Roos sounding like Neeld (The Age)?

[45HG 1,539]

Must say - I read his comments on the AFL app and immediately had terrible flashbacks.

Of course, there are different circumstances and the like but nevertheless the thought crossed my mind.

I genuinely think he is surprised just how bad this team is.

[Guest]

Fair enough comment by Grant Thomas.

If Roos won't commit,why should Frawley or Scully or any other of the vfl players we have signed up.

I agree with that part Biff.

I don't agree with the 'shifting' the blame bit or sounding like Neeld bit. You need to remember that the club was an amazingly divided place upon his arrival. His actions ended up aggravating those divisions.

[John Crow Batty 8,255]

Will be interesting to see how Roos responds. He is used to have unbroken linear success as a coach. He did go through the dark days of Fitzroy as player so he should know whats its like to be player at a club on the skids. Big challenge for him.

[Gorgoroth 12,321]

From what Derm said on SEN, Roos gave them a good serve after the game. Maybe the anger hadn't subsided by the time he got the presser.

But seriously the skills were so poor I'd be [censored] off too...wait I was.

AFL footballers should be able to hit a target two meters away, and the fact they couldn't...

[Guest]

From what Derm said on SEN, Roos gave them a good serve after the game. Maybe the anger hadn't subsided by the time he got the presser.

But seriously the skills were so poor I'd be [censored] off too...wait I was.

AFL footballers should be able to hit a target two meters away, and the fact they couldn't...

I am a little concerned hearing this. I thought Roos was big on not spraying players directly after the game as that, in his words, is the time relationships can be permanently broken.

[Cheap Seats 3,300]

Clearly didn't watch the game did our boy Cherny

I find it amusing that anyone that watched us v WCE can give a pass mark to any more then a handfull of players

I don't understand soceity these - since when is someone else responsible for someone elses effort or ability

[Sir Why You Little 34,489]

I am a little concerned hearing this. I thought Roos was big on not spraying players directly after the game as that, in his words, is the time relationships can be permanently broken.

Colin that performance deserved an almighty spray. There is nowhere to hide.

If the Captain believes players didn't try then it is open slather in my book

[Guest]

Colin that performance deserved an almighty spray. There is nowhere to hide.

If the Captain believes players didn't try then it is open slather in my book

I think that a few home truths needed to be told but I'm a little more concerned that it was straight after the final siren.

It needed to be said eventually but I think timing was the issue. Roos has always been about clear thinking and I hope that he thought through everything he said.

[Demon Disciple 10,950]

It's about time that the real problem is focussed upon, and with it the responsibility and blame go towards. The playing group. It doesn't matter if you have all the best coaches with an unlimited amount of $$ to spend on development, if the playing group as a whole have the wrong/lazy/ignorant attitude, nothing will improve, the cracks will just be painted over.

This football club needs to become extremely stringent, so much so that even before players' walk in through the door, they know they have to earn every dollar of their contract. These players are getting paid premium dollars, yet they are continually putting in sub-standard performances. Since when is putting in less than 100%, or their absolute best 100% of the time, less than adequate?

If they were in any other industry, they would have been shown the door long ago. I know it's wrong to single out one player, as many are guilty, but i'll use Frawley as an example. He is going to be demanding quite a contract come years end, but does he deserve it? No. He continually chooses when to put in a good game or bad game, or whether he will put in 100% or not.

That simply isn't good enough. This is the highest level in the world where a person can play aussie rules. Nothing less than there absolute best is acceptable! Do they not realise that it's a privilege to play at the highest level? How many people try to get on to an AFL list, and how many actually make it?

[Sir Why You Little 34,489]

I think that a few home truths needed to be told but I'm a little more concerned that it was straight after the final siren.

It needed to be said eventually but I think timing was the issue. Roos has always been about clear thinking and I hope that he thought through everything he said.

i was pretty clear with what was going on after 10 minutes of the first Quarter.

Roos had more than 2 hours to see what was going on.

Enough is enough Colin. The back bone of this list has had the same attitude since 2011.

It's just all too hard.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Roos needs to be with us for 5+ years. end of story.

[Cheap Seats 3,300]

It's about time that the real problem is focussed upon, and with it the responsibility and blame go towards. The playing group. It doesn't matter if you have all the best coaches with an unlimited amount of $$ to spend on development, if the playing group as a whole have the wrong/lazy/ignorant attitude, nothing will improve, the cracks will just be painted over.

This football club needs to become extremely stringent, so much so that even before players' walk in through the door, they know they have to earn every dollar of their contract. These players are getting paid premium dollars, yet they are continually putting in sub-standard performances. Since when is putting in less than 100%, or their absolute best 100% of the time, less than adequate?

If they were in any other industry, they would have been shown the door long ago. I know it's wrong to single out one player, as many are guilty, but i'll use Frawley as an example. He is going to be demanding quite a contract come years end, but does he deserve it? No. He continually chooses when to put in a good game or bad game, or whether he will put in 100% or not.

