WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - HERITIER LUMUMBA

[robbiefrom13 894]

I had the unfortunate experience of living next to Lumumba early this year. He is not the guy everyone makes him out to be. He frequently woke my family (and everyone else in the apartment block) with aggressive and demeaning abuse of his girlfriend. What made it worst was that this often happened outside the window of my boys bedroom (they are 1 and 3). We were very conflicted and what we should do, we were going to call the police once, but it settled down; another time I went outside (to shut the gate) hoping he would notice that people were always around listening/watching. Not sure how anyone can make a stand about some social issues while being a perpetrator of another.

Have dealt with him in an official capacity and can concur he is a very unlikeable person.

My work mate who knows nothing about football asked a very innocent question "I believe you play football?".

He replied in an extremely smarmy manner "thats ONE of the things I do! "

Cut it out....seriously.

these posts change my view. Don't like the idea of bringing in such a guy.

Funny thing is, I would still give Jurrah another chance. Jurrah's problem never strikes me as ego. I guess the big ego is what I think is the real culture-killer.

[monoccular 17,679]

yes, that's true.

still, if one of your blokes raises issues, you can show respect or rubbish him. Maybe Bucks had had enough and broke the rules in frustration. Hard to tell since we weren't there. But, all the same, even though PC can be a pain at times I know, a boss ought to behave the way a boss is expected to, in this day and age. Gotta respect the guys, if you expect to get the best out of them. if you have to address issues, surely you do it in private?

Heretier is more up-to-date than Bucks, that's how I see it. Should he be getting bullied into acting a redneck too?

Maybe, now that Workcare or Worksafe (or whatever they call themselves this year) are getting actively involved in AFL on the supplements issue, they could have a look at Buckley and Collingwood - work place bullying can incur huge penalties for both the perp and the institution!! Maybe bankrupt them??!! :-)

I had the unfortunate experience of living next to Lumumba early this year. He is not the guy everyone makes him out to be. He frequently woke my family (and everyone else in the apartment block) with aggressive and demeaning abuse of his girlfriend. What made it worst was that this often happened outside the window of my boys bedroom (they are 1 and 3). We were very conflicted and what we should do, we were going to call the police once, but it settled down; another time I went outside (to shut the gate) hoping he would notice that people were always around listening/watching. Not sure how anyone can make a stand about some social issues while being a perpetrator of another.

If that is fact then he is a seriously nasty hypocrite and should be outed publicly -- not someone I would go and watch, or want to fund.

[Ron Burgundy 8,588]

Get Malceski.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

My missus was unfortunately on a red eye flight with the entire Coll team back from WA several years ago. She knows nothing about AFL and said they were like rude, pushy boys who would disobey flight attendants and do whatever they liked. She sat next to H and said he was delightful and got the guys around him to turn their phones off, lower their voices, and generally behave like adults. He was good conversation apparently and well respected by the players.

Sometimes there is another side to the coin.

[Mousey 47]

Sensed Roos was pretty excited about the possibility of this occurring after watching 360.

Like Roos said, i have never seen or heard anything too bad about him. I do know he brings great strengths to a footy field in speed and not being afraid of putting his body on the line.Would be great playing on the wing for a while till others develop the capacity to do so.

Yeah he is different, but who cares! He will get paid to play for this football club and i have no doubts he will bring his all to his job. The rest i could not care less about. If he plays football for the demons, i will support him when he runs out there for us.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,289]

My missus was unfortunately on a red eye flight with the entire Coll team back from WA several years ago. She knows nothing about AFL and said they were like rude, pushy boys who would disobey flight attendants and do whatever they liked. She sat next to H and said he was delightful and got the guys around him to turn their phones off, lower their voices, and generally behave like adults. He was good conversation apparently and well respected by the players.

Sometimes there is another side to the coin.

Credibility is questionable as the 'missus' married you!

