Changes v Collingwood

[Biffen 12,380]

If I recall correctly, when JKH was drafted I believe he was praised for his work ethic. Isn't this also what Roos was saying when he picked him to play at the beginning of last season?

What evidence is there that he has a "very suspect work ethic"?

Has exceeded expectation already and will be better when he slows down a touch, yes slows down.

[Ted Lasso 16,931]

Play dawes in defence?

[Biffen 12,380]

Play dawes in defence?

over de fence!

[nrc73 77]

But Dawes has barely put in one good game this year, he passed as serviceable as second ruck/forward last week but this week was found out for his lack of.....well anything. If his role is forward/second ruck then I reckon we'd get just as much, possibly more from Jamar. Jamar has also had good Casey form and would be a just reward for his effort. IMO we'd get a better ruck, and a just as competent forward.

Agree 100% with everyone that Dawes output all year does not warrant his salary, senior member status, nor possibly a permanent spot in the team. The only value Dawes has really provided is a link up man when we move it through the centre at speed. That's about it. I seem him as being in the same ball park as Grimes, who's been forced to improve his game before earning a spot.

One thing you can be confident about Jamar - he does know how to clunk a mark in the forward line, although I wonder if he has the athleticism to lead up all game. Surely it's time to find out if he has another year in him.

[boydie 653]

Play dawes in defence?

So Jesse White can kick 7 this time?

[picket fence 15,376]

INNS

RILEY ( Gunna be wet, need strong in an under)

WHITE ( Elevate to Senior List) Elite Kicking and reader of play)

HUNT ( For Pace)

OUTS

STRETCH ( Needs a spell)

HARMES ( Not enough last week)

MICHIE ( Not productive enough)

Might be tempted to also play ANB

Mc Donald to backline, If Howe plays must play forward!

That's it

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

in hindsight i was sucked in by the spin when we picked him up

he's an all-australian and a premiership player, these are facts, not spin

[old dee 22,946]

he's an all-australian and a premiership player, these are facts, not spin

So was Dawes and we know how good he is.

[rpfc 27,590]

So was Dawes and we know how good he is.

Better than he has shown, and good enough to play a role in our resurgence?

Happy to be Robison Crusoe on this.

It's lonely, though...

[old dee 22,946]

Better than he has shown, and good enough to play a role in our resurgence?

Happy to be Robison Crusoe on this.

It's lonely, though...

Yes I think your group would be close to one rpfc

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,499]

Better than he has shown, and good enough to play a role in our resurgence?

Happy to be Robison Crusoe on this.

It's lonely, though...

Yes I think your group would be close to one rpfc

Two. I'm with you, rpfc.

[loges 6,144]

We played about a quarter against this mob last time and only lost by 4 goals. Play 4 quarters and we should win.

4 quarters of what kind of football?? The essendon game or the geelong game

[Coq au vin 754]

I'm no fan, but Grimes was our second best player last week.

How about someone post some changes without unfounded bias?

Gawn was our best and Viney second best. Grimes kept turning it over.

[Gator 16,906]

From the bit I saw Hogan was much worse than Dawes,petulant, abusing team mates, and when he had it could generally not kick the ball over a jam tin, I guess people believe what they want to believe, 7 disposals is not a bag, and is miserly compared to Dawes 17 touches, would not be surprised if his lack of effort he found himself at Casey, needs to pull his big head in.

[Coq au vin 754]

Dawes was a walking disaster.

[Guest]

Just Stretch out for ANB.

Good lord. Dawes must have incriminating photos at his disposal.

Edited July 30, 2015 by Scythe

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Just Stretch out for ANB.

Good lord. Dawes must have incriminating photos at his disposal.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/teams

who did you want in? with Salem, Kent, Frost, Pederson, Petracca and Trengove injured, this is our best 22. Nat Fyfe is not at Casey you know

Edited July 30, 2015 by Curry & Beer

[Coq au vin 754]

ANB in Stretch out. Pathetic! Where's the accountability?

Edited July 30, 2015 by Kali

[What 18,810]

Dawes still in LOL

if Michie is the sub again Im gonna go nuts

[Guest]

Drop the rookie, not the soft as butter experienced players who, again, are allowed to completely lack accountability.

[Brayshaw Self 847]

Collingwood are trying to expose us by dropping Jesse White. It will be interesting to see how our tall backline goes.

McDonald forward, Dunn on resting ruck and Garland on small forward/mid doesn't sound too bad to me.

I don't mind how we match up on paper.

[picket fence 15,376]

Hnmm starting to question the integrity of selections!

Hnmm Riley better than Michie, Roll the dice Upgrade White and Hunt and "Blood" for the future!

Too much "Dead Wood" still getting games!

Also some players must be wondering "What do I have to do to get a game"

[Frosty Demon 153]

I wouldn't be upset if Tyson was dropped.

you mean Jekyl and Hyde

[stuie 7,374]

One change? ONE CHANGE?!

To a team that has been dismal for 3 weeks?!

What happened to culture Roosy?

[old dee 22,946]

Two. I'm with you, rpfc.

wow monster group is now three LDC