POST MATCH DISCUSSION - Round 6

[ManDee 7,147]

McDonald should be moved to CHF, like Neatz, All Australian CHB, was the making of him, McDonald CHF, Hogan FF, doubt if Roos has the flair to see beyond Cross and Lamumba, he has a let's not lose it attitude on the game instead of a let's win it, I won't miss Paul Roos.

Tmac reminds me of Jeremy Cameron.

[Roost It 1,434]

Neitx was a much better CHB than a FF

Moving TMac would be a disaster

Good offence starts with a good defence. It's then the midfield that helps to win the game

You don't need a particularly strong forward line to win a Premiership. Hogan, Garlett, Dawes and Watts is easily good enough. Just fix the midfield. Bluey you are a [censored] moron

[Adam The God 30,249]

Completely agree. I think he has a negative influence on our development. Always leads wide, fails to make an impact for 80% of the game. Sucks the life out of the team. Only pops up when the rest of the team are playing well. Seemed like Neeld gave him a free ride into the team because of his Collingwood association and now he's on good terms with Roos because he's a good trainer or whatever

So it's a Tuesday afternoon troll, is it?

[Je Roos Salem 661]

So it's a Tuesday afternoon troll, is it?

'I disagree with you' would suffice, but whatever. I don't accept the results so I give my take on what's going wrong.

[dazzledavey36 54,925]

So it's a Tuesday afternoon troll, is it?

I found nothing in that was considered 'trolling'

Cannot understand why most people won't accept the truth that Dawes is just a very very ordinary player. We paid him big money to kick goals and provide leadership. The first one he is not even that good at and 2nd i still question his so call leadership.. rarely does he stand up in the big games when we need him most.

He has the worst hands i have ever seen as a key forward, he leads far too wide and when he does have the ball he just turns it over.

Collingwood did the right thing getting rid of him for Jesse White.

[Ethan Tremblay 30,859]

Tmac reminds me of Jeremy Cameron.

Yeah they could pass as brothers couldn't they.

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,765]

Its fun reading how some players are marked and how the criticism gets justified but others float by.

Toumpas first game back in for a grand total of 20th with probably third as the sub has 7 kicks 7 handballs at 71%.

Newton has 7 kicks and 7 handballs at 71% including two shocking errors early in the game.

Spencer after half time was clearly the better ruckman and had the second most tackles and second most clearances in his first game back. Pike who some claim is a second rate ruckman was second for contested grabs in the league last year, achieved the tap out record in one game last week and has only been beaten by Sandilands all year. Jamar showed at VFL he is done and Gawn did some good things but does not work half as hard as Spencer.

Watts comes on and was clean and serviceable. Howe floats by in another lazy, disinterested soft game.

My main disappointment was we seemed so focussed on halving the stoppages with them last night that no held position and no had interest to spread when we had the ball.

Tyson needs to face criticism for his inability to spread or if he is that injured try and get right whatever is wrong. JKH's workrate is appalling and he needs to have a long stint at Casey. Hopefully Viney back so Vince can be let off the leash as we are now missing his attacking creativity whilst he is more focussed on the tag.

This has not happened before - I tend to agree with every single thing above.

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,765]

I found nothing in that was considered 'trolling'

Cannot understand why most people won't accept the truth that Dawes is just a very very ordinary player. We paid him big money to kick goals and provide leadership. The first one he is not even that good at and 2nd i still question his so call leadership.. rarely does he stand up in the big games when we need him most.

He has the worst hands i have ever seen as a key forward, he leads far too wide and when he does have the ball he just turns it over.

Collingwood did the right thing getting rid of him for Jesse White.

hahaha...Dawes isn't playing well but c'mon...Jesse White? That's a low blow.

[bluey 1,102]

Rivers was a rising star, Frawley was an All Australian, Grimes was a highly skilled young Captain of the club, Howe was moved back and looks completely shot, nobody can mentally stand under the torrent of ball that is unleashed to our Backline, stacking up one loss after another, the writing is on the wall for McDonald, too good a player, hopefully it's not a matter of move forward or move club.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Rivers was a rising star, Frawley was an All Australian, Grimes was a highly skilled young Captain of the club, Howe was moved back and looks completely shot, nobody can mentally stand under the torrent of ball that is unleashed to our Backline, stacking up one loss after another, the writing is on the wall for McDonald, too good a player, hopefully it's not a matter of move forward or move club.

