Roos sounding like Neeld (The Age)?

[DemonOX 8,818]

Pretty much bang on mate. Always seems to be excuses being made for our PLAYERS. It's always someone else's fault. Seriously time to start playing like men not boys before it's too late for our club. Surely many of them are embarrassed when they watch back on the video of some of their 'contests'. Enough is enough.

They had a stat up on 360 saying we have lost 21 games since 2008 by 75 points I think.

That's basically a whole season.

What a joke.

[Coup Cooper 610]

Ridiculous article.

Ah yes.. But neeld had a forward line.. Roos is waiting for his to get on the park

[Demon Head 299]

Ah yes.. But neeld had a forward line.. Roos is waiting for his to get on the park

Well actually. Neeld recruited Dawes to allow for his plan to have twin towers on his forward line but Clark and Dawes have yet to play together in a game so you could argue he never had a forward line either.

[45HG 1,559]

Well actually. Neeld recruited Dawes to allow for his plan to have twin towers on his forward line but Clark and Dawes have yet to play together in a game so you could argue he never had a forward line either.

And he sacrificed immediate reward to get Hogan.

[tonatopia 278]

Roos has been strangely non-committal to the Demons, looking ahead from the outset to a coaching handover in two or three years. It is hardly awe-inspiring.

Does he really want to be there? And how long will the players cop public flak like that before they too lose faith in their messiah?

very true.

very worrying.

we need committed folk.

[PaulRB 6,426]

I can't see the problem, according to "By the Numbers" on the MFC site, this was our best round 2 result in three years...

So we're on the up and up

[bush demon 2,118]

A good, old fashioned spray will spruce us up for the GWS:

[bush demon 2,118]

Or this, "Healey off, Ellingworth on. Weak as p*$$!"

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

A good, old fashioned spray will spruce us up for the GWS:

Superb Bush!!

Would our blokes burst into tears??

[Guest]

lol... You do realise your talking about Paul Roos yeah?

He isn't considered one of the best coaches in the AFL, because he yells and screams at players.... Im very confident that even if he did give them a bake, It would have been a structured powerful home truth that the players needed to hear... When someone yells at people all the time, it becomes normal and ineffective... When a guy who is normally calm and considered raises their voice in disapproval, the message is usually load and clear...

I guess I was thinking that this is two games in. We will be touched up again, make no bones about it. If he pulls this out of the locker too early, it may not have an effect later. That being said, and here is the key part, Roosy has said he didn't spray the players on 360. I will take his word over Dermott's as he was actually there.

To be honest, everything that needed to be said was said in the presser. If he repeated that in that tone, I think it would have been enough. No need for theatrics.

Why do people keep thinking I believe the players should be 'loved' through this? No damn way! That was disgraceful but I just felt that stunts of years by such as MN's reverse peer assessment and 'not on your life' press conference caused more division than good because they were knee jerk and not thought out. I know Roosy would most likely have thought out any message he sent to the players.

[Tyson_Viney_Toumpas 269]

They had a stat up on 360 saying we have lost 21 games since 2008 by 75 points I think.

That's basically a whole season.

What a joke.

And somehow we didn't qualify for a priority pick!

Melbournes bad run has come at a really awful time with the expansion clubs.

But still, there are a large amount of players that need to be cut.

[Return to Glory 8,448]

Roos, as great as he has been, has to prove that he can markedly improve this team. I believe he can but, in terms of results, he has not so far.

[Yossarian 1,820]

..yeah, but who wouldn't stand on Grant Thomas' face until they heard cracking.. and then start stomping??

Regardless how you feel about the guy, this is disgusting.

[FireInTheBennelly 4,099]

Pretty much bang on mate. Always seems to be excuses being made for our PLAYERS. It's always someone else's fault. Seriously time to start playing like men not boys before it's too late for our club. Surely many of them are embarrassed when they watch back on the video of some of their 'contests'. Enough is enough.

