Yeah I stole your thread idea Return To Glory (sorry) but as it is the off season it seems like it could be a bit of fun. What were your opinions or feelings regarding a player that were completely wrong?

The one that comes to mind for me is that Addam Maric just didn't get enough of a chance.

Cale Morton.

I still believe with the right weights program and in a decent team that didnt destroy his confidence he'd have been ok

I've so many I don't know where to start.

Jack Viney: thought he'd be too small and skills too scrappy to be any good.

Nev Jetta : same.

Luke Tapscott:...but he looks so strong and likes hurting people...if only he could find the ball.

Was happy to delist Jetta, was against rookie spotting him as I thought he had already shown he was useless.

Morton, Sylvia, Gysberts, Tapscott, Blease...the list goes on. Good thing I'm not a scout.

Two blokes I owe apologies to:

Lynden Dunn: other than his first handful of games where he looked like he'd be a good HFF, all I could see was a bloke that was prone to brain farts and who was more interested in being phoney tough than playing football. "We'll never be a good team as long as he's in our 22" was something I was pretty fond of saying until not that long ago. I don't know if it's maturity; him finding a position that suits him; the right word in his ear at the right time or shaving off the mo, but I'm pleased that he is comfortably picked each week and is someone dependable in our backline.

Clint Bartram: "Why the hell is he getting picked at all? Bloody useless. We'd be better off a man short." Yeah, that's what I thought of him for his first couple of years. But geez at the end he was the shutdown king on small forwards. If his knee had have held up we'd be a 2-3 goal a week better side with him in it (that is 2-3 goal we don't have to worry about getting kicked on us side).

On the other end of the scale:

Tom Scully: Yeah I was seduced. I thought he was going to be the Fyfe of the new Melbourne era. That 18 touch last quarter against Footscray seemed to prove the point. But he's proved to be a very expensive good ordinary player. Still he saved us $300 million a season and got us Hogan, so I can't hate him for his backstab. Nah, who am I kidding. He's still a turd, but lucky for us he's not our turd.

I fear my confession would fill several pages of this thread.

I paid good money to get into a Dionne Warwick concert about 20 years ago.

I still harbour a secret desire to be drafted by the Dees at the age of 63. Reckon I'd go OK in a forward pocket.

Edited November 7, 20159 yr by chook fowler

Cale Morton.

I still believe with the right weights program and in a decent team that didnt destroy his confidence he'd have been ok

Not so much confidence, but having it drilled into him from the beginning in the AFL that he was an outside receiver that should float around collecting cheap possessions, and avoiding anything physical or contested.

I once thought a ponytail looked good on a man.

I paid good money to get into a Dionne Warwick concert about 20 years ago.

I would've walked on by Biffen.

I did, however, buy a Glen Campbell greatest hits album and I still like it and anything written by Jimmy Webb.

Felt Luke Tapscott could be Rene Kink - like if he could get on the park. He's doing very well for Sorrento.

Human League to be bigger than The Beatles

Darren Cuthbertson to win a Brownlow

Brian Wilson is no good

Human League to be bigger than The Beatles

Darren Cuthbertson to win a Brownlow

Brian Wilson is no good

Wow

Please don't tell us anymore, BBO.

I don't want to be an accomplice after the fact...

Um, jeez, I don't know - about every player I suggested during my cringeworthy Flag Core © madness from a few years ago... Morton and Gysberts the most laughable.

But the ones that were the reverse - wrote off Garland after Rd 2, 2008. Dunn has stopped jumper punching and pulled a career out of the fire I didn't think he would be able to get. Not many of these...

I was right onto Viney and Hogan. Knew Viney would be this good when his mum had parents of older boys complain to her about how he played his footy.

And as soon as I saw some footage of Hogan before the Mini Draft - it was by any means necessary...

So it's not all delusion and stupidity.

thought gysberts was going to be a star.

thought brent heaver was going to be a star.

thought sean charles was going to be a star.

thought jurrah was going to be a star, and a pillar of the community, and inspiration for a legion of aboriginal players coming through.

thought jakovich was going to be the greatest goal kicking full forward ever, and lead us to the promised land.

thought northey was the man to take us to a premiership.

the list goes on and on...

Not a player, but I thought Neeld was going to be an excellent coach!

Weve all made mistakes. ..especially putting some into type

i once thought greenies lived in the country

I was all over JKH after his 3 goals in the last qtr v Richmond in the preseason two years ago.

Still waiting for him to come on....

Not a player, but I thought Neeld was going to be an excellent coach!

So did I, up until then a few players had had it too easy for little return.

Are the Suns going to confess they stuffed up taking Martin over Hogan.

I used to like Michael Long - before 2000.

I paid good money to get into a Dionne Warwick concert about 20 years ago.

the first concert I ever went to was rick astley

i once saw bobby and laurie