Let's just draft Tom McDonalds brother and be done with it*

*havent seen him play, don't know if he can play, don't even know what he looks like.

Wonder if Goodyear is any good in the wet?

Some posters here need to get a grip.

I'll take 5c royalties on the nickname Blimp.

Ill see your 5c and raise you "Weary"

More bad player related puns? I mean wheelie?!!

Pick 53: Ash Smith (if not available as a delisted FA).

Goodyear looks like he has a good set of wheels on him....

Any chance he'll slide to us?

The story on goodyear is that he need pressure to perform well.He gained some traction at the end of the year.

Pick 53: Ash Smith (if not available as a delisted FA).

Multiple Choice

a) You've never seen him play

b) Your taking the pi55

c) You have NFI

d) You're blind

Nah from what i've heard, Goodyear is wildly inconsistent. He only saves a game once a year.

Multiple Choice

a) You've never seen him play

b) Your taking the pi55

c) You have NFI

d) You're blind

Oh Pennant Almighty you suggest these options for having an opinion that differs to yours? Get over yourself man.

Michie went for pick 54 last year, what is so insane about Smith for 53 this year?

Oh Pennant Almighty you suggest these options for having an opinion that differs to yours? Get over yourself man.

Michie went for pick 54 last year, what is so insane about Smith for 53 this year?

Michie was traded from Freo for 54 > big difference!

Edited October 22, 201411 yr by CBDees

Michie was traded from Freo for 54 > big difference!

Obviously he was traded, doesn't change anything in the post.

Edited October 22, 201411 yr by Carlos Danger

Oh Pennant Almighty you suggest these options for having an opinion that differs to yours? Get over yourself man.

Michie went for pick 54 last year, what is so insane about Smith for 53 this year?

The difference is Michie can play and was a standout at WAFL level in a very poor side, he was out of contract and wanted to head home for more opportunities. Smith is not leaving WA by choice

Ash Smith can not play and is out of his depth at WAFL level, when he first came over to WA he looked a likely type but his footy has been going backwards since about 2011/12

Seen him play many times for Perth and then this year with East Perth under the Meth Coast alignment, he murders the ball gets a bit of the pill due to his superior AFL fitness but turns it over by poor disposal or by making horrible decisions.

Your opinion does differ from mine and I may be wrong in my assumption but I'm going to hazard a guess that barring TV you would not have seen much of Ash Smith

Obviously he was traded, doesn't change anything in the post.

Michie's not scared of contact nor does he turn it over at will. Smith played a good season, got a contract and hasn't played well since for 2 if not 3 years.

Brett Eddy ...at 53 for me. Mature 23yo skilled 193cm forward. Gunston like.

More bad player related puns? I mean wheelie?!!

tread carefully!

Thanks for that jabberwocky. Goodyear looks the type of player you would never get tyred of watching.

Heard his stats were rubbery.

tread carefully!

Apparently deflated about his chances.

The difference is Michie can play and was a standout at WAFL level in a very poor side, he was out of contract and wanted to head home for more opportunities. Smith is not leaving WA by choice

Ash Smith can not play and is out of his depth at WAFL level, when he first came over to WA he looked a likely type but his footy has been going backwards since about 2011/12

Seen him play many times for Perth and then this year with East Perth under the Meth Coast alignment, he murders the ball gets a bit of the pill due to his superior AFL fitness but turns it over by poor disposal or by making horrible decisions.

Your opinion does differ from mine and I may be wrong in my assumption but I'm going to hazard a guess that barring TV you would not have seen much of Ash Smith

This list for the most-part is incredibly slow. Smith has pace and uses it, that's what attracted my interest. Along with considerable years in the system retaining his spot at WCE.

Obviously it's very easy to pick faults in a player that's just been delisted. I'm sure you would've also had a lot of negative output on Matty Spangher when he was delisted.

I'm tyred about all this discussion!

I'm tyred about all this discussion!

You're full of air Clit!

Goodyear - he's a blimp.

Sorry -didn't realise it's been done.

Edited October 31, 201411 yr by chook fowler

Pick 53: Ash Smith (if not available as a delisted FA).

Oh dear you are having shockers.....

Leroy Jetta and now Ash Smith!?

Please stear clear right away from our recruiting team!

Now we have 40 to use we should activate 53 and use it to better our list.

Now we have 40 to use we should activate 53 and use it to better our list.

And who would you suggest we delist for 53? Pickles, Trenners?