[Ethan Tremblay 31,262]

My missus was unfortunately on a red eye flight with the entire Coll team back from WA several years ago. She knows nothing about AFL and said they were like rude, pushy boys who would disobey flight attendants and do whatever they liked. She sat next to H and said he was delightful and got the guys around him to turn their phones off, lower their voices, and generally behave like adults. He was good conversation apparently and well respected by the players.

Sometimes there is another side to the coin.

Hard to tell from one interaction I suppose.

Real life, not movie psychopaths, are very likeable and carismatic people when in public. Behind closed doors they are controlling and manipulating.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I'm all for getting him, he can play footy.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

Hard to tell from one interaction I suppose.

Real life, not movie psychopaths, are very likeable and carismatic people when in public. Behind closed doors they are controlling and manipulating.

Given that you have obviously met him and know him well and are not basing your comment upon media reports, I guess he must surely be controlling and manipulating. Thanks for clearing that up.

[Nasher 33,617]

these posts change my view. Don't like the idea of bringing in such a guy.

Funny thing is, I would still give Jurrah another chance. Jurrah's problem never strikes me as ego. I guess the big ego is what I think is the real culture-killer.

You would reject a guy based on hearsay of shouting at his partner and being rude to people, but would happily take one who has been found guilty of assault once and charged a number of other times. It would be fair to say your standards are a bit inconsistent.

[nutbean 8,838]

I would confidently say that I've played team sports for longer and to a higher level, and therefore been exposed to the things Lumumba rightfully feels uncomfortable and frustrated about.

And I'd also say that like Lumumba, there are things that frustrate and disappoint me hugely in a stereotypical 'blokey' environment... It's a deeply rooted issue and I'd go on to say that I highly doubt the throway line about the mardi gras in isolation would have been the reason he has an issue. It would be a series of repetitive remarks over his career that has culminated in his frustration to such an issue.

Do you find it amusing ( I do ) that posters take exception with stands the Lumumba has taken yet find no problem in saying things like "Fevola is just being a bloke and if he adds to our list I would grab him in heartbeat".

Roos said last night that it was nonsense to suggest that one mardigras line has caused this.

[rpfc 28,950]

Demonland Meme: "We Only Recruit Choir Boys!"

Demonland Meme: "Unlikeable Bloke. Look Elsewhere!"

Demonland Meme: "We Just Need Footy Players!"

Pick a lane, any lane...

[InVINCEable 358]

Split down the middle because he's a good player but also a [censored].

[Ethan Tremblay 31,262]

Given that you have obviously met him and know him well and are not basing your comment upon media reports, I guess he must surely be controlling and manipulating. Thanks for clearing that up.

I've met him several times, and not on a plane.

I wasn't basing my comment on him personally either. Was simply saying people are often completely different people behind closed doors.

Hard to base an opinion from a singular flight.

I'm yet to have an opinion on him.

- Quite ironic considering over in the MC thread you made comment that he isn't ready to come back. Know him personally do you? Or just going from media reports?

Anyway, wouldn't be much of a forum if we couldn't convey an opinion or comment, I respect yours.

Edited September 9, 2014 by Ethan Tremblay

[Guest]

I'm all for getting him, he can play footy.

But will he be a part of our next premiership team? Remember, we aren't aiming for mid-table mediocrity anymore! We are aiming for the flag!

It seems sometimes that being actually able to play the game is a mark against your name wtih the MFC supporter base/Demonland posters.

Edited September 9, 2014 by Colin B. Flaubert

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

But will he be a part of our next premiership team? Remember, we aren't aiming for mid-table mediocrity anymore! We are aiming for the flag!

It seems sometimes that being actually able to play the game is a mark against your name wtih the MFC supporter base/Demonland posters.

He will make Melbourne play better which will increase our chances of winning a premiership.

The odds are the Jesse Hogan won't play in Melbourne's next premiership so we should give up on him too.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,289]

He will make Melbourne play better which will increase our chances of winning a premiership.

The odds are the Jesse Hogan won't play in Melbourne's next premiership so we should give up on him too.

