryd Lyons is a good target as gets the inside footy.

Swap for Tapscott in my opinion. Win-Win.

[Demon Disciple 12,122]

Our clearance rate is still dead last in the league. It kills us.

Jarryd Lyons is a good target as gets the inside footy.

Swap for Tapscott in my opinion. Win-Win.

It would need to be Tapscott and a pick. Or a lower pick just on its own. BP could sure pick them!

Edited June 24, 2014 by Demon Disciple

[CBDees 3,167]

Why should the Hawks have it on their own in throwing money at (out-of-contract) Crotchin [as reported in this morning's paper]? He would be a very good midfield pick-up for us if Roos could wrangle it!

[Ted Lasso 19,513]

Why should the Hawks have it on their own in throwing money at (out-of-contract) Crotchin [as reported in this morning's paper]? He would be a very good midfield pick-up for us if Roos could wrangle it!

the hawks seem to be linked to everyone at the moment, Cotch, Danger, Fyfe, Chip, Mundy

[whatwhat say what 22,747]

Buddy money.

[Little Richard 6,262]

the hawks seem to be linked to everyone at the moment, Cotch, Danger, Fyfe, Chip, Mundy

And they seem to get everyone they want...

[mitch 127]

And they seem to get everyone they want...

They didn't get Tom Gillies after trying in 2010, look who landed with that star.

[spirit of norm smith 16,450]

Too good for SANFL but behind Thompson, Dangerfield, Sloane and Crouch bros x2. A role in our midfield for sure.

A straight swap for Tapscott. Lock it in. Welcome home Jarryd.

[spirit of norm smith 16,450]

I have to keep raising this.

Jarryd Lyons swap for Luke Tapscott is win-win.

[Yossarian 1,820]

Not sure if you're aware mate, but recruiting decisions aren't based on a Demonland consensus.

[Deemotivated 550]

I have to keep raising this.

Jarryd Lyons swap for Luke Tapscott is win-win.

Check the stats for both on footywire... There's nothing between them so what's the point in swapping them?

[DeeSpencer 25,687]

I have to keep raising this.

Jarryd Lyons swap for Luke Tapscott is win-win.

Explain to me how Adelaide win? I think Lyons might have a future as a haf forward/midfiled player with decent speed and size. I think Tapscott whilst really hard and tough is short, slow and not all that great with the ball and isn't up to AFL.

[IWAP 170]

Check the stats for both on footywire... There's nothing between them so what's the point in swapping them?

Similar number of disposals, but on average Tapscott has had 50% more time on ground than Lyons.

[Redleg 40,906]

Not sure if you're aware mate, but recruiting decisions aren't based on a Demonland consensus.

They're not?

[Machsy 2,858]

I have to keep raising this.

Jarryd Lyons swap for Luke Tapscott is win-win.

I'd say it's more of a nil-all-draw...

[Akum 2,660]

Not sure if you're aware mate, but recruiting decisions aren't based on a Demonland consensus.

What the hell is a "Demonland consensus?"

And how would I know it if I ever saw it??