Ok, you will all have your own opinions about this guy yeah he has had his problems off the field and there is a risk, but this guy can play! He is exactly what we need in the centre tough as nails in the centre throws his weight around has a bit of dash and lays some bone crunching tackles too! He would add some much needed depth in the centre to help out Cross Vince and some of the younger onballers. Im sure if Roos thinks he can sort him out im In!!

Remember cant put to much expectation onto a Brayshaw so early, hasn't worked for us in the past!!!

Do you honestly think they will bring him in straight after we just recruited Garlett...

I disagree that he can play. If you haven't got a lot going for you personality wise, you need to be a good enough player to offset that, and Robinson isn't.

Do you honestly think they will bring him in straight after we just recruited Garlett...

Probably not. But gee I liked the way he went about it. Not overly endowed with talent, but makes the most of what he has. interesting contrast to some we have/had on our list who didn't manage to do the same.

I certainly wouldn't mind his type of grunt on our half back line.

Helps our team with hard-ball gets and courage.

Doesn't help our team with his disposal.

We should've got him last year when Picket Fence offered up pick 2 for him.

Just No.

FFS, no!

Just to help keep Garlett out of trouble, if for no other reason.

Do you honestly think they will bring him in straight after we just recruited Garlett...

Post of the year from Deefella!!

We should've got him last year when Picket Fence offered up pick 2 for him.

I still say we start a 'Hall of Shame' thread for posts such as that.

We can add the one where that bloke said Cameron Ling was too ugly to be a senior coach and that other one where it was suggested we try to recruit Tim Tebow to the club.

Edited October 17, 201410 yr by Colin B. Flaubert

may as well get dank and the weapon too

i hear their price has dropped somewhat

Would be worth it just to keep our young guys out of trouble at the big day out.

I think Robinson (like Lamumba in many respects) is underrated as player due to perceptions about his personality.

I would have thought the club looked at Robinson and Gartlett and wisely chose only one of them.

They both need a change of scenery and time away from the people who they formed bad habits alongside.

We should've got him last year when Picket Fence offered up pick 2 for him.

He didn't did he...

I think Robinson (like Lamumba in many respects) is underrated as player due to perceptions about his personality.

I would have thought the club looked at Robinson and Gartlett and wisely chose only one of them.

They both need a change of scenery and time away from the people who they formed bad habits alongside.

Themselves....

Nein, nein, nein.

No DH policy applies in his case!

I don't think he wants to come here and play "bruise free footy"......

Luke Thompson from the Crows would be worth some thought.

I still say we start a 'Hall of Shame' thread for posts such as that.

We can add the one where that bloke said Cameron Ling was too ugly to be a senior coach and that other one where it was suggested we try and recruit Tim Tebow to the club.

Hahaha yes the Tebow one, w t f.

Should get Yao Ming in the ruck too. Really cement that China connection we've got going on...

No, thanks.

It's honestly bewildering reading comments lambasting someone I would wager none of you have met in your lives.

And for what, exactly?

A comment he never actually made himself ("bruise free"). What a DH!

Defending himself when physically attacked at a music festival. What a DH!

His greatest crime was not being upfront with the club regarding his involvement with Garlett, who reportedly was also attacked. But of course let's assume the worst cause it's Robinson. Did I mention..what a DH!!!

I'm sure none of you have ever touched a drop of alcohol or gone out and found yourself In a situation you'd rather not be in. A bunch of pristine angels.

His on field value is what matters, and that is debatable. He didn't have the most inspiring season but Malthouse was clearly never a huge fan.

Any off field stuff is a bunch of overblown tripe. This idea that he could corrupt the club is absolutely ridiculous.

if we didnt have Garlett then yes

Robinson would walk into our starting midfield

Let's just pick him up and refer to him as the King and be done with it..

Let's get him and back Roos into managing him. If he can be managed could be valuable for us. Let him play lots of bruise adorned football!!!

Yes from me, DH???? may well be but improves our midfield depth and hardness