That simply isn't good enough. This is the highest level in the world where a person can play aussie rules. Nothing less than there absolute best is acceptable! Do they not realise that it's a privilege to play at the highest level? How many people try to get on to an AFL list, and how many actually make it?

I really like this post you've summed up some of my thoughts really well

The problem is from an outside POV it looks like some players think it's just going to happen - they'll be good one day or it's the clubs fault that they're poor players

After 5 or 7 coaches or whatever figure it is over the past 5 years (including the fill ins) it is pretty clear the majority of the blame lays with the players or their ability or their attitutde toweards AFL footy

IF anyone can argue that Roos isn't getting the best out of the players then the MFC is f'd and we might as well fold because we won't win games for years to come. The mistakes players made on the weekend are unacceptable at AFL level and they continually make them over and over again year after year..... dropping marks, missing kicks, fumbling, missing tackles it's a disgrace

Sure they need edcuatoin and guidence but f me there has to be a line drawn and if you can't do the basics you won't play

Edited March 31, 2014 by Unleash Hell

[Guest]

i was pretty clear with what was going on after 10 minutes of the first Quarter.

Roos had more than 2 hours to see what was going on.

Enough is enough Colin. The back bone of this list has had the same attitude since 2011.

It's just all too hard.

I know you will take up the challenge of arguing for the sake of arguing but here goes.

I don't doubt that something needed to be said to the players. However, I DO hope Roos didn't go in there all guns blazing, with his mouth running off before his brain.

It seems also a little strange and a little concerning that Roosy has broken the one rule he has set since he started coaching 'Don't blast players after the final siren.'

[Nasher 33,047]

Fair enough comment by Grant Thomas.

If Roos won't commit,why should Frawley or Scully or any other of the vfl players we have signed up.

I for one think Scully will stay.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Must say - I read his comments on the AFL app and immediately had terrible flashbacks.

Of course, there are different circumstances and the like but nevertheless the thought crossed my mind.

I genuinely think he is surprised just how bad this team is.

I thought the same.

[Sir Why You Little 34,489]

I know you will take up the challenge of arguing for the sake of arguing but here goes.

I don't doubt that something needed to be said to the players. However, I DO hope Roos didn't go in there all guns blazing, with his mouth running off before his brain.

It seems also a little strange and a little concerning that Roosy has broken the one rule he has set since he started coaching 'Don't blast players after the final siren.'

That's is a fair call. But when the Captain says to a news reporter that he didn't believe the team tried then we have a different set of circumstances.

The players have to take full responsibility here.

Party is over.

[John Crow Batty 8,255]

i was pretty clear with what was going on after 10 minutes of the first Quarter.

Roos had more than 2 hours to see what was going on.

Enough is enough Colin. The back bone of this list has had the same attitude since 2011.

It's just all too hard.

That first quarter was as bad a first quarter as I have ever seen from us. A spray is well deserved. I understand players may have past grievances but if they have now found a new grievance I would be very disappointed and what the hell do they want if so? I am also scratching my head as to why it is most of our highly players that seem to have issues for whatever reason.

[Cheap Seats 3,300]

I know you will take up the challenge of arguing for the sake of arguing but here goes.

I don't doubt that something needed to be said to the players. However, I DO hope Roos didn't go in there all guns blazing, with his mouth running off before his brain.

It seems also a little strange and a little concerning that Roosy has broken the one rule he has set since he started coaching 'Don't blast players after the final siren.'

At the end of the day will it make a difference?

How much worse can they play after that spray? Surely you can't accept that performance on the weeked? I know we're starting a long way back but that performance on the weekend from a professional club can not be tolerated as the performance the MFC serves up each week.

[dees189227 10,773]

Roos is on AFL 360 tonight did anyone see what he said?

[Cheap Seats 3,300]

Roos is on AFL 360 tonight did anyone see what he said?

not on for another halfa

Will be interesting

[Sir Why You Little 34,489]

not on for another halfa

Will be interesting

Sure will. We will see how committed he is.

[Tatu 416]

At least Paul Roos now truly knows what he is dealing with... Im more confident that he can identify major issues, now that this capitulation has happen while He was in charge.... Im not sure if he can fix our problems? Who knows? It might be to late?

Paul Roos is one of the best, coaches in Australia.... I think we are good hands... And I'm sure he wont stop until the problems are identify and removed...

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

I'm sure it has been said on here but maybe it's our players who make not just Roos but all of us sound like Neeld after a game.

[DemonOX 8,530]

When it came out of Neelds mouth he sounded like an arrogant turd

When u hear Paul Roos speak it's totally different. He has runs on the board.

Not even in the same class and it's an insult that they compare the two.

[chook fowler 18,243]

Here Here Ox. This is a no story dreamed up by a hack journo with nothing else to say.