Damning evidence indeed.....good points raised.

I hope our midfield can develop quickly so they remain competitive for the entire game. This will relieve some pressure...

[dazzledavey36 54,925]

hahaha...Dawes isn't playing well but c'mon...Jesse White? That's a low blow.

Its true 3.. ask any Collingwood supporter or player and they will tell you they do not miss him one bit.

I agree white isn't that good at all but id take his form over Dawes.

Atleast he can mark the footy FFS

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Its true 3.. ask any Collingwood supporter or player and they will tell you they do not miss him one bit.

I agree white isn't that good at all but id take his form over Dawes.

Atleast he can mark the footy FFS

I'd prefer their midfield delivering to Dawes and Hogan....

[IRW 1,387]

McDonald should be moved to CHF, like Neatz, All Australian CHB, was the making of him, McDonald CHF, Hogan FF, doubt if Roos has the flair to see beyond Cross and Lamumba, he has a let's not lose it attitude on the game instead of a let's win it, I won't miss Paul Roos.

Good to see you've kept up with your speling practice on your new site Old coq

Edited May 12, 2015 by IRW

[dazzledavey36 54,925]

I'd prefer their midfield delivering to Dawes and Hogan....

And then watch the opposition rebound after another Dawes spilt mark..

Look he is a good honest battler and thats it. I still reckon we recruit a big key forward in the draft. Josh Schache should be in our sights.

Edited May 12, 2015 by dazzledavey36

[Je Roos Salem 661]

I'd prefer their midfield delivering to Dawes and Hogan....

Many people are blaming our midfield without being too specific. I'm just looking at some stats. Jones, Vince and Tyson are our Top 3 in clangers. They were 3 of our top 4 last year, so not sure if that's a huge revelation. Newton leads inside 50s this season with 21, Tyson and Vince only have 12 and 11 respectively. (Vince lead us last year with 3.7 PG).

Vince and Tyson had 51 possessions between them for only 2 i50s V Sydney.

Hogan has taken 13 marks i50, compared to Dawes' 2.

Meanwhile, Jones is down to 3.3 clearances a game after averaging 6.3 last year.

Our team is ranked last in both disposal efficiency and disposal average while we were ranked 4th in the AFL in D.E last year

[Biffen 12,943]

Neitx was a much better CHB than a FF

Moving TMac would be a disaster

Good offence starts with a good defence. It's then the midfield that helps to win the game

You don't need a particularly strong forward line to win a Premiership. Hogan, Garlett, Dawes and Watts is easily good enough. Just fix the midfield. Bluey you are a [censored] moron

[Biffen 12,943]

Neitx was a much better CHB than a FF

Moving TMac would be a disaster

Good offence starts with a good defence. It's then the midfield that helps to win the game

You don't need a particularly strong forward line to win a Premiership. Hogan, Garlett, Dawes and Watts is easily good enough. Just fix the midfield. Bluey you are a [censored] moron

At least he has company.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Many people are blaming our midfield without being too specific. I'm just looking at some stats. Jones, Vince and Tyson are our Top 3 in clangers. They were 3 of our top 4 last year, so not sure if that's a huge revelation. Newton leads inside 50s this season with 21, Tyson and Vince only have 12 and 11 respectively. (Vince lead us last year with 3.7 PG).

Vince and Tyson had 51 possessions between them for only 2 i50s V Sydney.

Hogan has taken 13 marks i50, compared to Dawes' 2.

Meanwhile, Jones is down to 3.3 clearances a game after averaging 6.3 last year.

Our team is ranked last in both disposal efficiency and disposal average while we were ranked 4th in the AFL in D.E last year

He is so heavily tagged this year, it's not funny.....

[Adam The God 30,249]

'I disagree with you' would suffice, but whatever. I don't accept the results so I give my take on what's going wrong.

