Are we still talking about Bennell or Lewis Jetta?

Bennell

Bennell

Cheers. Where's it been reported that he wants to return to WA?

Cheers. Where's it been reported that he wants to return to WA?

My dog knows some board members

Jetta has requested to go back to WA. I don't think I've heard anywhere that Bennell wants to go back to WA

Jetta has requested to go back to WA. I don't think I've heard anywhere that Bennell wants to go back to WA

At first glance I thought you meant our Jetta

I really want Bennell. Worth the risk in my opinion.

We beat Gold Coast in a game a couple of years ago at a the G. I can't remember exactly but Ablett got something like 35 and Bennell got 38? I predicted at the time that he would soon be a Brownlow medalist. Well things haven't quite panned out that way but he still has the potential.

He is a Ferrari in the same way as Judd is. He's possibly going to be very high maintenance but it's worth the risk to get our hands on this quality of talent. Every player carries risk. Dangerfield or Fyfe could have career-ending injuries but it wouldn't put you off getting them if you could.

My dog knows some board members

I don't believe you.

I don't believe you.

It is true. my orangutan's trainer knows MC's dog's cousin. It is a reliable source sauce!!!

However, I hear MC's dog has a crack problem, can not keep his nose out of it... See what I did there, dogs & butt cracks... I'll move on now.

Jetta has requested to go back to WA. I don't think I've heard anywhere that Bennell wants to go back to WA

Apparently his family don't want him back in WA (big footy as a secondary source, family member facebook primary source).

There are too many bad influences for Bennell in WA. He was up to no good before he got drafted. I think his only hope is to try his hand in Vic.

Roosy would actually be ideal for Bennell. I think he might end up a Demon to be honest.

My dog knows some board members

When you say "knows" you mean in the biblical sense right?

I don't believe you.

I seem to be the only person that picked up on this.

Tigers met Harley today.

Still makes me angry we seem to not be in the hunt.

Still makes me angry we seem to not be in the hunt.

we might have someone better lined up. Im not fussed

we might have someone better lined up. Im not fussed

Melksham?

Melksham?

less milk...more fish

Maybe the issue isn't that we don't want him but that he doesn't want us. If that's the case there's no point being desperate.

I'd love to have him, but I don't Hogan, Brayshaw, Petracca etc going off the rails either.

If the consensus is that we aren't ready to bring in a bad apple in then I can understand that.

Much as I really would like him at the Dees he's not someone to "chase". He's someone that if we're interested we meet with him and see where his heads at, make an offer, and leave it at that. If he doesn't want to meet with us then that's up to him and I wouldn't want him at the club. But if he's open to us then we have a strategy and we stick to it.

Still makes me angry we seem to not be in the hunt.

Tigers think they're in a premiership window and are prepared to roll the dice and risk it with Harley. We're in the middle of a major culture shift and to bring in Bennell now would most definitely risk denting all of the hard work the club has done over the Roos/Jackson period. I'd be willing to think the club sees it as simply not worth it.

Ken Judge passed some comments on Bennell last Saturday on the radio which went something like:

Ablett Snr showed how much of a potential star in the making he was at Hawthorn but didn't toe the line and for fear of it infecting the rest of the list, Yabby Jeans moved him on and he ended up at Geelong where he turned out to be one of the all time greats and played in two GF's - the Hawks went on to win 4 premierships. I can't recall who Judge mentioned but they basically said there was two sets of rules at Geelong which was one for Ablett and the other for the rest of the squad.

His comments about Bennell directly were referencing a couple of other incidents that occurred between the infamous Tassie photo and when he had the incident with the bouncer. He said they were kept under wraps and out of the media but were pretty disturbing. I think PSD probably alluded these incidents early on in this thread.

Richmond might back themselves in to control Bennell given they've managed to get Dusty's [censored] together for him and maybe the MFC might think it could do the same however, we have one problem child at the club that takes up enormous resources at the expense of the rest of the players (Jurrah) is not fair and doesn't bode well for a strong culture being built off the foundation of a team first mentality.

The Suns want him gone. I think that speaks volumes on its own.

I reckon we'll look back on this one and not be too disappointed at all.

Still makes me angry we seem to not be in the hunt.

Why take the risk we have to be a clean cut club what's a couple more years without winning [censored] off as well exactly what we need I would trade pick 6 for him take a chance

It's all over the news on SEN that he wants to go to WA. This move was compared to that of Dale Garlett who is now in gaol.

Edited September 30, 201510 yr by Diamond

Was told today we lost interest a while back. The meeting posted early was 100% bs.

Was told today we lost interest a while back. The meeting posted early was 100% bs.

Roos openly said that, but nobody on here chose to believe him.

I dared to believe as well.

Roos openly said that, but nobody on here chose to believe him.

Prior to coaching MFC Roos also said he had no interest in coaching.