Considering our lack of ruck depth, I wondered, if you had the choice to bring either Majak Daw, Tyrone Vickery or Jason Holmes to our club, who would you choose?

I'd choose... none.

I think I was just sick in my mouth.

I'd choose Majak Daw's.......... body to undergo experimental gene splicing therapy with Nathan Jones' blood, to mutate and increase Majaks Football IQ

 

James Hird was a lightweight.

With a gun pointed to my head I'd choose.....

 

Ah hell just gimme the bullet.

Surely we need to aim a bit higher than that

I'd consider giving Mitch King a run with a bung knee if ee lost both Gawn and Spencer

I choose Jake Spencer

15 minutes ago, Left-Field said:

Considering our lack of ruck depth, I wondered, if you had the choice to bring either Majak Daw, Tyrone Vickery or Jason Holmes to our club, who would you choose?

too left field for me, left field

This thread is from left field. 

Jason Holmes is the one i rate the highest of the three, but still... none.

 

Thinking about it, maybe we should rookie that Keilty bloke instead.

1 minute ago, Left-Field said:

Thinking about it, maybe we should rookie that Keilty bloke instead.

how tall is he? thought he looked at bit short for afl ruck but not certain.

Castration, acid waterboarding or suspension by fish hooks. Which would you choose?

Are we talking Long John Holmes?

I don't recall us having a ruck problem this year.

17 minutes ago, Abe said:

Jason Holmes is the one i rate the highest of the three, but still... none.

 

Who is he? I've never heard of him

On 8/3/2016 at 9:23 PM, Dr. Gonzo said:

Who is he? I've never heard of him

Sherlocks cousin 

13 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Castration, acid waterboarding or suspension by fish hooks. Which would you choose?

Depends who I'm doing it to

2 minutes ago, Abe said:

Sherlocks cousin 

Elementary, Abe!

It's a trick question ? 

29 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

how tall is he? thought he looked at bit short for afl ruck but not certain.

Number: 15
Height: 194cm 
Weight: 88kg 
DOB: 08/05/1995

57 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

I'd choose... none.

I'll have what he's having!

13 minutes ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

Elementary, Abe!

The game's afoot .. but Watson...( All jobes aside ) do we go left or right. Egads the blighter's legged it. Send message to Le Strad.

This conundrum smells of Moriarty's doing.

I feel the need of a pipe ( seek out Martin.He nose the way )

Alas John ...Vickery would be ours but for Daws early mourn !!

Daw's better than Holmes, but he might actually cost something. You'd think we take someone as ruck depth and they are hard to find. So no great options there.

Vickery is a forward who can pinch hit in the ruck. As a free agent he's going to cost nothing in draft picks but something decent in salary. I wouldn't take him as I think Hulett and Weid should come on pretty quickly and one of Dawes/Pedo can be kept for depth.

Certainly both ruck and forward/ruck are positions where we need someone and there might not be a lot of good alternatives.

If the Bombers cut him I'd take a look at McKernan as a very cheap 1 year deal player.