Apologies. I did actually think you were legitimately trolling. :D Let's say I disagree and retract my troll comment with an apology attached.

Many people are blaming our midfield without being too specific. I'm just looking at some stats. Jones, Vince and Tyson are our Top 3 in clangers. They were 3 of our top 4 last year, so not sure if that's a huge revelation. Newton leads inside 50s this season with 21, Tyson and Vince only have 12 and 11 respectively. (Vince lead us last year with 3.7 PG).

Vince and Tyson had 51 possessions between them for only 2 i50s V Sydney.

Hogan has taken 13 marks i50, compared to Dawes' 2.

Meanwhile, Jones is down to 3.3 clearances a game after averaging 6.3 last year.

Our team is ranked last in both disposal efficiency and disposal average while we were ranked 4th in the AFL in D.E last year

Disposal efficiency is one of the most misleading stats in the game. We chipped the ball around at half back all year in '14. That made our DE look a lot healthier. Now that we're taking a few more risks, our DE is dropping.

Thanks for the clangers stats though. That is enlightening. I hope Jones, Tyson and Vince can turn it around. I suspect Tyson is carrying an injury though, which continues to hinder him.

Its true 3.. ask any Collingwood supporter or player and they will tell you they do not miss him one bit.

I agree white isn't that good at all but id take his form over Dawes.

Atleast he can mark the footy FFS

And Collingwood are going to say that they miss him? Far too arrogant to admit fault. Dawes should be playing out of the square, IMO.

[3Dee 1,153]

How far off is Omomatic / O-Mac / OMO ?

Edited May 13, 2015 by 3Dee

[ManDee 7,147]

Yeah they could pass as brothers couldn't they.

Like Arnie and Danny deVito.

No, I mean the way they run and turn the surprising hardness when bumped. They both go straight at the ball and are very hard to knock off line. Cameron is a far more natural kick.

Edit: I likened T Mac with Jeremy Cameron

Edited May 13, 2015 by ManDee

[ManDee 7,147]

Many people are blaming our midfield without being too specific. I'm just looking at some stats. Jones, Vince and Tyson are our Top 3 in clangers. They were 3 of our top 4 last year, so not sure if that's a huge revelation. Newton leads inside 50s this season with 21, Tyson and Vince only have 12 and 11 respectively. (Vince lead us last year with 3.7 PG).

Vince and Tyson had 51 possessions between them for only 2 i50s V Sydney.

Hogan has taken 13 marks i50, compared to Dawes' 2.

Meanwhile, Jones is down to 3.3 clearances a game after averaging 6.3 last year.

Our team is ranked last in both disposal efficiency and disposal average while we were ranked 4th in the AFL in D.E last year

He is so heavily tagged this year, it's not funny.....

Pretty sure Jones is carrying an injury , his shoulder is giving him trouble. A mere mortal would have missed 4 to 6

Edited May 13, 2015 by ManDee

[sue 9,104]

Pretty sure Jones is carrying an injury , his shoulder is giving him trouble. A mere mortal would have missed 4 to 6

He grabbed his shoulder at least once v Sydney.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Pretty sure Jones is carrying an injury , his shoulder is giving him trouble. A mere mortal would have missed 4 to 6

G.Ablett- the mere mortal.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Apologies. I did actually think you were legitimately trolling. :D Let's say I disagree and retract my troll comment with an apology attached.

Disposal efficiency is one of the most misleading stats in the game. We chipped the ball around at half back all year in '14. That made our DE look a lot healthier. Now that we're taking a few more risks, our DE is dropping.

Thanks for the clangers stats though. That is enlightening. I hope Jones, Tyson and Vince can turn it around. I suspect Tyson is carrying an injury though, which continues to hinder him.

And Collingwood are going to say that they miss him? Far too arrogant to admit fault. Dawes should be playing out of the square, IMO.

True, and we've played a couple of wet weather games. Still, tons of unacceptable turnovers in the dry V Sydney. Well, it's gonna stay tough if Jones and Tyson don't get 100%. To me that says Bernie needs to lift or we need Lumumba in the middle more just to be able to break away from stoppages