What's 1 draft pick we have nailed in the past 10 years?

[The Stigga 1,096]

Besides Nathan Jones?

[Striker475 696]

Pick 53, 2010 National Draft.

Look him up.

[The Stigga 1,096]

Pick 53, 2010 National Draft.

Look him up.

Yeah, not sure about that yet.

[Redleg 41,935]

Pick 53, 2010 National Draft.

Look him up.

If that is Tom Mc, that was a great pick.

[Redleg 41,935]

The terrible legacy of club destroyer Prendergast lives on. Overlooking Daniel Talia at pick 13 for Gysberts, despite most on Demonland hoping Talia would be there at 13, now winning Crows B & F on top of AA selection and AA squad selection this year.

This guy nearly destroyed the club on his own.

[Demonsone 2,050]

Either all gone to other clubs...... Or delisted!

[The Stigga 1,096]

If that is Tom Mc, that was a great pick.

Really?

[Little Goffy 14,750]

Contenders -

2010 - Howe at 33 McDonald at 53

2009 - Max Gawn at 34

2007 - Stefan Martin, PSD pick 3

2006 - Frawley pick 12 Garland, pick 46

2005 - Jones pick 12 Bartram, pick 60

2004 - Dunn pick 15

2003 - Davey, Rookie pick 3

You have to go right back to Davey to find a real 'nailed it' kind of pick. There are a few 'good value for where they went'.

But Jones is the only really outstanding player we've drafted in ten years, followed by Frawley.

We can hope that some from the recent drafts, including Howe and McDonald, might take another step and make us look back and say, yeah, we got that right.

[SaberFang 7,151]

I'm hopeful JKH proves a real steal. Be hard pressed to find many other ~40ish draft picks last year who had close to the same impact.

[deanox 10,045]

In all honesty, other than Jones we don't have a player worthy of "nailed it" so I don't think we need to even look at where they have been drafted.

Edited September 5, 2014 by deanox

[Redleg 41,935]

Really?

Yes, Tom Mc at pick 53 is a good pick. The departing FB was taken at 12, 41 picks earlier.

Who would you rather keep?

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Dean Kent at 48 is a nice pick.

[Sir Why You Little 37,302]

Peter Jackson.

[Qwerty30 196]

The terrible legacy of club destroyer Prendergast lives on. Overlooking Daniel Talia at pick 13 for Gysberts, despite most on Demonland hoping Talia would be there at 13, now winning Crows B & F on top of AA selection and AA squad selection this year.

This guy nearly destroyed the club on his own.

While Prendergast was a disaster (no argument), his predecessor Craig Cameron was not much better.

[Bang Bang Bang 5,839]

I don't care if he's leaving, we clearly nailed the Frawley pick in 2006. At the time I was filthy we didn't take James Sellar, who went to the Crows two picks later. Just sayin...

Edited September 6, 2014 by Sylvia Saint

[Qwerty30 196]

Contenders -

2010 - Howe at 33 McDonald at 53

2009 - Max Gawn at 34

2007 - Stefan Martin, PSD pick 3

2006 - Frawley pick 12 Garland, pick 46

2005 - Jones pick 12 Bartram, pick 60

2004 - Dunn pick 15

2003 - Davey, Rookie pick 3

You have to go right back to Davey to find a real 'nailed it' kind of pick. There are a few 'good value for where they went'.

But Jones is the only really outstanding player we've drafted in ten years, followed by Frawley.

We can hope that some from the recent drafts, including Howe and McDonald, might take another step and make us look back and say, yeah, we got that right.

I dont think we have nailed it since Scott Thompson in 2000 and we could not keep him.

An assessment of drafting can be done on the basis of expectations you have each pick you have. If you get it right a first round pick should get you a player who will be at least a backbone of your side with a successful long term career. 3^rd round and later picks become a mixture of good fortune and a keen eye to find talent late in the draft. Your expectations are not as great and you may actual get access to a reasonable player and that pick can be seen as a success.

An Indicative Minimum Criteria (Assuming player is not hampered by injury or illness)

1^st Round Pick (Pick 1-18) – min 8 to 10 year player with 150 to 200 games who is a cornerstone of the side.

2^nd round pick (Pick 19-36) – 5 -8 year player with at least 100 games who is at the very least a serviceable player over a sustained period

3^rd round pick (Pick 37-54) – 2 -5 year player that you get at least serviceable 30 plus games out of a player who fills a short to medium term gap in your side.

4^th round pick ( Pick 55+)/Rookie/PSD– A smokie that plays at least serviceable 10 games.

Minimum Criteria may be achieved where a player has underperformed the prima facie criteria but the Club has successfully traded that player for draft picks/compensation that results in a net gain. (Notwithstanding the Club might have not used the draft pick well). Two examples would be Brock McLean and Tom Scully

Here it goes but I might have missed someone.

Craig Cameron was Head of Recruiting 2000 - 2007, Barry Prendergast 2008- 2011

2000 – Nothing (Unfortunately we lost Scott Thompson)

2001 – Nothing

2002 - Pick 26 Jared Rivers, Pick 55 –Brad Miller

2003 – Rookie – Aaron Davey

2004 – Rookie - Mark Jamar

2005 – Pick 12 – Nathan Jones, Pick 60 – Clint Bartram

2006 – Pick 12 - Frawley , Pick 46 - Garland

2007 – PSD - Stef Martin

2008 – Pick 51 Neville Jetta Pick 64 Rohan Bail

2009 – Nothing

2010 – Pic 33 - Howe, Pick 53 - McDonald

2011 - Nothing. Possible rookies in McKenzie and Spencer

2012 -2013 – Too early to judge but some promising players are there

Did not have Dunn who as a 1st round pick has been good in his last year or so but has under delivered over his career. A so so pick over the course thus far. I hope he adds value in his remaining years.

But from 2000 to 2011 its been an absolute train wreck when you consider some of the poor trades as well.

Edited September 6, 2014 by Qwerty30

[Frosty Demon 153]

Jeremy Howe

[beelzebub 23,390]

Dean Kent at 48 is a nice pick.

shaping that way... 2015 I think he'll come on some.

[Biffen 12,949]

Nev and Tom Mac in the 50s were good gets.

[Guest]

The terrible legacy of club destroyer Prendergast lives on. Overlooking Daniel Talia at pick 13 for Gysberts, despite most on Demonland hoping Talia would be there at 13, now winning Crows B & F on top of AA selection and AA squad selection this year.

This guy nearly destroyed the club on his own.

He did a horrible job, Redleg. I would actually ask above all else who actually hired him. He had never worked in recruiting before and had been a coach up to that point if I am correct. We up until this year seemed to have a knack of putting under-qualified and inexperienced people in positions they had no hope of ever succeeding in.

Edited September 6, 2014 by Colin B. Flaubert

[Dockett 32 1,239]

Couldn't help notice the size, strength, toughness and resolve of the Swans and Freo players and the Essendon /North players also for that matter. Total commitment and bodies on the line for 100 minutes. I hope we recruit more of these types.

[Adzman 2,154]

Garlo was a great pick up. Had a rough year this year but he has showed plenty and has been a terrific player for this club.

[DeeZee 7,445]

Jack viney

[Ron Burgundy 8,587]

Blease over Shuey and Strauss over Zaharakis were sweet selections in 2008.

Demonland would not have got these wrong.

Thank you Barry.

[Max Power 37]

Jack viney

Bit early to evaluate fairly I'd think.