You're onto something here. Each training session this week should be preceded by the whole team sitting down to watch the replay together. If it's hard for us to watch it must be tough for each team member to see every [censored] up by one of their team mates.

[angrydee 842]

Roos, as great as he has been, has to prove that he can markedly improve this team. I believe he can but, in terms of results, he has not so far.

Not in 2 games.

[Gorgoroth 13,136]

In fairness to Dermie he said he was told, and stressed it was hearsay.

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

Roos, as great as he has been, has to prove that he can markedly improve this team. I believe he can but, in terms of results, he has not so far.

He already has, our disposal, contested posessions, tackles, and inside 50's have all improved out of sight, we finally have some sort of structure and plan we are building towards although the forwards being down doesn't help that

[John Crow Batty 8,879]

Caroline Wilson has her say. Though she gives advice rather than sneering criticism.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/time-for-paul-roos-to-commit-and-start-using-the-we-word-at-melbourne-20140331-zqp24.html

[Guest]

Caroline Wilson has her say. Though she gives advice rather than sneering criticism.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/time-for-paul-roos-to-commit-and-start-using-the-we-word-at-melbourne-20140331-zqp24.html

I don't disagree with this.

[P-man 13,366]

Roos was a hell of a lot more measured than Neeld. The tone was one of surprise and determination, rather than shock and anger. The fact both alluded to a change in personnel seems to be the basis of the article. Cheap shot for mine. They are nothing alike.

Caroline Wilson has her say. Though she gives advice rather than sneering criticism.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/time-for-paul-roos-to-commit-and-start-using-the-we-word-at-melbourne-20140331-zqp24.html

One of the better articles she's written about Melbourne.

Edited March 31, 2014 by P-man

[rpfc 28,843]

New boss same as the old boss?

Hardly.

The team remains the same - and its issues. And maybe the puerile references to Neeld can now be moved on from?

Wilson makes a very good point - what is his vision for his own involvement with this club?

It is not a question he has to answer soon, or even this year, but when he decides who is to be his successor (whenever that may be) he has got to also announce in what capacity he is going help that successor once he takes over.

We are going through a transition period to say the least - we are not situated to do a 'Port Adelaide' - there are too many question marks on key players to be able to do what Port did.

Clark, Dawes, Gawn, Frawley, Dunn, and Jamar are in footballing limbo for various reasons.

And while we have some great young talent in Hogan, Viney, and Tyson - there are too many question marks on the list in addition to the 6 above*: Byrnes, McKenzie, Clisby, Blease, Cross, Strauss, Pedersen, Nicholson, Evans, Riley, Tapscott, Spencer, Bail, Jones, Terlich, Jetta, Georgiou and Fitzpatrick.

That is 24 players on the list that are either in limbo for 2014, near the end of their careers, or simply not good enough unless their form changes radically.

I don't believe Port Adelaide had that base before last year.

Roos should have been told that by Jackson coming in but, if not, he better know it now.

*Salem, JKH, Michie, Kent, Toumpas, Hunt, Harmes, King and Barry get a reprieve as they are starting their careers.

[chook fowler 19,675]

For once I agree with Caro. THe gratest boost for the players and fans would be for Roos and Jackson to commit long term.

Hoppefully pride in getting a job done will see this happen.

[daisycutter 29,799]

Roos did make a comment about spilled chest marks. The most obvious culprit was Watts in front of goal. At The Age again. A back page photo of Watts with his eyes closed as he spills it. No doubt bracing for the spoil around the ears in preference to swallowing the ball.

i doubt he was bracing for the spoil as he knew he was metres clear

just lazy (or as some would say "laconic")

[praha 11,240]

"the failure of some players to even break into a chase."

Take particular notice of Frawley, Jones, Watts and Fitzpatrick: these guys did not chase. And apart from Jones, they give up on the chase very early. Frawley could have at least tried to get involved in several contests but simply gave up. Watch the replay. It's very, very obvious. Reminds me of his 186 performance.

[Return to Glory 8,448]

Chip may not have physically left the club but I cannot believe he is invested in its success. Gonsky.