That is a very sobering thought Clint - and it takes a lot to sober me.

[Guest]

He will make Melbourne play better which will increase our chances of winning a premiership.

The odds are the Jesse Hogan won't play in Melbourne's next premiership so we should give up on him too.

Sarcasm was implied in my post, Clint. I was just trying to pull out one of the hackneyed cliches wheeled out here about why we shouldn't pick up a genuine player when one becomes available.

We are comfortable with not letting in HL to the club but Colin Sylvia and his crew of drinking buddies got to stink the joint up for ten years.

[Jarka 767]

Demonland Meme: "We Only Recruit Choir Boys!"

Demonland Meme: "Unlikeable Bloke. Look Elsewhere!"

Demonland Meme: "We Just Need Footy Players!"

Pick a lane, any lane...

It's like watching that scene of Moneyball at the start when they're all sitting around the room discussing potential recruits.

[Guest]

It's like watching that scene of Moneyball at the start when they're all sitting around the room discussing potential recruits.

Wrong sport, Jarka.

Plus this kind of conversation has occurred at Melbourne.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Sarcasm was implied in my post, Clint. I was just trying to pull out one of the hackneyed cliches wheeled out here about why we shouldn't pick up a genuine player when one becomes available.

We are comfortable with not letting in HL to the club but Colin Sylvia and his crew of drinking buddies got to stink the joint up for ten years.

Apologies, straight over my head.

[robbiefrom13 894]

You would reject a guy based on hearsay of shouting at his partner and being rude to people, but would happily take one who has been found guilty of assault once and charged a number of other times. It would be fair to say your standards are a bit inconsistent.

True. I admit it. I'm owning up to my arbitrariness; and I think it's likely a lot of us are likewise applying fairly arbitrary and inconsistent standards. And changing our minds on flimsy grounds.

Good thing it's not up to us.

A mate of mine was manager of ABC TV one time, and he told me the experts used to ring him every day explaining to him all the problems with programming at the ABC. The experts were retired know-alls with nothing better to do. Or, the great Toscanini conducted Mozart and Beethoven in his first tour of the US. At interval some society dame bailed him up and began explaining at length why Beethoven was better than Mozart - "well, that's my opinion anyway," she said. "Madam," the no-longer patient Toscanini is supposed to have said, "your opinion doesn't matter."

Pontificating on recruitment, I began to feel my opinions were a bit all over the place. And that I was not alone.

[Webber 10,628]

True. I admit it. I'm owning up to my arbitrariness; and I think it's likely a lot of us are likewise applying fairly arbitrary and inconsistent standards. And changing our minds on flimsy grounds.

Good thing it's not up to us.

A mate of mine was manager of ABC TV one time, and he told me the experts used to ring him every day explaining to him all the problems with programming at the ABC. The experts were retired know-alls with nothing better to do. Or, the great Toscanini conducted Mozart and Beethoven in his first tour of the US. At interval some society dame bailed him up and began explaining at length why Beethoven was better than Mozart - "well, that's my opinion anyway," she said. "Madam," the no-longer patient Toscanini is supposed to have said, "your opinion doesn't matter."

Pontificating on recruitment, I began to feel my opinions were a bit all over the place. And that I was not alone.

Have had the same thoughts, so it's a club. Mozart definitely edges Beethoven, btw.

[Bay Riffin 1,499]

No thank you. (Spoken in that deliberate way your mum had when you were really in the s*7$.

Lumumba does not cut it for me - has been exposed in a less than very good team as a one trick pony.

Watts has more skill more time and more upside.

Lumumba has so much more going for him then Watts except maybe age. A premiership player who is attacking, usually puts his body on the line and a genuine line breaker, versus a possession collector who is worse on our list in 1 on 1s, a weak tackler and zero ferocity for the contest.

Sorry but watts does not even come close.

[nutbean 8,838]

Have had the same thoughts, so it's a club. Mozart definitely edges Beethoven, btw.

Neither of them hold a candle to Amity Affliction.